The Gaza Ceasefire That Wasn't, Putin's Fifth Inauguration, House Speaker Vote?
2024-05-07 00:16:04
NPR's Up First is the news you need to start your day. The three biggest stories of the day, with reporting and analysis from NPR News â in 10 minutes. Available weekdays at 6:30 a.m. ET, with hosts Leila Fadel, Steve Inskeep, Michel Martin and A Martinez. Also available on Saturdays at 9 a.m. ET, with Ayesha Rascoe and Scott Simon. On Sundays, hear a longer exploration behind the headlines with Ayesha Rascoe on "The Sunday Story," available by 8 a.m. ET. Subscribe and listen, then support your local NPR station at donate.npr.org.<br><br><em>Support NPR's reporting by subscribing to Up First+ and unlock sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org/upfirst</em>
People in Gaza celebrated what seemed like a ceasefire, which hasn't happened. Instead, Israel continues operations against Hamas around the city of Rafah.
Are negotiations really over, or is there still hope for a deal?
I'm Steve Inskeep with Michelle Martin and this is up first from NPR News.
Russian President Vladimir Putin takes the oath of office again today. One analyst says his near-total control puts Russia at risk.
It's not that some external enemy or domestic opponents threatening the existence of Putin's regime, but rather Putin himself.
And the House could vote today on another motion to oust a Republican speaker.
Mike Johnson is not capable of that job, he has proven it over and over again.
But he might survive thanks to Democrats. Stay with us, we'll give you the news you need to start your day.
Support for this podcast and the following message come from Wise.
The app that makes managing your money in different currencies easy.
With Wise, you can send and spend money internationally at the mid-market exchange rate.
No guesswork and no hidden fees.
Learn more about how Wise could work for you at Wise.
CoM It's a high-stakes election year, so it's not enough to just follow along, you need to understand what's happening so you are fully informed. Come November. Every weekday on the NPR Politics Podcast, our political reporters break down important stories and backstories from the campaign trail. So you understand why it matters to you, listen to the NPR Politics Podcast wherever you get your podcasts.
On the Ted Radio Hour, MIT psychologist Sherry Turkle, her latest research into the intimate relationships people are having with chatbots. Technologies that say, I care about you, I love you, I'm here for you, take care of me. The pros and Cons of artificial intimacy. That's on the Ted Radio Hour from NPR.
After seven months of war and tens of thousands of deaths, a pause in the fighting in Gaza seemed to be in sight yesterday.
So it seemed, and in the city of Rafah, people celebrated.
They were cheering, honking car horns, setting off firecrackers. Hamas announced it had just agreed to a ceasefire deal. And then Israel said the terms that Hamas claimed to have agreed to were not the terms that Israel put forth on the table. This morning, Israeli tanks are in Rafah and in control of Gaza's border crossing with Egypt.
NPR correspondent Eya Bertrawi has been tracking these developments from Dubai, and she is with us now. Good morning Eya.
Good morning Michelle.
So it has been a whirlwind 24 hours there for people in Rafah. Could you just tell us how we got here?
It really has been, I mean, this actually really began, you could say, Sunday afternoon when Hamas fired rockets from Rafah into Israel, killing four soldiers. And this was in the middle of ongoing ceasefire talks in Cairo now. Israel, which had been planning an attack on Rafah, then dropped flyers and sent messages for people to leave certain parts of Rafah. The order impacts at least 100,000 people.
There were chaotic scenes of people frightened, packing their bags, again displaced for the fourth and fifth time, trying to walk with canes, wheelchairs, whatever they could carry. And just when it looked like Hamas and Israel were all dug in for this major battle in Rafah. Hamas says they're ready to release hostages and accept a truce, something that huge numbers of supporters of Israeli hostages were waiting for.
You know, obviously, you know. For these hostages and for the people of Gaza, the stakes could not be higher. So what do we know about the deal that Hamas agreed to?
So the devil here is really in the details, Michelle, now. This was a version of the deal that Egypt and Qatari mediators had been hammering out with Hamas over the weekend in Cairo, with the C.I.A. director there as well. Now, Hamas leaked a draft of this proposal and basically, it calls for three phases to end the war. Starting with a six-week pause and the release of some Israeli hostages in exchange for, you know, Palestinian prisoners and more aid coming into Gaza. But ultimately, the sticking point has been, and continues to be that Hamas wants a deal that ends the war, and Israel says that would just leave Hamas intact.
So Israel's war cabinet says the current deal doesn't meet its requirements, but they will send negotiators this time around to Cairo. They weren't there over the weekend. And meanwhile, you know, we're seeing these striking images of Israeli tanks in control of Gaza's border crossing just across from Egypt.
What about that? What does Israel's military operation look like in Rafah now? I mean, is this the major assault on the city that the U.S and others had been warning against?
So, Michelle, this really just depends on who you ask, you know? A U.S official told NPR in Washington. This did not appear to be that. But they said the White House has real concerns about this unfolding Israeli operation. Now, the Israeli military says this is a quote precise counterterrorism operation aimed at Hamas infrastructure. They say they killed 20 militants overnight.
But for Palestinians in Rafah, this is what they feared the most, you know? Hundreds have been killed in Rafah in Israeli airstrikes over past weeks. There were intense airstrikes again overnight, striking homes and killing families sheltering there. And aid organizations say this is also a nightmare scenario for them as well. Because the area that Israel told people to evacuate from in Rafah is where Gaza's main crossing with Egypt is now. This is a gateway for people to leave Gaza, but also for aid organizations to have their staff enter and for aid to enter Gaza.
And it is now sealed at a time when people are dying of hunger. So this is why we heard, like the International Rescue Committee, saying, for example, this is as bad as it gets. And there's also the question of where do people in Rafah go, you know? Aid groups on the ground running, field hospitals and aid distributions say the areas people were told to flee to by the Israeli military are uninhabitable and don't have vital services or even shelter. And so I think right now it's just unclear to us how far Israel's military really intends to push into Rafah.
Nermeen Shaikh That is NPR's Eya Bertralli Eya, thank you.
Thanks so much, Michelle.
So, given the war in Ukraine, how would you describe, I guess, what I would call the state of the country as Putin hits this milestone?
Yeah, you know, I think the way I'd put it is that Putin's decision to invade Ukraine has changed everything. Here, you know, from the products Russians buy, to where they can travel, to what they can say and what they can read. The economy, culture, media, education. They all now serve the war effort, which is increasingly framed not as a battle with Ukraine, but with what Putin calls the collective West. And that fight also extends to value systems. You know, Putin presents Russia as a global leader in defending so-called traditional values from Western liberal propaganda of LGBTQ plus rights in particular.
That's in his view. And these days, Russia is a drastically more repressive society. Public space for dissenting views has disappeared completely, enforced by a rash of new laws that criminalize public criticism of the government or the war effort. And so most who disagree with the president are either in exile, jail or silenced out of fear of persecution.
And I think people will remember that Putin's probably best known critic, Alexei Navalny, died in jail just before the election. Does that mean that Putin faces no challenges at all?
Well, you know, Putin's hold over political life here is arguably never been stronger. And yet, the decision to invade Ukraine has upended Putin's reputation for providing stability to Russians following the collapse of the Soviet Union. So instead, we have now tens of thousands of Russians and Ukrainians dead. Relations with the West in tatters. And this wasn't something that the public was clamoring for, at least not outright. And some observers argue this points to the inherent fragility of today's Russia.
There's a powerful president in Vladimir Putin, but no institutions to check him, and I recently spoke with Maxim Samorukov. He's a fellow with the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center who argues that as long as the country is built around the whims of one man, Russia will always remain one potential step away from collapse.
It's not that some external enemy, external opponents or domestic opponents threatening the existence of Putin's regime, but rather Putin himself. Because of his self-defeating decisions, because of his propensity to make moves that create problems for the survival.
Of his system.
Do we have any idea of what Putin's objectives are now, how he's going to use that system in this fifth term?
Well, Putin's vowed to fulfill Moscow's goals in Ukraine. The question is what that might entail, for example, more mobilization or higher taxes. Putin's also promised a slew of social programs, suggesting he thinks that Russia can do it all. Despite the cost of the war and Western sanctions. But Putin's real focus has often been on bigger forces at play. He argues this is a pivotal moment when the world is realigning into a new order, with Russia at the forefront.
And in that sense, some, like Samorukov, the Carnegie analyst, argue Putin healthy, but age 71 is in a race against time. He's a man in a hurry. He's now in the pantheon of longest-serving Russian leaders, certainly in the modern era, at a quarter century and counting. But it would seem he has a lot still to do to achieve his greater mission, which is to reestablish some form of the Russian empire and reverse the outcomes of the Cold War.
That is NPR's Charles Mainz in Moscow, Charles, thank you.
Thank you.
The House of Representatives could vote today on whether to oust the speaker second time that's happened lately.
Last year, then-speaker Kevin McCarthy lost his job in a divided house. Just a few Republicans voted against him, but that was enough because Democrats did not save him. Now, an even more closely divided House votes on Speaker Mike Johnson. Georgia Republican Marjorie Taylor Greene is leading this effort, but this time, Democrats appear ready to help the speaker if he needs it.
NPR Congressional reporter Barbara Sprunt will be following whatever happens and she's on the line. Good morning.
Good morning.
Okay, let's just remember. Under the current rules, any one lawmaker can start this process. Greene is the latest to try it. Why?
Well, this all started because she was angry about the way Johnson handled a set of six appropriations bills for this year. That package passed in the House with more Democratic support than Republican support. And then the same thing happened with the foreign aid package, including money for Ukraine, something that she and others in the conference oppose. She's been raising money off of this effort to potentially oust the speaker. It's been getting lots of attention.
Here she is. Last week, she said House Republicans need a leader who will support Donald Trump's agenda.
Not working for Hakeem Jeffries, not working for Joe Biden, and not going to be twisted and lulled into continuing the disgusting practices of Washington D.
C.
For those who don't follow us every day, Hakeem Jeffries is the House Democratic leader, and of course, he's a factor here, by the way. So how is Speaker Johnson responding to this threat?
Well, leading up to this week, he'd been saying he's not focused on this, he's got a job to do that. The overall effort is bad for Republicans and for the Republican Party. Yesterday, after emerging from a long meeting with Greene and Kentucky Republican Thomas Massey, who's co-sponsoring this motion of Greene's. Johnson said he understands their frustration that the conference isn't advancing more conservative policy.
The reality is, we are working with the smallest majority in U.
S history with a one vote margin. It makes it very difficult for us to, using my football metaphor as I often do, throw touchdown passes on every single play.
He's making a case for what you do in divided government. You don't get everything, you get what you can, and then you go on to the next election. That's what Johnson is saying. So how does the threat to Johnson compare to last year's threat to his predecessor, McCarthy?
Well, the math is a factor. Greene just doesn't have the votes. Top House Democrats have already said they'll support a motion to basically set all of this aside, a motion to table. It would avoid a situation where members stand on the floor and directly cast their votes to remove or keep Johnson. And I've talked to Republican members who are pretty upset with the speaker's choices so far, but they still say that removing him as speaker would be a mistake.
They say it's unproductive, they don't want to relive the chaos of trying to elect another speaker, and of course, it's an election year. They worry it doesn't look good for the party to be mired in this sort of infighting just months before people go to the polls. And not to mention there's no clear successor for Johnson.
Of course, if Democrats do save his job, it sort of boosts Greene's claims that he's operating far too closely with Democrats.
Is Greene going to go through with this if she doesn't have the numbers?
We'll find out later today. Last week, she insisted she was done, waiting and would move ahead this week, but she met with Johnson yesterday for about two hours. When she came out, she gave very brief remarks and basically said, we had a nice chat, long chat. We'll have another one today.
We just had a nice chat with NPR's Barbara Sprunt, Thanks so much.
Thanks for having me.
And finally, today, some universities are changing their commencement plans because of the student protests against the war in Gaza.
At least two universities, Columbia and USC, canceled the main graduation ceremonies, although USC is throwing a party on the football field. Instead, Emory University in Atlanta plans to hold its main commencement ceremony off campus, and some other colleges are adding extra security.
Esa Johnson is about to graduate with a degree in journalism from USC. She also missed her high school graduation in 2020 because of Covid. She says a lot of her classmates are upset. They're kind of just like, you know, I want a normal graduation. I just wish things could be normal on campus.
University of Virginia senior Charlie Burns also did not have a high school graduation in 2020.
So any kind of disruption to my college graduation, especially my grandparents are visiting from Kansas City, that would be a huge bummer.
The schools that have canceled their main commencement plan to focus on smaller ceremonies, where students are able to walk on stage to accept their diplomas.
And that's up first for Tuesday, May 7th. I'm Michelle Martin.
And I'm Steve Inskeep. Consider listening to consider this from NPR News. Eric Adams, the mayor of New York City, blamed outside agitators for protests at Columbia University. That's a term people have used for decades.
But who are the outside agitators, and what purpose does the label serve? Listen to consider this.
Today's episode of Up First was edited by Vincent Nee, Nick Spicer, Kelsey Snell, Ben Adler, Lisa Thompson and Alice Wolfley. It was produced by Ziad Butch, Ben Abrams and Katie Klein. We get engineering support from Phil Edfors, and our technical director is Stacy Abbott. Join us again tomorrow.
How does the brain process memories? Why is AI a solution and a problem for our climate? What is leadership in 2025 and beyond? The TED Radio Hour explores the biggest questions and the most complicated ideas of our time with the world's greatest thinkers. Listen now to the TED Radio Hour from NPR.
Listening to the news can feel like a journey, but the 1A podcast guides you beyond the headlines and cuts through the noise. Listen to 1A, where we celebrate your freedom to listen by getting to the heart of the story together. Only from NPR.
v1.0.0.260408-1-a910ba6_os