Episode 573: The Kidnapping & Murder of Marion Parker (Part 1)

I'm Dan Taberski. In 2011, something strange began to happen at a high school in upstate New York. A mystery illness, bizarre symptoms and spreading fast. What's the answer, and what do you do if they tell you it's all in your head?

Hysterical, a new podcast from Wondery and Pineapple Street Studios, binge all episodes of Hysterical early and ad-free on Wondery Plus. Hey weirdos, I'm Alayna, I'm Ash.

And this is morbid.

Hey, what's up? Hey, I like that. Thanks, you're welcome.

Thank you. How are you? I'm feeling good, I feel like I'm going to bring the mood down a little bit in a little bit. Yeah, always.

Yeah, not always that you bring the mood down, but always that a sad case will. It's true. It's true, you know, I brought my mood down this morning.

What I found my first fucking gray hair. Oh Lord, everybody settle in, can do you...

Uh-huh, I mean, I started going gray at like 18, so yeah, that's horrible, it's horrible, it's just so sad.

Aging, you know, fuck that. It's a beautiful thing. It's also just. I decided to stop dying my hair, and then my hair said, Oh no, no, baby, continue. It said, No, start up again.

Start up again, yeah, just days before her 28th year, I'm saying, that's when it....

I mean, you're lucky you went that far, I know, honestly, it's what it's a question of our family history, yeah.

We all have gray hair. Did you go gray before your sisters? though? I don't know your other sisters, your other sisters.

I don't know other sisters that aren't me. Probably. Yeah, it kind of seems like you did.

Yeah, you know, I'm just an old soul, that's just me, you kind of are, I get that?

I like that I liked your TikTok that you made this morning, that you guys helped me make. Yeah, that was a full Podlab collaboration. Me and Mikey were the creative directors.

It's true you were. We're like, faint on this couch, hold the book like this, drop the book like that.

Yeah, we did a TikTok, we did a TikTok. I'm trying to figure out creative ways to get you all excited about the Butcher game to market the book, since you're the marketing genius.

Yeah, I'm trying to get more creative with it and actually it's kind of fun. So when I heard the sound, which go, check out my Instagram or TikTok to see the video. But when I heard that sound, I love that sound.

Oh, my God, it's the one that's like, These are my ladies. Big Mouth is such a funny show. And it's such a fucking funny sound that I was like, I need something to do to this sound. And I'm like, Wait a minute.

It's perfect. Wait a second, all the different languages of the book, I got, these international book covers, let's go.

What a boss bitch thing to say. I got these international book covers. Wow, wow, just boss bitches, doing boss bitch things. It's a pretty cool thing, but it was fun.

And yeah, you guys got a little sneaky peeky at the podlab, a little bit. yeah, a little bit. You should shout out your handles, probably on both. I'm Elena to the max.

ELENA to the mizzity, mizzity Max. I'm pretty sure. Let's double check that just to make sure it's absolutely correct. The truth, yep.

Elena A-l-a-i-n-a to the max on TikTok. I'm not good at shouting out my things, we know my handles. That's what Zillennials are here for.

Yeah, I think on Instagram, I'm the same same thing. Look at that. Yeah, I try to keep it very simple for myself and for others.

Of course, the bold. Oh my God, I love the cover photo, this is great, all right.

Tonight, I said, Tonight, it is the day. Today's case is going to be a two-padder, a two-padder.

One because it's long. There's a lot of information in it, so I don't want to try to condense it too much and miss some information. Yep, and two, man, oh man, you're so brutal lately.

I know I apologize everybody. What's going on in your psyche? This one's from the 20s, from the 20s.

From the 20s, speaking of ghosts, it'll always happen. Who's excited for that movie?

Marion Parker was a 12-year-old girl. Oh, no, so just know that ahead of time. This crime is shocking, yeah.

Just be forewarned. It is very brutal, it is very shocking, and it's just like the whole story is just at the end of it. You're just going to go, what the fuck, that's all you're going to be able to say, I think.

Okay, yeah.

So let's begin, shall we? Let's now. Frances Marion Parker and her twin sister, Marjorie, were born on October 11th, 1915, in Los Angeles, California. Their parents were Perry and Geraldine Parker. And although they were almost always together, like stuck to each other at the hip, and they definitely preferred each other's company over the company of anyone else. The girls were actually really different in disposition and in personality, which I think is a lot of times the case in twins, yeah.

And I think, just like sisters in general, sometimes now. According to author James Nybor quote, Marjorie was very much a girl who liked girly things. But Marion had a slightly rougher edge. Not afraid to get dirty or get hurt, Marion was what would be considered a tomboy. Now kind of sounds like your twins.

Yeah, it really does now. Although she had many girlfriends, Marion preferred to spend her time outside of school playing with. You know what we would now like, what society would deem to be? Traditionally like more boy oriented toys like trucks, and especially in the 20s, it was very societal, like these are boy toys, these are girl toys.

Like, you know, trucks, trains. Playing football with the boys in the neighborhood. Like she did, she was definitely a tomboy. Yeah, but despite her rough and tumble approach to play, she was also very sensitive. She was shy.

She was a little reserved, she didn't like to be away from home or be away from her parents for very long. Which is very heart wrenching when you consider the fact that she is the one who will be kidnapped and murdered. Oh, no. She had a very close bond with her father, Perry. She would actually often spend afternoons by his side at the First National Trust and Savings Bank, where he worked as an assistant cashier.

So she would just like, hang out with him there, that's so sweet. The girls also had a very close relationship with their brother. They like, adored him. Perry Jr. He was several years older than Marion and Marjorie, but he always made time for them.

Like, it was just a really good family. In many ways. Marion Parker was like most girls of her generation and age, she loved movies, she loved radio plays. Cool.

Which is just like very 20s, yes. She loved to dance to the music on her, to music on her parents phonograph. She loved to make her siblings and parents laugh with jokes and impressions. She was just a typical 12-year-old, cool chick.

Just, you know, they just sound like a very like, for lack of a better way of saying it, like all-american family. Yeah, very wholesome, yeah, just like very tight bonds.

Yeah, seemed to all love each other and take care of each other. Now. Unfortunately, because it was the 20s and she's only 12 years old, these are really the only things that we know about her life. We don't have a whole lot of details other than that. I think it gives a good picture of her family life, her relationships inside of the house, outside of the house.

You know what kind of, what kind of gal she was? It sounds like that, pretty much like mostly would cover it for a 12-year-old like, I think you got a good amount of information of who she was.

Why? Thank you and thank you, Dave. Yes, shout out to you. So, the week of December 15th, 1927, was a hectic one at Mount Vernon Junior High.

You know, the Christmas season is in full swing, the students are all excited about the holiday and the holiday break. The school's Christmas party was just a few days away. And to make matters worse, the school principal, Cora Freeman, was actually out on the 15th. So this left one of the teachers, Mary Holt, in charge of the students coming and going for the day.

Oh, that's a lot of responsibility, especially if you're not used to it, you know, like you're not trained. And it happens to be on a holiday week where it's chaos, yeah, like it's already chaos. According to Nyborg, quote Mrs.

Holt was quite strict about student deportment and even more careful about strangers visiting the building. That's good, but she was very overwhelmed by the dual responsibility she had that day. She was still acting as a teacher and acting as like guarding who was coming and going, so she let her guard down a little bit unintentionally.

Of course, by, you know, there's a lot going on that probably haunted her for the rest of her life. Yes, now. That afternoon, a young man entered the school's front office and walked up to Mrs.

Holt at the reception desk and said he would like to see the Parker girl now. The man was small, average looking, he said. His name was Mr. Cooper, and he said that he worked with Perry Parker at the bank, he said, Mr.

Parker has been in an accident and is calling for his daughter. Just one, there you go, so slightly confused, Mrs Holt said. The Parkers have two daughters and the man said he wants the younger one.

They're twins. In hindsight, that should have been the red flag. Yeah, and to be honest, I'm a little confused here why she didn't catch on to that, yeah.

She lived with the guilt for the rest of her life, of course, but this was negligent big time and I would be fucking furious at this.

Well, obviously, this is way before the days of. Like, who are the three people allowed to pick them up? Exactly? Let me check their sheet, that kind of thing, but oh my God.

And this is why it needs to be. If you to your kids, if you, I will never send someone that you don't know to come get you. Never, ever, ever, never. It will never happen.

No, again, this should have been a pretty big red flag. Because the man seemed not only ignorant to the fact that the Parkers had two daughters, yeah, but also that they were twins, right?

And there wasn't an apparent. Obviously, there's always a quote unquote younger one in twins, but like, let's be real, yeah, he's not being like the one that's three minutes younger, right?

So Mrs Holt said, Do you mean Marion?

Why are you giving him that information? Why? Like, what you're? Of course, he's going to be like, Yeah, what do you think he's going to be like? Oh no, I don't know who Marion is.

He's going to be like, Yeah, of course, yeah, Marion. And he said, Yes, yes, ma'am.

And he said, That's, that's her name, Oh, no. Later, Mary Holt would tell investigators that the man seemed to know Marion and could describe her. And he seemed so confident that it never occurred to her that he could be lying. Why wouldn't you just call like, obviously, again, we know, I'm sure she lived with the guilt forever, but you got to call the parents to say, Hey, was somebody else supposed to pick Marion up today?

And why the whole situation? Like, I'm like, why didn't that rub you? As strange that he's asking for one of his daughters when he's been in an accident? Well, and that's that's part of the thing, too. And it's also like, I know we're supposed to be looking at this and being like. I know she lived with the guilt for the rest of her life. I'm going to say right now, fuck that shit.

This was negligent and it was stupid.

And somebody, a whole family, paid the biggest price you can imagine for it. I think it's fucked up, I think it's fucked up that Mary Holt just handed over this child to this stranger. I think it's fucked up. I do too.

I'd love to be, to be nicer about it, but no, I wouldn't, actually. Well, I'm sure the family would have loved to. Yeah, I'm sure the family felt the same way. It's a mistake, but it's a mistake you can't make.

And that's just the way it is when it sounds like it's a mistake that cost somebody's life, it absolutely was now. Also, what she wasn't realizing is that during their exchange, she was actually feeding him pieces of information. By giving Marion's name away, by saying the Parkers have two daughters.

Yeah, you're just handing this stranger more personal information about this family and these children. And just the fact that you have to say the Parkers have two daughters. Obviously, you're dealing with somebody who's not supposed to be here to pick one of them up exactly. And by giving him these little details and these little pieces, you are allowing this man to come off as more familiar than he actually is.

Yeah, and also, the man said he worked with Perry Parker and knew details about Mr. Parker's employment, which, of course, gave him a little more credibility. But still, Mary Holt never bothered to ask even the most basic questions, like what type of accident happened? Why was he only asking for one of his two daughters?

Or why a coworker was sent to get the little girl instead of a police officer or any other member of the family? Yeah, instead, she just sent for Marion and handed her over to this man. Oh, no, fuck that.

Honestly, that's fucked up, honestly, because why wouldn't her older brother be there? why wouldn't an aunt or an uncle be there, you know?

Mary Holt felt the repercussions from this mistake for the rest of her life. I'm not taking that away, but that's fucked up, I mean, that's fucked up. When I read this, I could not believe that this little girl was handed over to a complete fucking stranger who didn't even do the basic shit to get this little girl.

Because this woman just fed him the information. That's the responsibility that you take on it is, that's the thing in that role.

Like, if you weren't prepared, like, obviously it's hectic. Yeah, sure, but this isn't like.

You're a server and it's a hectic time at the restaurant and you give somebody the wrong dish. You're giving the wrong kid to someone, this is big, like you're handing out someone's baby to someone else, that's a big deal.

Right, oh, it made me so angry reading this, like I was fuming. I'm so stressed out right now because who the fuck is this man? It's going to get really bad.

And I need you. I'm not going to go into detail. We don't know details about, like, what happened during her captivity. Okay, the aftermath is rough, so I just want everyone to know that.

Scammers are best known for living the high life until they're forced to trade it all in for handcuffs and an orange jumpsuit once they're finally caught. I'm Sachi Cole and I'm Sarah Hagee. And we're the host of Scamfluencers, a weekly podcast from Wondery that takes you along the twists and turns of some of the most infamous scams of all time. The impact on victims and what's left once a facade falls away? We've covered stories like a shark tank-certified entrepreneur who left the show with an investment but soon faced mounting bills. An active lawsuit filed by Larry King. And no real product to push.

He then began to prey on vulnerable women, instead selling the idea of a future together while stealing from them behind their backs. To the infamous scams of Real Housewives stars like Teresa Giudice, what should have proven to be a major downfall only seemed to solidify her place in the Real Housewives Hall of Fame. Follow Scamfluencers on the Wondery app, or wherever you get your podcasts. you can listen to Scamfluencers early and ad-free right now on Wondery Plus.

I'm Dan Taberski. In 2011, something strange began to happen at the high school in Leroy, New York. I was like, at my locker and she came up to me and she was like, stuttering, super bad. I'm like, stop around, She's like, I can't.

A mystery illness, bizarre symptoms and spreading fast, like doubling and tripling. And it's all these girls with a diagnosis. The state tried to keep on the down low.

Everybody thought I was holding something back. Well, you were holding something back intentionally. Yeah, yeah, well, yeah, no, it's hysteria, it's all in your head.

It's not physical. Oh my gosh, you're exaggerating. Is this the largest mass hysteria since the Witches of Salem, or is it something else entirely? Something's wrong here?

Something's not right. Leroy was the new dateline, and everyone was trying to solve the murder. A new limited series from Wondery and Pineapple Street Studios. Hysterical Follow Hysterical on the Wondery app, or wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge all episodes of Hysterical early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus.

Now, when Marion appeared in the front office, the man told her the story. Your father's been in an accident. He sent me, I work with him at the bank, and, you know, he asked to see you.

So Marion probably more concerned about her father than her own safety at that moment, because, remember, she has a deep, deep bond with her father. She just left with him willingly. She's 12, you know, like, what is she?

So, as James Nyborg points out, this was the 1920s, also a time when children trusted adults and authority figures with a certain blind faith. Yeah, I mean, you weren't allowed to question adult authority back then. So that's what makes it even more up to the adults in charge to make sure that that child's blind faith is not placed in the wrong adult. Yeah.

So it didn't occur to her that her teacher would hand her off to a stranger without completely verifying this story. She just took it as okay. This must be true. My teacher would never hand me to this man. Or she would never even think that an adult would lie to her about something so serious, like her father being hurt. Why would you think that back then?

Having it be for nefarious purposes. She's 12. Yeah. In fact, if someone had asked one or two clarifying questions that day, even just one or two questions just to get a little more information from this guy. Or taken the time to even call the bank and say, Hey, did an accident happen with Perry Parker? Was someone from your bank sent to pick up one of his children from school?

The story would have a totally different outcome, absolutely, but none of that was done. I just don't understand not trying to one call home or two call the bank. And that's why I don't have sympathy for the other side of this equation.

It's hard to, I just don't, yeah, now, having not sensed anything strange about the incident, neither Mrs. Holt nor Mrs.

Freeman thought to say anything about it to Marjorie. Mrs. Freeman was another worker at the school. Sure. Marjorie waited a long time outside the school for her sister once the day had ended, because they always went home together.

Oh, no, and the girls, you know, they walked home together. And so, when the school was finally locked up for the day. Marjorie ended up heading home without her sister after waiting for her for a long time. Because no one told her what? Yeah, this is all just like a lot of negligence.

Strange information, because I'm also like, I'm sorry, Mrs. Holt and Mrs Freeman. So a man came in and said Perry Parker was in an accident and asked for one of his children.

Barring all the stupidity that happened there, that you just allowed one of the children to go with a stranger. You didn't think to tell her twin sister your father's been in an accident, yeah. And maybe try to call her mother or something and see, like, do you want her to come home? Is somebody else picking her up? You just let her sit outside of school and wait for her sister and not have any fucking clue what happened?

Oh man, this is why I'm like, Yeah, you earned that guilt, because it's like, I don't know what to tell you, that's fucked up, uh-huh.

So she went home, and when she got home, Marjorie explained that Marion hadn't met her outside of school and she didn't know where she'd gone. And at first, the Parkers weren't, like, super concerned, because there had been times when it's the 1920s. Yeah, of course, when she'd gone home with a school friend or stayed late to help a teacher at school.

But it was out of character for her to stay out by herself without telling anyone. That was the thing that bothered them. So Perry called the school, Perry Parker. Uh-huh, and Mary Holt answered.

Okay, and Perry thought it was a little unusual because Mary Holt said, Oh, Mr. Parker, how are you feeling? And he was like, I'm feeling okay, but like it didn't raise any alarm.

He was just like, I'm okay, how are you? But when he asked whether Marion was still at school and Mary, Holt explained that she'd gone home with the man you sent to pick her up. Oh my God, he dropped that pleasant demeanor.

He was pissed, yeah, of course, and alarmed, like he was freaking out. He was exactly how anybody would be.

He was like, What the fuck do you mean? You sent her home with a man? And he said, There has not been an accident. I have not been an accident, no one has been sent to pick up my child.

Oh my God, you can, just like you can barely even imagine the panic running through that man's entire body. I'm angry and upset for him, I can't even imagine angry and upset.

He's feeling that, but also fucking panic, the panic, and he said, In fact, and this is even worse. He said he had been home all day with his wife because it was his wife's 40th birthday. Oh my God, and that's like, why didn't you just call home?

Just call home and they literally would have said, we didn't send anyone to send her. Do not call the police and you deal with the situation, then call the police. This could have ended.

Oh my god. Oh my God. It's their birthday. yeah, their mother's birthday. Oh no, now. Throughout the early decades of the 20th century, kidnapping for ransom was pretty common.

Yeah, like, it was actually a pretty common feature in the press and it was not unheard of. For this kind of thing to happen, like, not this exact thing. But like, for children to go missing and to turn up dead with little or no explanation, it was kind of a thing.

Jesus, because a lot of people were trying to get money and extort people. And just a few years earlier, in Chicago, was Leopold and Loeb. Oh God, they kidnapped and murdered 14-year-old Bobby Franks just for the thrill of it.

None of this was lost on Perry and Geraldine Parker, I'm sure, and they wasted no time calling the police. But before Perry could even finish dialing the number, the doorbell rang, Okay.

So he answers the door. And it was a Western Union messenger with a telegram, and it was addressed to Perry from a sender in Pasadena, the Telegram said. Do positively nothing till you receive special delivery letter. And so they were terrified, of course.

Terrified for Marion's safety. So they did as instructed, and they waited. Yeah, now, oh my God.

The second telegram came a short time later, this time from Alhambra. I hope I said that right, about 10 miles outside Los Angeles, and it said Marion secure.

Use good judgment. Interference with my plans dangerous. And it was signed. George Fox Okay, no one in the family recognized that name.

Nobody knew who that was. But Marjorie told her parents that a day or two earlier, there had been a man driving a gray car alongside the street car she and Marion had been riding in. He had been gesturing for the girls to get off the car and come talk to him. Oh, no.

But they didn't like to be around strangers, so Marion was like, Fuck, no. This story only further supported the Parker's belief that their daughter had been kidnapped and was obviously being held for ransom. Now, not wanting to piss off the kidnapper, Perry and Geraldine didn't call the police that night and waited for further instructions.

They were worried somebody was watching the house. That I can't imagine that predicament because you're fighting internally, I'm sure with yourself. Do I call the police? Is somebody watching me?

If I call the police, are they going to kill her? Yeah, but then every instinct inside of you is probably saying, call the fucking police. I just want help, like, I need help.

Somebody needs to help, like, that's the like, a massive amount of just helplessness and frustration and sadness that would. And what ends up happening, and we'll obviously get to it is things go so awry.

And they go so awry through no fault of Perry's and Geraldine's, and Marion pays for it. And it's like, and they did everything that they were, they did everything they thought they were supposed to. And actually, like, the the police kind of fucked this up and the press fucked it up. No, and these two were doing everything that they could to get their child home safely.

Now they did, they waited further instructions, but then the morning came and they still hadn't received a third telegram. So they finally called and reported the kidnapping. Cause they were like, we can't, we can't just sit around and wait. And that morning, as detectives were sitting with the Parkers in their home to take their statements, that third telegram came.

And it was addressed to PM Parker with a lot more details and instructions. In this one, it said, Use good judgment, you are the loser, do this.

Secure $75 $20 gold certificates U.S. currency $1,500 at once. Keep them on your person, go about your daily business as usual, leave out. Police and detectives, make no public notice.

Keep this affair private, make no search. Fulfilling these terms with the transfer of currency will secure the return of the girl. Failure to comply with these requests means no one will ever see the girl again, except the angels in heaven. Oh God.

The affair must end one way or another. Within three days 72 hours you will receive further notice, but the terms remain the same. It's like, literally making my stomach hurt, yeah.

Now, unlike the previous telegrams, which had only which had included what appeared to be a man's name, this one just was signed. Fate. Oh God, what the fuck?

Yeah, the telegram was accompanied by a note, like another note with it and this one, and this is heartbreaking. It was from her. It was handwritten by Marion.

I'm not going to read the whole thing. You can look it up online. It's gut wrenching. It's literally like addressed to, like, daddy and mother, she wrote. I wish I could come home.

Yeah, of course. And she said, I think I'll die if I have to be like this much longer. Won't someone tell me why this has happened to me? Daddy, please do what this man tells you, or he'll kill me if you don't. And it was just signed.

Marion Parker Oh my god, yeah, now. Upon reading the telegram, the detectives were immediately struck by the small amount of money being demanded by the kidnappers. It didn't sound like a lot.

And the unusual way that they were really insisting it be delivered to them. Adjusted for inflation, now, their demands would be like little over $27,000, which it's not a small amount of money, obviously, but not really a ransom demand for a whole ass child.

No, I would say no, but either way. Investigators agreed to work quietly on the case and allowed Perry to gather the funds and make the exchange. With everyone agreeing not to alert the press or do anything else to jeopardize Marion's safe return. So everybody was like, shut the fuck up, we're all going to work on this quietly.

Do what we got to do. Yeah, so at first it seemed like everyone was doing what they need to do. After giving his statement, Perry went to work and just acted like nothing was wrong because that's what he was told to do. Oh my God.

So this man had to go to work and just deal with people all day. Knowing his child is in the clutches of people who are are going to kill her. And like, just, oh my, oh my God. And after withdrawing the amount of money needed from his account, he went about his day just as he had been instructed to do. Um, but he did remember to write down the serial numbers for the bills so that they could be tracked later. Because, he said, hopefully we can catch them this way.

Meanwhile, detectives spent the day interviewing Marion's friends and the staff at school in the hopes that someone would remember seeing anything out of the ordinary that day. Um, with Mary Holt obviously being the most important witness now. Obviously I know I'm going hard at Mary, which I stand by, but she was fucking devastated. Of course. I mean, it's not, like this woman, a bad mistake.

There was no intent, no intention of ill will or anything, but there was no intention for something like this to happen. She never thought in a million years this was going to happen. Um, and she had a hard time remembering anything because she was just in a state. Um, she said. The man was young.

She said But otherwise, he was kind of unremarkable, like there was, which I understand. Sometimes it's hard to pick out anything. You're like, I don't know, you have brown hair.

I mean, she's probably seen how many adults come pick up their kids, like throughout the whole day. She did say he was about. He appeared to be about 25 to 30 years of age, she could say, like five foot eight inches in height, around 150 pounds. Having a slender build and thin features, he was smooth shaven, medium complexion, dark wavy brown hair. Which I'm like, actually, that's pretty good, that's a lot.

He also looks like a lot of guys I know, especially at the time, and they weren't really able to get a lot. Much more out of her other than that description, because she was so overwhelmed by guilt, the guilt that she actually needed to be sedated. Wow.

So when I say she, she felt she felt the weight of it, she felt the weight of it. It doesn't help, and it doesn't change it, but she felt the weight of it. She's not a bad person, absolutely not.

Bad mistake. I would never forgive her, but that's me, yeah, and I can understand why this family probably wouldn't either.

She struck him with her motor vehicle, she had been under the influence, and then she left him there. In January 2022, local woman Karen Reed was implicated in the mysterious death of her boyfriend, Boston Police Officer John O'Keefe. It was alleged that after an innocent night out for drinks with friends, Karen and John got into a lover's quarrel en route to the next location. What happens next depends on who you ask.

So was it a crime of passion? If you believe the prosecution, it's because the evidence was so compelling. This was clearly an intentional act, and his cause of death was blunt force trauma with hypothermia or a corrupt police cover-up?

If you believe the defense theory, however, this was all a cover-up to prevent one of their own from going down. Everyone had an opinion and after the 10-week trial, the jury could not come to a unanimous decision to end in a mistrial. It's just a confirmation of just how complicated this case is. Law and Crime presents the most in-depth analysis to date of the sensational case in Karen.

You can listen to Karen exclusively with Wondery Plus. join Wondery Plus in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify.

But when Perry returned from work that afternoon, he was surprised to find that the kidnapper still hadn't called. But a few hours later, the phone finally rang, and in a calm, even voice, the man on the other end confirmed that Perry. He said, You got the money? and Perry said, Yes.

And then he said he would call back with instructions in five minutes. Okay, but nearly a half hour passed before he called back again. So he's just toying with games. The kidnapper instructed Perry to get in his car and travel alone a few blocks away.

Then park on Gramercy, where the exchange would be made. Not wanting to risk anything, Perry did exactly as he was told he did not alert authorities. When he got to the location. There didn't appear to be anyone, so he waited.

And he waited, and he waited. Hours went by and this man is waiting with cash for his child. By 11.45pm, no one had come.

So how do you make the decision to leave? That's the thing. So he's like, something went wrong. So he went back home. And that's where he learned that the police had been following him from the moment he left the house. So he said, Oh, no.

What if the kidnappers saw them and he didn't alert them, right, like he did what he was told, right?

And they fucked it up, like, let him go, you'll get him later. I don't know, especially you already have the serial number about it.

Yeah, you know what I mean? It sounds like they were in mocked cars, it sounds like they were pretty, like they were following him. It was pretty obvious. Oh, no.

Things got worse the following morning when Perry learned that the previous day the press had been alerted. Who the fuck alerted the press? I don't know, but now it was on all the fucking front pages, exactly what they told him not to do. All of Los Angeles.

All of them, the Los Angeles record said, hunt kidnappers of girl. Others focused on the fact that Marion had been taken from school without any resistance from the staff. Yeah, which I'm like, you can talk about that later when she's safe.

Yeah, but despite his best efforts to do literally exactly as he had been told by the kidnappers, it seemed like everything had gone fucking wrong. And the Parkers were like, Fuck, the worst is going to happen and we, we didn't do it now. That afternoon, another telegram came to the house.

Oh, no. And this one said, When I asked you over the phone to give me your word of honor as a Christian and honest businessman, you didn't answer why? Because those two closed cars carefully followed your car north on Wilton to 10th and stopped shortly off Wilton and proceeded to circle the block on Gramercy. Had they not done that, it sounds like they would have passed the money and gotten the girl.

It's horrifying. And it was exactly as he had feared they spotted the police car and they had blown the opportunity to get Marion back. And what's even worse is what they wrote next in the Telegram, they said. She was so eager to know that it would only be a short while before she would be free from my terrible torture.

And when you, then you mess the whole damn affair, how do you live like the rest of your life? Yeah, and they said they'll give him one more chance, saying, Pray to God for forgiveness for your mistake last night. And it was signed Fate Fox.

It had another note in Marion's handwriting imploring her father to do as the kidnappers demanded. Which is even worse because he did, yeah, and she was being told that he didn't. She didn't know that he had done everything he was supposed to do, and that it was the police and the press that had fucked it up. And so she wrote, Please don't bring anyone with you today.

And Perry Parker later said he does believe those notes were written by his daughter, or at the very least that, even if they weren't composed by her. Like, she was saying it and somebody was transcribing it, yeah, now. The Parkers waited all afternoon, becoming increasingly frantic as the hours are passing by and no call is coming. And they did, however, receive two additional telegrams during that time.

The first one said, Please recover your senses rather than to kill your child, but so far, you have given me no other alternative. Of course, you want your child, but you'll never get her by notifying the police and causing all this publicity. I feel, however, that you started to the search before you received my warning, so I'm not blaming you for the bad beginning.

Be sensible and use good judgment. You can't deal with a mastermind like a common crook or kidnapper Fox fate. This person is sadistic.

Now, the second Telegram arrived a short time later and seemed to just reiterate the points made by the first one. But a little more dramatic flare was in this one. It said Fox is my name, I'm very sly, you know?

Set no traps. I'll watch for them. Get this straight. Remember that life hangs by a thread. I have a gillette ready and am able to handle the situation.

Oh, my God, and it was signed Fate this is. I'm like, Oh, this is awful. Yeah, I'm having such a visceral reaction to this right now.

Yeah, it really. It's a cautionary tale in about a hundred different ways now. The call finally came later that evening, and Perry was given instructions to travel alone to Manhattan Place and wait in his car. If he failed to do that, Marion would die, and so he did as he was instructed.

He packed up the money, he drove to the destination and a little after 8 p.

M. He saw headlights of another car coming towards him and at first he worried it might be the police. And this whole thing was going to be fucked up again. But then when it pulled up next to him, he saw the driver wearing a hat with a bandana covering the lower part of his face. And he rolled down his window and raised a sawed off shotgun, pointed right at Perry.

And he said, give it to me, and Perry insisted to see his daughter first. So the driver was annoyed and then just gestured to the seat next to him. And he looked, and he said he could see Marion wrapped in a blanket of some sort. Her head was nearly covered by the material.

And later, Perry said that he thought Marion was in some sort of daze, or maybe she had been drugged. The driver said she was sleeping, but Perry was like her eyes are open. And so he was like she was gazing forward on, blinking like she looked out of it. But he said she looked alive, she had color in her cheeks.

Like, she didn't look dead, yeah. Now. Very eager to get his daughter back, Perry reached out the window to pass the money to the kidnapper. The kidnapper grabbed it from him and told him to wait as he checked the contents of the envelope. Once he was satisfied, he put the vehicle in drive and rolled forward slightly and then came to a stop again.

And now that he was in the darkness, like out of any kind of light. He opened the passenger door and something large fell from the car and landed on the curb. Then the car just sped off, so when the car was out of sight, Perry ran out of his car and ran to the bundle. He could see his daughter's face peering from the bundled blanket, and he immediately reached down to pull her into his arms. And then he realized the bundle was surprisingly light.

And so he laid his daughter on the ground and frantically untied the cord on the blanket. And that's when he discovered that Marion's legs were missing and her arms had been severed just below the elbow, she was dead.

Perry's screams were loud enough to be heard by shopkeepers at nearby businesses. This has honestly made me cry. They ran out into the street to find out what was happening. Some of them tried to comfort him. the others went back to call the police.

It was chaos like this man was literally inconsolable. Obviously you don't recover from that. How the fuck do you do that to somebody?

Yeah. George Contreras, the lead detective in the case, arrived a short time later with other investigators and patrol officers. They started cordoning off the scene, and they initiated one of the largest manhunts in the state of California's history. Detective Contreras approached the body and noticed.

Some other things that were highly disturbing. Marion's eyes were open.

When they looked closer, they saw that the killer had used a needle and thread to sew them open to make it appear that she was alive.

Sewed her eyes open, they had also applied makeup to her cheeks to give her that complexion that made her look alive.

Luckily, don't worry now. Marion's remains reached the morgue a little after 9 p...m, and the coroner, Dr. A..F. Wagner, began the autopsy right away.

He was a very experienced pathologist, very experienced coroner. But this one was really hard for him. Because he had lived next door to the Parkers for the previous four years and knew this family very well now, Wagner noted that the remains. At least you know that this doctor is going to be, like most coroners and pathologists, are very gentle and loving with a body. But he knows this girl, so, you know, at least there was somebody who cares about her and knows her doing this. I also think he's been the coroner in other cases that we've.

It sounds very familiar. WAGNER Definitely, it does now. He noted that the remains were incomplete and included only the head, the trunk quote down to an inch above the navel and the upper arms down to the elbow joints. There was a two-inch cut along the left shoulder and the cause of death was determined to be strangulation. I guess. Luckily, there's no other signs of premortem trauma to the body.

So the idea that she was tortured, or anything like that doesn't seem to be true. Okay, I think they were just saying, exactly like physically tortured. Also, Marion's internal organs all appeared to be intact and healthy. She had not been beaten, she had not been hurt in any way physically until what happened. Yeah, and these cuts were made postmortem.

There was, however, a towel with the Bellevue Arms Apartments emblem on it and a piece of a man's shirt stuffed into her abdominal cavity. Interesting. The following day, a man out for a walk in Elysian Park found two bundles of newspaper lying beside the road. And when he opened them, he found what would later be confirmed to be Marion's arms. Her lower arms. The other pieces of her body were discovered a few hours later in a gully nearby. Now, Wagner couldn't say exactly when Marion had died, but later in court, it was established that she had been killed shortly after the first botched exchange, on the night of December 17th.

So him saying I'll give you one more chance was just all bullshit. Yeah, no matter what had happened, they wouldn't have given her back, and it was that she was killed after that botched exchange. So she might have been given back to them alive had the police not followed. Wow, yeah, now. While Wagner performed the autopsy, investigators wasted no time beginning their search for the killer. And this is the part that they do right.

I mean, they really fucked up that beginning, but they go hard. They quickly located the man's car in a parking lot on 9th and Grand Streets, several miles from the scene, according to the parking lot attendant. The driver was a young, dark haired man who said he would be back for the Chrysler Coupe the following day. Detectives would be staked out at the scene throughout the night and into the next day. But no one returned to that vehicle. And he was, in fact, much farther away than anyone would have imagined at this point. The following morning, December 18th, the story of Marion Parker's murder was on the front page of every single newspaper all across California.

Each one were in the twenties, each one was providing grisly details of how, quote? Her lifeless body, horribly mutilated, was left on a Manhattan Street lawn for her father to discover after handing back the ransom. The coverage of the crime was honestly shocking by the standards of any era, and the press printed large portions of the kidnappers. Telegrams gave detailed descriptions of the moments when Perry Parker discovered his daughter's dead body, including graphic descriptions of the mutilation and horror contained within that bundle of little blankets. They even one article wrote falsely quote Death apparently came from chloroform, or loss of blood after a terrific, lashing Jesus with things like this.

It's like, it's already fucking horrible, It's literally the worst it could possibly be. It's already a nightmare. Why are you embellishing but sell your papers?

They're gonna sell anyway, and it's like, that's fake shit, you're just making stuff up. Yeah, where's your fucking integrity? They wrote the horrible torture to which the little one must have been subjected. And also, this was all printed with no verifiable details about the murder, and they had not confirmed anything with investigators. They just made shit up and printed it for that family to read false shit, but conjure up more horrible images of their child's last moments.

It's crazy, like what the press was able to get, I mean, it's crazy what press can get away with, even now. But way back when it was so much worse now. Although residents of California had become kind of accustomed to reading stories about kidnappings, at this point, this came as a big shock. This was a different sort of thing. This was horrifying, so parents across the state were freaking the fuck out.

Many decided to stay home rather than go out anywhere. The next week, school attendance fell dramatically. No one was sending them to school because what the fuck's going to happen, you're just going to give them to a murderer. I don't know how you would be able to send your kids to school.

I don't even know what I would do, I don't know.

But what's most, what's like? Also, a very surprising outcome of this was that the government of Mexico closed the border between the states to prevent the fox from escaping into Mexico. So this was huge. That doesn't happen often. Those who didn't react with fear responded to the case the only other way they knew how. Vigilante Justice.

As soon as Mary Holt's description was published in the papers, men who resembled the killer were targeted for harassment and violence. And, like we said, not great because a lot of guys look like this guy and it got really bad and you can't just go out like trying.

To.

Oh my god, yeah, so it's like, this got really bad, what? yeah?

Now, while the press and public panicked and freaked the fuck out, holy shit. Detective Contreras and the other investigators on the case continued to pursue every single legal action in every piece of evidence they had. In a search of the area around the Parker's home, police found another note that had been inexplicably left in a fire alarm box on the street near the house. Okay, addressed to P..M. Parker and apparently left after the first attempted exchange got botched, the note said. For all the trouble you have caused, Marjorie Parker will be the next victim. Oh my god, nothing can stop the fox. And they they who will try will know the penalty.

If you warn anyone of this second success, it will mean you next try and get me. I am the fox. You will never know the rest of my success. You will miss her at twelve o'clock. Oh my God.

Now, upon further review of this letter at the L.

A.

P.

D Crime Lab, a handwriting analyst, determined that the letter did not match the handwriting in the previous letters, and they deemed it a hoax. Who the fuck would do that? We say it all the time, people are always people, and they always have been peopling. There's always been pieces of absolute shit wow like this.

But I'm never, I'm never. Not shocked. No, as you shouldn't be. What the fuck yeah, this family is? I mean, the way this man found his fucking daughter and then you're gonna threaten his other daughter cause you're fucking bored with your jank ass life.

These are the people who, if they were born in this era, would be on the internet. Telling people they're ugly, and, you know, telling them to kill themselves. On the internet, in social media forums, these are, they are the exact same person and you're on the same level like you, you're just a shithead. So well, LAPD officers fanned out across the city in search of this killer. Others were sent to the Bellevue Arms apartments because of the evidence found within the body.

Officers went room by room looking for anything that could be traced back to the killer, but they really didn't find anything. Meanwhile, police in Las Vegas arrested a man they thought might be the killer and they turned him into the Los Angeles investigators. The suspect was 25 year old, which is right in the age range. Louis Wyatt, who was the son of a Los Angeles doctor and had a history of harassing and assaulting girls, great, according to the initial reports from the press. A spokesperson for the LAPD described Wyatt as being in a position to know intimate details of the Parker family life. And said he was keen minded, well educated and egotistical, particularly in believing that he has a master criminal mind now. Unfortunately, Wyatt's fingerprints didn't match those found on the ransom demands, nor did the serial numbers on his $20 notes match those withdrawn by Parker. So they had to release him now. The first real clue finally came a few days later, after technicians finished processing the car that the killer had abandoned in the lot on the night of the murder.

It was obvious that he had gone to great lengths not to leave any evidence behind, but he forgot to wipe the steering wheel. Wow, yep, the fact that this motherfucker went to great lengths and didn't think to wipe the steering wheel. He at least didn't wipe it clean. Because he left fingerprints behind, and the fingerprints were a match for those left on the Telegram sent to the Parkers. And within a few days, they had been matched to a set of prints contained within a juvenile court record for a forgery case a few years earlier. Those prints belonged to 19 year old William Edward Hickman, 19, who was also a recent resident of the Bellevue Arms apartments. So they already searched his place at that point. Well, he ended up.

He wasn't living there at the time, so for someone so young, William Hickman had a fairly significant criminal record that began in his mid-teens. He had been a star high school athlete in Kansas City, but he turned to crime in his mid-teens when he met fellow student Welby Hunt. And they started shoplifting, committing forgery, all that stuff, and it quickly escalated into armed robbery. Once they'd completed high school. In 1926, Hickman and Hunt left Kansas City for Los Angeles, where Hickman found a job as a messenger at the First National Bank, where Perry Parker worked as a teller.

So he worked at the same place now. While employed there, Hickman forged roughly $400 worth of checks before being arrested. He was given six months probation for that. When his probation ended, he tried to get his job back but was unsuccessful. Obviously, that led investigators to theorize that this man had a grudge against the bank. And he just decided to take it out on Perry. Just randomly.

Perry's a cashier, like, he's a teller, yeah, like he doesn't own the bank, right? But he took it out on him. He's not in charge of this man's job. He had kids, what the fuck, now 19 years old?

Yeah, having discovered the killer's identity at address now, detectives returned to the Bellevue Arms apartments. And they learned that William Hickman had been living under the name Donald Evans, and he had vacated the premises a few days earlier. That's why they didn't find him at first, neighbors confirmed that Donald Evans matched the description provided by Mary Holt, and fingerprints taken from inside the apartment were a match for Hickman. Investigators also discovered in the apartment several razor blades, copies of newspapers reporting the kidnapping and a burned memo that appeared to be a draft of one of the ransom demands. Despite this evidence, captain James Bean of the homicide squad told reporters there's nothing to indicate that Hickman took the Parker girl there.

I would disagree, and I would say there's everything to indicate that. Where do you think he took her now when she was shown a photograph of the teenager? Mary Holt confirmed that it was Hickman who had come into school the day that day and left with Mary and Parker. She thought he was between 25 and 30 19. Perry Parker also remembered who William Hickman was really, and he told detectives quote.

The eerie familiarity of the kidnapper speaking voice now makes sense because he had talked to him on the phone. Oh my god, yeah. And Parker also remembered the incident that led to Hickman being fired, and he remembered that Hickman was denied his job after finishing probation. But he couldn't think of any reason why Hickman would have targeted him or his family, right, he's like.

I didn't have anything to do with it. And he said, I cannot call to mind any words of madness or revenge that passed while I was talking with Hickman. While the motive might have alluded them at the time, Hickman's familiarity with Parker could explain the relatively small ransom demand. He knew he didn't have the money, right. That's why, because they were baffled by that, wanted some money. And I think this was all just to hurt someone. I don't even think the money was the biggest part of it.

I think money was obviously part of it. So do you think they were always going to kill her or no, I don't know. I've started to question it, like with his identity being revealed now. But that's what makes sense about that number now. Because he knew Parker's position at the bank, he wasn't like running the bank. So he knew the family didn't have that much money to speak of, and he would only be able to deliver that much right now. The first real clue to where Hickman was finally came on December 21st. This is going quick, at least.

And but just think of like, normally, this family would be getting ready to spend Christmas. We're coming up on Christmas. And now they're just trying to find the man who murdered their daughter and burying their child. Now. Police in Redlands, California, a town about 60 miles east of Los Angeles, investigated an auto accident. And in that accident, the driver, who was a man matching Hickman's description, fled the scene. The following day, investigators picked up his trail in Seattle. When one of the twenty dollar gold certificates was used at a clothing store in the city, and the shop owner identified Hickman as the customer. After being shown a photograph a few hours later, Hickman was spotted again, this time in Portland, Oregon, where a gas station attendant saw him filling his tank.

By that point, Hickman's photograph was unavoidable, it was everywhere, and as soon as the attendant recognized the driver as Hickman. He reported the sighting to authorities and said the man was headed in the direction of the Columbia River gorge. That's where we're gonna end for part one. You motherfucker, uh, it has a it has an ending that at least has justice being served in some way, shape or form. But we're gonna stop there so that you can, uh, you can take that in, digest that what just happened.

Yeah, cause the rest is going to be very interesting. My, oh my, what a tragic, tragic, tragic case. I lit, I knew, you said right at the top, like it was a murder, kidnapping and a murder. But I still held hope that entire time that somehow the outcome was gonna change. And there's no way to describe this one like, you're like, it's bad and I don't know how else to describe it. It's brutal, it's bad, it's awful, it's heartbreaking, heart-wrenching.

And this poor family? You just want to give Perry a hug, man, I just want to give him a hug and be like you didn't do anything wrong. You just wanna like you wanna set time back and tell that lady, maybe don't release this girl to a fucking 19 year old stranger, homicidal maniac who knows nothing about this family. My God call someone like this 19 year old was able to trick you into giving him, yeah, a child for ransom. I'd be infuriated.

I don't know how you got past that. Oh man, alright. Well, we hope you keep listening. see you for part two. yeah, and we hope you keep it. Weird. Yeah, I don't think I gotta tell you, yeah.

Right now, by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts, Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at Wondery.com Slash Survey.