2024-05-31 00:21:23
Twelve-year-old McKay Everett disappeared from his Texas home in September 1995. His father Carl returned from an Amway meeting to find the back door ajar and the telephone ringing. On the line, a woman with a raspy voice demanded $500,000. Over the next week, the FBI played a game of cat-and-mouse with the kidnappers, who used inside information to stay one step ahead of the investigation. Ultimately the FBI uncovered a series of crimes that started long before McKay was taken. Most shocking of all was the suspect. McKay had been betrayed by someone he trusted – a pillar of the community hiding a dark secret. But decades later, McKay’s mother, Paulette, still isn’t satisfied with the official story. She doesn’t think everyone involved has been brought to justice. Ransom: Season 1 - Position of Trust is a story of greed and betrayal and how one’s outward appearance can be dangerously deceiving.
In this bonus episode of Ransom, we share more of our interview with the Ransom caller, Irene Flores. Alright, so I'm outside the address where I think Irene Flores lives. I sort of drove in, looped around, and now I'm parked at a church that's a little way down the street. In part because they ended up giving me this very flashy looking rental car, and I don't know, I feel sort of weird about that. And, uh, yeah, hopefully it's the right place, and hopefully no one pulls a gun out on me or something.
It looked like it was kind of a little trailer home complex out here in Pearland, Texas. I guess the main thing that scares me is it had these private property signs.
But, uh, I'm just gonna walk over, knock, and what am I gonna say?
As I walked closer to Flores' trailer home, I realized that the front door faced away from the road and was fenced off. I thought for sure that that was a sign she didn't want visitors. But actually, Flores was quite welcoming. The fence, I learned, was for her dog.
Because of my little dog, we put up that fence.
At first, Flores wasn't sure she wanted to rehash old memories, but she ended up having a lot to say. We started off discussing how she knew Hilton.
I'd known him for years.
And was that, like, did you work with him in the security business?
Yeah, he, in the security business, I used to, uh, he would give me good jobs, right? And, uh, he was a friend. He would say, hey, can you do this, like, cook something, like enchiladas or whatever, or dinner, right? But, uh, that's, I considered him a friend.
Do you remember the first time you met Hilton Crawford?
I, uh, was looking for a job. Oh, God, I can't even remember what year. He worked for security guard services. Or he was, uh, like an area supervisor. He had an area he worked.
And so I went, and I got a job. And that's how I met him.
Like it was, like, answered at an interview or something?
No, I just went, no. I must have gone, maybe through the Yellow Pages, when there were Yellow Pages. And, uh, and I just went there.
Yeah.
And I got hired.
Was he a good boss?
He was a good boss, yes. Oh. Yeah, he would give me some of the top-paying in-house security jobs. I think he just went downhill, you know, after he got into so much debt.
You know, I've heard some people, but it's people that didn't know him that well, you know, kind of describe him as, like, a flashy guy, like he was living the Vegas life out here in Texas.
I think, yeah, that's, yeah. I saw that part of his personality.
When you think back about Hilton Crawford, is there any little memory that pops in your mind or a little story?
No, not really. I just knew he was a good man to me and to my family. He gave my sister a job. A bunch of my family's and friends' jobs. And, you know, he'd call me up and say, hey, I need blah, blah, blah.
And I said, okay, well, let me give a call to some of my friends, see if they need a job.
Yeah.
Same day.
You told that story before about the enchiladas. Is that something where he would just be, like, asking for a favor or would he be, like, making...
Yeah, he said he was going to have, like, a little dinner party at his home.
Was that also sort of a job? Like, would he pay or was it...
No, we just did it. I mean, he did me a lot of favors, so.
Yeah.
So you felt like it was returning a favor. Yeah, it was just, you give and take.
Do you think he enjoyed being that guy? Like, that was part of his identity, being, like, the guy that could...
I think maybe that was part of him. That part of him. Because I think we have different parts to our personality. So you put on one face for people, maybe, like me, another face for people like you, and so on and so forth.
And you're saying, like, everyone, does that, or that was what he was kind of.
I think everybody, you know. I mean, I don't think people want to show everything of themselves, you know, maybe to a wife, maybe not even to a wife. You know, that's the way I think.
Yeah, I guess I kind of wonder, you know, because I never met him. Like, you know, was he a good guy that kind of ended up going down this dark path? Or sometimes I also wonder, you know, was that dark part there the whole time and he tried to hide it? or he tried to, you know, suppress it or...
Looking back, I think he tried to hide it and didn't allow people to know that side of him.
He was at some point in his life where he was so far in debt, he didn't care about.
About anything or anybody or me.
Or his own family, like he's taken out credit cards in his son's name.
In his son's name, yeah. Yeah, that's another thing. I mean, I didn't know anything of this until afterwards.
Yeah.
So, after everything happened, that he was in financial dire straits. Okay. So that's all I know.
And, well, that's it. And then he called me up one day and he said, Irene, I'll give you $25,000.. You know, all you have to do is make this phone call. And he told me about, you know, the wife, the mother. She's involved.
She wants to get away from her husband and she needs, you know, some finance. And I believed him. I mean, he's never lied to me. He gave me a job and he helped me get other people jobs. So, you know, I trusted him.
Yeah. And I trusted everything that he told me. That's all you have to do, just make the phone call.
Did he give you, like, a script of what to say or how to.
He just, yeah, he told me, you know, just say this when you make the phone call. Just say that we've got the boy, and if you want to ever see him again, don't call the law enforcement.
What was, like, the time period between when Hilton told you about the plan and then, kind of, when it happened?
I don't know. Three weeks, a month before anything happened.
And then was there kind of a follow-up call. once he picked, like, the time he was going to do it or something?
I didn't even know what time. No, he didn't tell me any information. All he told me was or schooled me on what to say.
But he had to tell you, like, when, like, what day and what time?
I think he told me that when he told me, he said maybe in a couple of days.
Like a couple of days before. he called you back and said, okay, plan's happening.
Yeah.
And nobody was home. I think I called maybe three times. It was around 11.. And Mr. Everett, he was the one that answered the phone.
Do you remember, when you spoke to Carl on the phone, what his voice was like?
He was angry. Yeah. He was angry. He was angry and demanded that he talk to me. Okay, well, I didn't have any.
Yeah.
So, I said, well, he's not here.
But in your head, you're thinking the wife has the son and they're, or the wife's going to get the son and they're going to.
And they're going to, they're going to reunite and whatever, and she's going to leave. And there was going to be a happy ending. Those were my thoughts.
One of the things I wonder is, like, what, if Paulette had been the one that answered the phone? You know, like, what would you have said to her, like, thinking that she was in on it?
Yeah, I would have said the same thing, because maybe the phone was being recorded or something. I really didn't want to implicate her. Okay. Yeah. But, let's see, if she'd answered the phone, but he was the one that answered the phone.
And I guess, when they got home, they couldn't, McKay was not there. So, they wondered.
Is that something that, like, over the years you've kind of thought about a lot?
Oh, it has never gone out of my mind. Okay. Yeah. If I hadn't known that I was being used and that she didn't know anything about it, I would never have gotten involved, ever. Yeah.
What about when you think back to kind of Hilton and the stuff he was telling you? Was there anything that, in retrospect, you thought, like, oh, like, I kind of ignored that at the time, but, like, that seemed a little weird?
No, because I trusted him. Yeah. But I really didn't give it much thought. I just believed him. I believed him, and I believed what he told me about the lady, that she was involved and that everything was going to be okay.
So, you know, well, he knew these people. I didn't. Yeah. So.
So, in that first call, I think there was, like, the plan to call it in with the details the next morning. Was he going to handle that?
I had no idea.
Yeah.
All I know is just what I'm telling you. I had no idea how that was going to work out or anything.
Did you talk to Hilton after making that phone call? Like, was there some kind of, like, follow-up?
When we were arrested, we were in this, I guess, in an interview or whatever room. He kept telling him that she doesn't know anything, which I didn't know anything, okay? All I knew was what I just told you. That's all he told me, and that was it.
But there wasn't, like, a conversation where he called to, like, make sure that you had made the call or something like that?
I was at work. He called me and told me that the boy was safe in Mississippi, and that was the last time I talked to him.
After a brief break, Irene Flores tells us about the FBI knocking on her door and what she learned from the whole experience.
As a Ransom listener, you know that the world can be a very dangerous and unpredictable place. There are a variety of indoor and outdoor cameras that allow you to have that peace of mind, knowing that you can see everywhere, in and out of your home, wherever you are. It's backed by 24-7 professional monitoring for less than $1 a day, no contracts, and a 60-day money-back guarantee. SimpliSafe was named Best Home Security Systems 2024 by U.S. News & World Report.
Newsweek ranked it Best Customer Service in Home Security. It really gives you that personal peace of mind that everything's okay. And that's why I recommend SimpliSafe Home Security. SimpliSafe has given me and many of my listeners real peace of mind. I want you to have it, too.
Right now, get 20% off any new SimpliSafe system with FastProtect monitoring at simplisafe.
com slash ransom. There's no safe like SimpliSafe.
When the FBI showed up, I guess, what were your first thoughts when they showed up?
To myself, I said, this wasn't supposed to happen. So what the hell did Hilton do? And then I, you know, in my mind, I'm going, well, shoot. I'm going to get arrested because I went through with this. And that's it.
And then I just waited.
And you would have told him then that you had made the call and they were expecting that?
Well, he knew, yeah. I showed him where I made the phone call from. It was a public phone. I was living in northwest Houston at the time, so it was out that way somewhere.
Did your case end up going to court?
We went to court. My lawyers worked out a deal and got 25..
Got 25.
. My charge was reduced to aggravated kidnapping, which I thank God.
Did you know, when you were making that call, that you could get charged for kidnapping? Or did it feel like a more minor thing?
No, I don't think I gave it much thought. No. I didn't think anything of it. Again, it's because I thought they had worked it out together.
Did you feel like the 25 years, did that feel fair to you?
I didn't even question that. I just thank God that I wasn't charged with capital murder.
A lot of good things happened to me.
During all that waiting to go to trial, I had a friend who was suing the Norplant.
I don't know what that is. Norplant?
It's birth control. She got sick after that, so it affected her vision. It affected her health. Anyway, she was the one that got me, the Guerin brothers, to defend me. I didn't have any money.
Out of that settlement that she got, she paid them.
I think that's why I didn't get the capital murder charge.
After this all happened, you talked to Hilton Crawford somewhere in Corg or something like that?
No. No. At that time, after we got sentenced, they weren't allowing us to communicate. He kept on apologizing and apologizing and apologizing. I said, well, hey, I allowed myself to be led, so I can't even blame you because I allowed myself to be led.
You weren't angry at him?
He was more angry at me.
I mean, what good does it do to stay angry?
How was the experience while you were in prison?
It was all right. I didn't mess with nobody. I just kept myself busy, stayed out of trouble, got close to God, did a lot of Bible studies, helped people out. Just do stuff for people that weren't as lucky as me or had a family like me that was supporting me. I didn't get depressed.
You do something, you pay for it. That was my mindset.
I guess if you could go back and talk to yourself.
Hindsight is 20-20.
What would you say with the hindsight?
Well, you go back and you think and you analyze and you just say, maybe I should have just stopped and maybe thought about it some more.
Do you have a sense of why, at that time in your life, you didn't do that?
I think because I'm very family-minded and I want to take care of my children. I said, well, $25,000, I can use that to send one of my kids to college. That's what I thought. Those were my thoughts.
If I remember right, I think maybe you had had a previous conviction for something already.
Same thing.
What do you mean by same thing?
Not the same thing, but again, it was because I wanted to take a shortcut to make some money for my family. A lot of people get away with stuff and I didn't.
What was the earlier case?
It was a cocaine. I didn't have it, but I was a middle person. I knew these people and this person was asking to see if I could help them do a deal. I did. They were talking to the DEA, unknown to them, they didn't know.
I think a lot of people have wondered why did Hilton Cropper do this? I know he was in a lot of debt, but it's still a very extreme thing to do.
True. I don't know, maybe he owed some big people. I don't know. He was pretty desperate.
Some people have wondered if it wasn't just the debts to the credit cards, but if it was loan sharks or something with drugs.
I don't think anything like that came up. I don't know.
I guess the security business at that time, was there an undercurrent of drugs and stuff like that?
With Hilton?
Or just in general, maybe not Hilton specifically, but working those security jobs. If that was the sort of thing people would do to make extra money or something like that.
No. No.
What about with Hilton? Do you ever get that impression?
No.
Like I said, I didn't even know he was in financial trouble. I had no idea.
I still want to get a better sense of him. It sounds like you mainly knew him through work and stuff, but how would you describe him to someone who's never met him before?
He was an involved person. He was, I think, maybe not a community figure, but the little bit I know about him, he was involved with the little kids baseball, not softball. And he was active in that perspective.
And that's it. He was very nice. He was a nice person. And I've known him for freaking years, you know?
I mean, after he had kind of told you that one lie, did you have a distrust for the other stuff? he said?
Yes. I still have trust issues.
I'm not going to take your word for it, no.
Yeah. But just since that incident, it's just been very hard to trust in general.
I didn't trust you. Well, yeah, I mean, that's fair. And I appreciate you talking to me about it. Why do we want to open up that door again?
Yeah, I don't know. I think it's just, it's a very strange story. I think, when I heard the outlines of this story...
It makes you wonder.
Yeah. I guess I was going to say, you know, it's hard to trust people. I mean, is that, do you kind of imagine other people are kind of like Hilton Cropper out there, that that was kind of a wake up call that people will lie right to your face?
Yeah. You know they do.
But that was kind of a.
It was a learning experience. Yeah. You know, and just, I just have trust issues. now. I don't trust very easily.
Yeah.
People can tell you anything, and either you choose to believe them or not.
or visit our website, RansomPodcast.
com. Ransom is researched and written by Ben Kebrick and hosted by me, Art Rascone. Production and sound design by Ben Kebrick, Aaron Mason, and Trent Sell, who also did the mixing. Co-created by Austin Miller. For Podcast One, executive producer Eli Dvorkin.
For Workhouse Media, executive producer Paul Anderson. And for KSL Podcasts, executive producer Cheryl Worsley. Ransom is produced by KSL Podcasts in association with Podcast One and Workhouse Media.
Thanks for listening to this bonus episode of Ransom. We'll be back on Wednesday with a full episode. Be sure to follow Ransom on your favorite podcast app to make sure you don't miss it. And while you're there, please leave a rating and review.
v1.0.0.250215-2_os