2023-10-31 01:57:09
The Ramsey Show believes you can build wealth and take control of your life—no matter what stupid mistakes you've made with money. Join as Dave Ramsey and his team of experts answer your questions on the top problems holding you back. Listen now or ask your question live by calling 888.825.5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET. Learn more at www.ramseysolutions.com
live from the headquarters of Ramsey Solutions. It's the Ramsey Show, where we help people build wealth, do work that they love, and create actual, amazing relationships. Jade Walshaw, Ramsey Personality, is my co-host today. as we answer your questions about your life and your money. Open phones at 888-825-5225..
Ariana is with us in Portland, Oregon, to start off this hour. Hey, Ariana, how are you? Good, how are you? Better than I deserve. What's?
up? I am trying to figure out how I can get my husband on the same page with his out-of-control spending so that we can have an emergency fund to fall on and pay off some of our debts.
that we have. Well, what is his out-of-control spending? What do you mean? My husband spends?
over $1,000 a month just on phone games. Oh, phone games? Like Candy Crush? Yeah, on his iPhone. Oh, wow.
Yes, and I found out, I looked up our statements.
When you say that out loud,
does it sound as crazy to you as it does to me? Yes. This is like illness level.
Last year, he... I'm sorry, you cut out, honey. What'd you say?
Uh-oh. Thousand. You're cutting in and out. He spent what? $14,000 last year.
Yeah, and what's your household income?
Apparently, your phone has not been paid.
I can't... Oh, you're back again. We're losing most of your phone here. Okay, so what is your household income? $83,000..
$83,000, okay. Are you somewhere where you can walk and get a better signal, maybe? Because we're losing you about every third word. All right, $85,000.. How old is your husband?
29.. Okay, all right. I have.
a question. We have a four-year-old daughter. I have a question. It's just what... I'm wondering.
Something tells me this is not the only thing he's overspending on. What else is he spending?
crazy money on?
His car. His, what? His car. His car? Car.
What's that? Yeah. He has a 91.
Volkswagen.
Yeah, okay. Yeah, that just screams money right there. I'm a stay-at-home mom,
and I am the one that pays the bills, and I pinch money wherever I can so that we can get.
those paid. You guys need to see... You need to get some professional help. That's what I'm thinking, too. Yeah, because this is not $100, and he makes $200,000..
It's over a month. I know, I know. It's $14,000 a year, and the money we're spending on the car, too. So there's something... I'm sure you're aware of this, or maybe you haven't heard, but in dealing with our phones, what we are now discovering is that a lot of the things, the games actually have them...
They've carefully designed the games to create a dopamine hit to cause you to come back again and again and again. They've designed these games to be addictive. If you're not aware of that, that's very true, okay? It's also true of, for instance, the way the videos now work on slot machines. They have carefully designed those to be addictive, and so your husband is involved in an addictive behavior loop, because if you just say what he's doing out loud, everyone that hears it except him thinks cray-cray.
Yes. They think he's nuts. I know. Okay, and so this is not a money problem. You have a husband that is addicted problem.
Now, what do you do with that? If your husband was doing cocaine, if your husband was doing pornography, if your husband was doing some other form of addiction, what would you do? Well, you would demand that he get some help, and you would begin to see someone to build language and a narrative, to talk to him in such a way that he starts to understand that he's destroying himself and his family with this.
behavior. Yes, because I feel like at this point I'm talking at him. At this point what? It feels like. I'm talking at him.
Oh, yeah, you are. You're talking to an addict. I just feel like I'm nagging.
He's glazed over. You're talking to him when he's drunk. Yeah. You can't talk to a drunk. Right.
It doesn't make any sense, and so, but what you do need to do is sit down with someone that can give you some language that says, okay, this is terrifying me. I have a baby, and I feel like I am in the house with a cocaine addict. Right. Because you are exhibiting the exact same behaviors as a.
cocaine addict. Yes, and he just spent 700 in the last three days. Yeah. So, it's getting worse. My.
goodness. Yeah. Well, I mean, we've established. he's out of control. We don't need any more.
We don't need any more evidence. That's established. Does he think that there's a problem at all,
or when you bring it up, is he like, no, this is fine. There's no problem here?
He's told me twice that he was going to disconnect the car from his phone, but then
that did not happen. Yeah. Well, I mean, I promise you, I'm not going to get drunk anymore,
but I am hanging out in the bar. Right. Yeah. Right. And we do have a car payment every month, and with what he spent last year, we could have paid off the full balance of what we owe left.
But the car payment is not your problem. The problem is your husband is an addict. Yes. And you need to start treating this situation like your hair is on fire. Okay.
With lots of urgency. And so, are you guys, by chance, in a good church? No, we're not. Who is in his life that can talk to him, that will listen to him?
It's not you. It's definitely not me.
I think that we'd have to hire somebody that doesn't know us because he doesn't have a father.
figure or a mother that he'll listen to. So you need to say, honey, I'm going to marriage counseling because I'm afraid our marriage is going to end, because I'm terrified that I'm married to an addict. You are completely out of control. I'm going to go see a marriage counselor to try to save our marriage. I hope you'll come.
Okay. And set an appointment and go. Okay. Regardless of whether he goes or not, you go without him. Okay.
And have that person start to teach you how to speak to an addict to give you any possibility of getting through the fog of this into his brain. And he remembers that he's a husband and a father more than he is a game player on a freaking iPhone. Right. I don't care how much he works. It doesn't mean you don't.
Just because you work a lot doesn't mean you get to do cocaine.
Sorry, that's not how this works.
I think his phone, I think if I were in her shoes, his phone would suddenly go missing tonight. You think it would just look at you. It's almost like it ended up in the river and no one knows.
how it got there. I have no idea where it is. You know, after I dropped it out of the car doing 95, I have no idea what happened to that phone. Exactly. It's somewhere between one of those mile markers back there.
I know that's right. I have no idea, but he'll have another one by morning if he's not. well. That's true. This is the Ramsey Show.
This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. This is Deloney, and I'm always railing against social media, especially in the summer, because everyone uploads the highlight reels of their perfect bodies and perfect vacations and perfect kids. And I know they're not real. And I also know that I'm blessed beyond my wildest dreams. But I still find myself wishing my life was like other people's.
And, based on the data, I know this is happening to you, too. Comparison is wired into us, but comparison can also become the thief of joy, because we can feel like we're not enough and begin acting and thinking in ways we would never think otherwise. When it all gets to be too much, think about contacting BetterHelp. BetterHelp is 100 percent online therapy staffed with licensed therapists. It's convenient, flexible and suited to fit your schedule.
And, by the way, therapy isn't just for those who've experienced major trauma. It's for all of us who are ready to get out of the comparison spin cycle and find our own peace and joy in the life we're creating. Stop comparing and start focusing with BetterHelp. Visit BetterHelp.com slash Deloney today to get 10 percent off your first month. That's BetterHelp, H-E-L-P dot com, slash Deloney.
Jade Washall, Ramsey Personality is my co-host today. Open phones at 888-825-5225.. Josh is in Indianapolis. Hey, Josh, how are you?
Good, Mr. Ramsey. How are you doing?
Better than I deserve. What's up?
So my wife and I are planning on making a baby soon. And question is, how much money should we have saved up for our future before doing that?
Well, at the very least, I would say if you're on the baby steps, whatever baby step that you're on, I would pause that and then whatever money that you can stack up, stack up as much money as you can. And then, once the baby is born, you can take that money and throw it on whatever baby step.
you're on. What baby step are you on? Well, so we have no debt. I'm 21,, she's 20.. We've been married for almost a year.
now. We have $8,500 in a cash emergency fund. So that's about three months of our fixed expenses. And then, beyond that, we have just about $7,000 in the bank and two paid off used cars.
What's the other $7,000 for? What was that earmarked for?
Well, so we have that sort of earmarked in three different buckets. We have a birthing fund. We are going to have a fully funded birthing fund of about $5,000.. That's the goal.
Is that like your deductible?
So we're planning on doing sort of the at-home birth, which some of it will be covered, not all of it.
So there's that. So we have that bucket. We have a beginning of a Roth IRA.
That's another bucket. And then we have a down payment for a house bucket.
Josh, few humans in the history of mankind are as ready to have a child financially as you are.
Is she even pregnant yet?
No, no. We were thinking we have. So, Dave, we have a plan. I got okayed by both the dads, my dad and her dad. I wanted to see if Uncle Dave would approve of this plan and if you would make any tweaks to it.
I would make some tweaks.
The prerequisites financially was it's a total of $28,000, $15,000 in house and investments.
savings, $5,000 for a birthing fund and then the $8,500 emergency fund.
Let me make some tweaks. Do you mind?
Yeah, go for it.
All right. So she's not pregnant yet. So let's wait until she's pregnant to pause. But you've got money laying around here. So I like the $8,500..
That's your three months. Is she planning on working after the baby is born?
Yeah, she'll have six weeks PTO. We have a grandma and a mom on her side. They're both sort of on our way to work.
Okay. So she does plan on going back to work.
She does. Yeah.
Okay. So you've got the $7,000 here. Whether or not you want to keep that for your home down payment fund, I actually think that's the best place for it. You mentioned that some of it was supposed to go into a Roth IRA.
Yeah. I've been in talks with Smart Investor, Pro people and Edward Jones, interviewing all sorts of people, trying to see who could manage the money the best. The minimum, it seems to be is $5,000 to get it into one of these at least guided account management accounts. So that's kind of the goal there.
So your goal is to say for baby step three, be in baby step four, investing 15% at the same time?
Yeah. Yeah. We're saving for a down payment and would like to start investing. Okay. Sort of.
And then also, how much money, just in general, should we have laying around before putting a kid in this world?
Yeah.
You're good.
Yeah. I think so too. I mean, once she gets pregnant, I like that. you have some of this money set aside for baby step three B and investing. And if you wanted to save up your deductible once she gets pregnant, I'm not mad at that either.
Dustin's in Salt Lake City, Utah. Hi, Dustin. Welcome to the Ramsey Show.
Hi, thanks for having me. Sure. Yeah. So about six years ago, I received some company stock on loan that I would be able to pay off in the previous six years. And it's coming due and I'm a little bit unsure if I should have them take the stock back or if I should pay off the loan.
That's a very unusual transaction. Are you sure you don't have options to buy the stock?
Well, I was given options to buy the stock probably about 11 years ago. And then, at the end of those, it expired in five years. And at the end of the five years, I said, I don't have $30,000, but I'd love to be a member or a part owner of the company at that time.
So you borrowed $30,000 from who?
From the company. Oh.
Oh. Who? You're obviously not the owner of the company. Okay.
Oh, definitely. I mean, can you not sell the stock?
It's privately owned. Yeah. So I can't go out and sell it.
Have you been paying payments or interest on the $30,000??
Yeah. I've been paying about $600 a year.
What happens if you give up the stock to the money you've paid in?
They just take it back.
So you're going to lose money on the transaction?
Yeah. I've gone back and talked to them. They said, well, maybe this and maybe that. Maybe they'll give me stock to the amount of the interest I've paid, but nothing's definite.
at this point. How much has the stock grown since you've borrowed to get it?
It has gone up from $0.66 a stock to $2.20 a share.
Yeah, but you can't do anything with it because it's privately held and it's restricted.
Right.
So it has no value at all to you, except the cash that it creates. Have they been paying you dividends out on it while you were the owner of it, borrowed against?
Nope. No dividends.
Has it paid dividends to the other stockholders?
No. Not that I know of.
Okay. I'm turning it in. Yeah. Here's the situation. You have zero control over this, whether it makes money or doesn't make money.
You can't sell it ever except back to the company. It's a restricted, privately held company. It does not have a public exchange to it. And you have absolutely no control over its value, none whatsoever. So if they want to give me some stock, sure, I'll take that.
I mean, a free gift of anything. I'll just about take, as long as it's moral.
But investing in this, you're a minority shareholder. You have zero power to tell anybody what to do with anything. You're at their mercy, at the mercy of the handful of people that make the decision whether this goes up in value due to the way we run the company and make the decision as to whether there's any dividend distribution or not. And so I don't want to own any of that personally. And I'm certainly not going to pay for the opportunity to sort of own it by borrowing it.
No, I think we'll just let them have it back, man. That's what I would do.
I have a question about this. What did he... Because, based on everything you're saying, this sounds horrible. What did he think he was getting? Because, if he buys it, let's pretend he didn't borrow the money.
Let's just say he bought into it and there's no dividends paying out. There is no... What did he think he was going to get?
Well, the company, they set the stock price. It's not set by the marketplace because there is no marketplace for it.
Right, because it's not publicly...
And so when you own a company that's privately held, you think the company is going to be successful. And so the value of the stock, the stated value, went from 66 cents to $2 or something. So if he had actually owned it and could sell it for the triple, it went up. triple, 30,000 would have become 90,000..
Right, but...
But he has to have a place to sell it and they...
That's my question.
And if you get ready to sell it, you can't sell it on your schedule. You have to sell it on when they're willing to buy it back.
And do...
So they got to give him... They got to be willing to hand him $90,000 to take his ownership portion away from him, which is the stock. So it's just... You don't have any flexibility with this.
Right. And let's say he wanted to leave the company, but he had all this company stock.
They would buy him out. They would buy him out.
So they would have to, at that point, putting up the $90,000..
Because they're not going to let a non-employee be walking around with this privately held stock, in most cases anyway. Yeah. It depends on, I don't know his exact situation, but that's... Most of those things are very... It's tightly, closely held.
That's what they call it. Privately held, closely held. And so what he was hoping was to ride the value up as the value of the... As the company becomes more successful and cash out someday.
Someday.
But the day you don't have control over is the problem. And you don't have control over how much it goes up in value. Because the company could actually grow a lot and the stock price not go up. That could happen. Interesting.
This is the Ramsey Show.
Buying your first home is a big deal and sets the stage for your financial success. So work with a mortgage advisor you trust, not just some random website. Churchill Mortgage is Ramsey trusted because they help you avoid hidden traps and expertly guide you through every step. Learn more at churchillmortgage.com.
This is a paid advertisement. NMLS ID 1591.. NMLSconsumeraccess.org. Equal housing lender. 1749 Mallory Lane, Suite 100..
Brentwood, Tennessee 37027..
Thanks for joining us, America. This is the Ramsey Show. Jade Walshaw, Ramsey Personality, is my co-host today. If you're joining us, live from anywhere in America, you're joining us on Halloween. Boo.
The National Retail Federation, believes Americans will continue spending this holiday season despite inflation. And they have proven it. Halloween alone is expected to reel in $12.2 billion, with the average participant spending $108.24.. This marks a $2 billion jump compared to last year for Halloween. Frightening.
$2 billion. That's frightening. Boo. Americans are expected to spend $4.1 billion on costumes alone.
Wow. Pet costumes have become a recent trend that retailers are capitalizing on. Pet owners are expected to spend around $700 million on dressing up their pets.
I'm, I'm a gal. I just, I can't get my, it's not good. It's a catastrophe. What do you think about?
that?
Guys in the booth, like that one. Catastrophe.
That's why you get the big bucks. Well, here's a.
thing. It says there are countries with lower GDPs than $12.2 billion. So we spend more on Halloween than some countries even spend to just be there. Yeah. Listen, I'm not buying my pet a.
costume. If you want to buy your pet a costume, that's okay. But let me tell you what you shouldn't be doing. Okay. You should not be buying your pet or yourself a costume.
if you're whining about student loan forgiveness. Oh, you should not be buying your pet or yourself a costume. If you've not been generous and given more than that amount away to someone, a human being that's in need, like a hungry child versus your shih tzu with a tutu. I'm glad you said shih tzu. I'm just saying.
Unbelievable. Yeah. I mean, it's okay if you want to dress your pet up, but if your generosity factor is lower than your personal costume combined with your pet costume, you have issues. If you're broke and your kid is taking out a student loan because you don't have any money and they're going to college, but your Labrador retriever, or worse, your golden doodle, is all doodled up, then, I mean, again, the issue is not actually the actual spending. The issue is what you're not doing while you're spending this.
That's right. Yeah. In a country where all we hear about is all this drama about how house prices are so high. You boomers don't understand. You were able to buy a house for $13 and you don't understand.
You're right. We don't understand. while you're dressing up your golden doodle for Halloween. We don't understand. We think you're.
nuts. That's true. Look where I come from, if you had a roll of foil and the old, like a couple of.
toilet paper rolls, you can make a costume. Well, I like a party and I'm pretty much into candy and free candy coming from other people. I like the program. The program is a good program. I like.
the program. But if inflation is your problem, if you're worried about living, paycheck to paycheck.
You can't sit around and whine about wealth inequality when we spent $4.1 billion on costumes. But Americans are, the poor is getting poorer and the rich is getting richer. Oh my God. You know, you just can't have these, both these things coming out of your mouth. It makes you look stupid.
It makes you look as stupid as you are when you do that stuff. So it's okay. Celebrate Halloween. Celebrate Christmas. Celebrate your pets.
Spend money on your pets. I don't care. But then don't tell me that there's hungry children in your neighborhood or within 25 miles of where you're sitting right now. And you haven't done something about feeding them. That's very good.
That's just wrong. I mean, we live in the wealthiest nation the world has ever known in terms of total dollars. And, and we prove it with this, these kinds of numbers. And so I really am not the Grinch. I'm not against Christmas.
And I guess the Grinch was probably for Halloween. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know his stance on the Grinch. I haven't checked the Grinch on Halloween, but it's probably pro Halloween.
But, um, you know, either way, I'm not, I'm not against all this. I don't, I'm not against fun. I like fun. Fun's a good thing. But you shouldn't do it at the expense?
of the things that should be a priority. And you can't do it while you're whining and complaining.
about the world coming to an end because it's so unfair out there while I'm running around chasing.
my own stupid tail. And you certainly shouldn't be putting it on credit cards. Cause I know some of y'all went over to Home Depot and those big giant skeletons that I see in everybody's yard and those tombstones. They're giant. They're amazing, but they're like 500 bucks a pop.
Yeah. My, my grandkids saw that. They, Papa Dave, you got to get one of those. I didn't, but they told me I got to get one. Papa Dave, you didn't get one?
Papa Dave didn't get one. So it's just, it's not that I, you know, I'm not against large skeletons. I'm perfectly good. If you're a large skeleton, you're on my team. I'm just saying I'm, I'm, I'm for you.
I'm for the large skeleton, the, the large skeleton union. We're in good shape. I'm, I support the union, but the, uh, oh, my gosh, y'all. seriously. 12.2 b-b-b-billion.
B-b-b-billion. That's a lot. That's a thousand million. It says it's record spending. Oh, it is record spending in one of the worst economies.
I mean, the economy this time. last year was boomtown compared to right now.
Well, you know what? That's an interesting thing, Dave, because you ever go out to dinner and it's like a Tuesday night and it's not, you can't get in a restaurant. It's totally full. Can't get in a restaurant. I'm like, is this a myth?
Because when I go to Home Depot, people are buying the skeletons. And when I go to dinner, it's packed full in there.
It's the, uh, it's the Walmart measure of the economy. If the economy is horrible, but the Walmart parking lot is full, something's wrong with your measure, you know? So, um, cause you know, Walmart customers are not usually known as the same customer as Nordstrom.
That's true.
So, if the Walmart people are out there spending, uh, that tells you the economy is probably not as bad as somebody saying it is. So I, I think the economy is very slow right now. I think it's very sluggish. We've got these ridiculous high interest rates on, uh, houses right now. Um, so let's, uh, dress up like a kid and have a party.
I guess that's the plan. It's kind of like during, uh, the Fauci pandemic when the, uh, booze sales.
Oh yeah.
Wine and booze sales went through the roof. The liquor stores racked up. I mean, very few people made more during the Fauci pandemic, uh, than the liquor stores, except the Plexiglas people.
Well, it really goes to show that.
The Plexiglas people cashed in now.
People will figure out a way to cope with, whatever it is. Obviously, in COVID, people did wine and beers and things like that.
That's what it is. We traded one mask for another.
Yeah. Oh, whoa.
That's what it is.
That's profound, Dave.
Who knew? So we got used to covering our faces. That's what it is.
That's profound. I like it.
So, you know, so increase of $2 billion in Halloween spending this year. Interesting rent. Interesting discussion. It just, you know, the thing is, all we want you to do on all of these things is think.
I know it's a strain, but put down your phone and think. Think. Because if you in one breath are saying how horrible the world is, and in another breath are spending $800 for a giant skeleton in your front yard, something's off in your little deal right there, baby. You need to think. You need to think this through.
And so taking care of your kids, taking care of your adult responsibilities, and having a party can all happen at the same time. There is not a problem with that. Got no issue with that at all. But you can't just, you can't have it both ways. Not and look intelligent.
I mean, you look foolish when you try to do it both ways. It just, it doesn't play through for you. So consumers will be shopping early for festive decor and other related items. Retailers are prepared with the inventory, to help customers and their families take part in this popular and fun devil worship. I mean, tradition.
You sounded like my parents.
Couldn't resist. Couldn't resist. We made it too easy. It's an underhand pitch. It was.
This is the Ramsey Show.
I've got some good news and some bad news. The good news is that people have started buying life insurance to protect their families at levels not seen since the 1980s. The bad news is many of are still buying crappy cash value type plans. I don't care what you call them. Whole life, universal, variable, adjustable, flexible.
They're nothing but a waste of your money. Don't be confused and let someone sell you a plan that sounds better than it really is. Look, term life is the only way to go. Rates are back to all time lows and the process to apply is easier than ever, with many companies no longer requiring exams. You need to protect your family and use your money for as much smarter things than investing in a ripoff cash value insurance policy.
Go to Zander.com or call 800-356-4282 and just compare pricing. You'll see why these are the only plans I recommend. Take care of your family and do it in a smarter way.
Jade Walsh, our Ramsey personality, is my co-host today. Kyle is in Nashville. Hi, Kyle. Welcome to the Ramsey Show.
Hey, Dave. It's an honor to talk to you. You too, man. What's up? So, I have two questions today.
One is a little bit more straightforward. The other one probably a little bit more complex. So, the short one is I'm 29.. I have a seventh month old baby and I have another baby coming in May. Yay!
Which will be very exciting, yes. But with that, I'm struggling to figure out, given that, and also being an entrepreneur, like, I, feel like I should have more than six months emergency fund save. So, I'm trying to figure out what's the right number there. And I'm kind of feeling like, no matter where I get it to,
I feel like it's not enough. So, I'm curious. What event in your mind could occur or would occur that would require more than six months of your expenses to be covered?
You know, as an entrepreneur, I feel like I'm always thinking worst case scenario. So, there's a big recession or who knows if all of our business goes away.
What is the likelihood you're going to go six months with zero income?
Probably pretty unlikely. Yeah. Because as an entrepreneur, you would like get a job. True. Before that happened, right?
Yes, sir. Or you'd close that business, start another one. I don't know. But I've been an entrepreneur my whole life. I've never gone six months without an income.
I've never gone a month without an income. And I've been through some pretty catastrophic bullcrap, but I still didn't.
go without an income.
What do you do? What's your self-employed work? What do you do? I have a video production firm. Does your business have savings?
It. does. We try to keep three months of runway on hand in cash.
Yeah. Then I think you're good. I think if you have your six months...
How old are you? I am 29..
29, with a seven-month-old and a baby on the way. You know what you are? You're a good dad. That's what you are. No, you're a good dad.
That's why you're thinking about this, because you're concerned about taking care of your babies. That's what's making you think about this. But your math is fine. But the fact that you're worried about this, it doesn't mean your system's broken. All that means is you're a good man.
You just looked around and went, I've got responsibilities and I need to act like it.
So you're good. You're good.
Okay. Awesome. And so with that, if I have extra in my current emergency fund, should I reallocate that towards something else, put it into investments, put it on the mortgage,
or just... It's not going to kill you. What kills you is the concept.
Let's say you had seven months instead of six months and you didn't reallocate it. That's not going to keep you from becoming a millionaire. You understand? But continually adding to that and looking up, there's $107,000 in there because you continually haven't dealt intellectually with this emotional concern. Then yeah, then you've gotten yourself.
over into stupid land at that point, right? Yes. Well, I feel like I am in stupid land, because that's exactly how much I have in my emergency fund right now. $107,000.. I have in a high yield account, but yeah, I'm like...
Hold on. Hold on. Oh, wow. And what planet is? $100,000, six months of your expenses?
It's not... I was shooting for a year and I justified it by saying, hey, well, I'm self-employed. My wife's only working part-time now,
so I should have more than the normal... So on what planet is? 50,000, six months of expenses?
You have $10,000 a month of expenses? Well, that kind of leads me to my next question on whether or not my wife and I need to downsize our house, but... How much is your house payment? House payment is 4,200..
Okay. What's your household... Okay, then 50,000 would be there. Okay.
All right. Yup. And so with that... What do you make a year?
So with bonuses, take home is between like.
300 and... No, honey, you own the company.
What's your taxable income? That's it.
It's what? So my personal take-home pay, combined with my wife, like our take-home after taxes, is 300 to 350 a year.
Way to go. Okay. All right. Then maybe 100 is not too much. If 100 represents six months of expenses and you have 48,000, well, that's annualized.
No, you have 24,000. is your house payment for six months. Yeah. So 50 or 60 grand is probably enough. Yeah.
But the point is you can't keep doing what you're doing and you can't make 100 into 200 and a 300 into 400 in savings and high-yield savings. That doesn't make it smart. High-yield savings isn't even keeping up with inflation. So, I mean, you got Biden inflation at 9%, high-yield savings paying four or five. So you're running backwards on every one of those dollars.
Are you investing at all? I am, yes. I've started doing 15%.
Yeah. Yeah. And you got a house payment. So I'm going to take 40,000 or 30,000 of that. I'm going to decide 60 or 70 as my emergency fund.
Anything beyond that, I'm going to throw it at the house and I'm going to start throwing everything at the house from now on, beyond 15%, following the baby steps exactly. So, yeah, your income was a little skewed, more than I thought. For some reason, I had a more normal income in my head, but you're making a lot of money.
Yeah. He's doing good.
You're doing really good.
He's doing so well. Yeah.
You're doing really good. But, yeah, the point is a tiny bit more or less of something is not what's going to kill you. It's the concept that'll kill you if you extrapolate it and extend it out into oblivion. Caroline is with us in Chicago. Hi, Caroline.
How are you?
Good. Thanks for taking my call.
Sure. What's up?
So, my lease on my car is going to be up in a couple of months.
And I haven't listened to your show a whole lot. You've probably covered this, but
I'm 64.. Right around the same time my lease is up, I will turn 65, go on Medicare.
I'm semi-retired. I have a little business. I run out of my home. So, I'm trying to decide. This is my fourth lease in a row.
What's your net worth?
I'm not sure.
How much do you have in savings?
Investments and savings in retirement?
I've got about $175 in investments.
In cash, I've probably... Hang on. Let me look at my stuff here. I mean, in cash, I have $50,000 to $60,000 in cash.
Do you have any other investments?
Like retirement investments or 401k or Roth IRA or something like that. you're not telling me about yet?
Yeah. I mean, that's part of the $175 I've got.
Okay. So, if we cashed you out, you got $200,000..
My house is paid off.
What's it worth?
$375..
Okay. All right. So, Caroline, let me give you a couple of guidelines, since you're not a normal listener. Okay?
Okay.
A car lease, we call them car fleeces because they're the most expensive way to operate a vehicle. You basically are borrowing the money at an average of 14% interest. 14.2% is the average capitalization on the American car lease. All right? Okay.
And so, if you backed into the actual interest that you're paying, and you can back it out of numbers, if you know how to run the numbers on this, that you're going to find 10% to 20% interest somewhere in. there is what you're paying. The average nationally is 14.2%. So, consumer reports, many other people have documented that the car lease is the most expensive way to operate a vehicle. Never lease a car.
Okay? Rule number two, never invest in a brand new vehicle unless you've got a net worth in excess of a million dollars. And the reason is that new vehicles go down faster in value. You lose more money, and you don't have the money to lose. In your case, you don't have the money to lose.
You're 65 years old. You've got a paid-for home. You got $200,000 to your name. You don't have $2 million to your name. And so, you don't need to turn a $50,000 car into a $10,000 car over the next six years, which is what's going to happen if you're driving one.
So, buy a one- or a two-year-old used car and pay cash for it for the rest of your life. unless you inherit some money or get some money and end up with over a million dollar net worth. Do not buy new cars, folks. You can't afford the loss. And you certainly can't afford to lease them and get fleeced.
It's the most expensive way to operate a vehicle. Drive a one- or a two-year-old car, they're perfectly fine, and pay cash for them. This is the Ramsey Show.
Live from the headquarters of Ramsey Solutions, it's the Ramsey Show, where we help people build wealth, do work that they love, and create actual, amazing relationships. Jade Walsh, our Ramsey personality, is my co-host today. The phone number is 888-825-5225.. Justin is in Houston, Texas. Hi, Justin.
How are you?
Good afternoon, Dave. Good afternoon, Jade. Are y'all doing good today?
We're great. How can we help?
Well, I'm calling today about my cousin, Brandi. When you're an only child, your cousins are like your de facto siblings. My cousin Brandi is only three weeks younger than me. We often joke that we're the closest thing our families have to twins. We grew up very close.
She has two kids right now, a 13-year-old son and a 5-year-old daughter. About two years ago, her son, Brandon, wanted to start making his own money because they live pretty poor. He only makes about $18,000 or $19,000 a year. He wanted some money because he's an Astros fan. He wants to go to games.
He wants to wear a jersey. He wants to work and make his own money. He actually handwrote letters. There's his neighborhood next to the apartment they live in. He went around distributing these handwritten letters.
Hey, I'll mow your lawn for $40.. Give me a call. He started getting calls. He borrowed my lawnmower for a while, started making his own money. He bought his own and even looked up YouTube videos on how to take care of it, how to oil it and take care of the blades.
I'm so proud of him. I'm so proud of him for taking this initiative. Well, a little while later, the money he had in his drawer from working, his mom took it, saying, well, no, what do you mean? I didn't know you had this much money. We got bills to pay.
So much so he started hiding what he was making. About a year ago, he actually had enough saved to buy a riding lawnmower. He bought it from a pawn shop for about $900.. Again, I'm thrilled with him. He's looking at YouTube videos, taking care of it, how to maintain it.
He borrowed my flatbed trailer just so he could keep it at the house. That way, whenever he had a client, I would help him out on the weekends. I would just go there,
hook and book. Mom is going in there and taking his hard-earned $10, $15..
I'm afraid it's worse than that, Jade. How much is he making?
About $40.. It doesn't matter the fact that she's...
About six weeks ago, he came home from school and the mower's gone. She sold it. Saying that, quote, we needed to pay bills. She sold her $500 and then...
So she's making, like you said, $18,000 or $19,000 a year. Is that what you said?
Yes.
What's... Why? Do you know?
He's devastated. She works as a hotel desk clerk, but it's not at a fancy hotel. It's one of these mom-and-pop things. It's only in Houston. At this point, whenever he comes home, his mower's gone.
He's crushed. He's devastated. I go there because I'm that close to them. I care about them. I want to find out what's going on.
All she tells me is that we need to pay bills. I need $500.. Sorry, I had to tell them. She's unapologetic about it. At this point, he's crying right there.
His eyes are like cherries. He's devastated. He just stands up, walks to her and says, I can't be your son because you're not a mother right now. You're a monster and stormed off. He might have thrown in a four-letter word or two, which I'm not to say on radio.
At this point...
You're standing there, witnessing all this, to this lady who's like your sister, and you said what to her.
At this point, I was trying to say, why would you steal from them? What are you doing? She said two things. One, you can't steal from your kid. Everything that is is mine.
I needed to do something. That's what was available. I had to do what I had to do. The second of all was, and I swear, this is a very small defense for her. That is how we were raised.
That's how our moms raised us. That's how our grandmother raised them. Whenever you start working, you pitch in. There's no age requirement. When I got my first job at 15, the first thing my mom wanted to know was, okay, when are you getting paid?
We got this bill to pay. We were taught not to question it. Really, I don't know what to tell them. I don't know what the, quote, Ramsey's solution is on kids working, trying to earn their own money. Should they pitch in, or is the money theirs?
I'm a lost word because I don't have kids myself.
I don't really know what to tell her at this point. I care more about their relationship. I don't think she cares what.
you think. I don't think she does either. I know she doesn't care what I think.
I think she blames.
me for this part, because she thinks I'm just spilling ideas in his head that he doesn't have.
to pitch in, that he gets to keep all the money. What she's saying is, this has been a generational thing. This is the way she's been raised. It's the way you've been raised. Your grandparents have been raised.
It sounds like she thinks that this is right.
Like Dave said, I don't think she cares what you think at all. She thinks that this is the best way to go.
Obviously, I can look at this situation and see many, many things wrong with it. A, she's not earning enough money. It sounds like an able-bodied, healthy woman who could go out and earn more than $18,000 or $19,000 a year. It sounds like she needs to apply herself. She could earn double this next week.
Working 40 hours at Target, she could earn more.
Run over to Walmart. They're paying 20 bucks an hour. It's a lot more than she's making now. She could work 60 hours a week before I take money from my own kid. She has character issues.
You can blame it on your family tree if you want to, but just because misbehavior is part of your family heritage doesn't mean that it's a good.
thing. It doesn't make it okay. If anything, I think it would make you want to do better and do.
differently for your kids. Most of us have something somewhere in our family history that we absolutely don't want repeated down the family tree. That's a character flaw, including stealing from a 13-year-old. Now, if you want to go down the path she's going down philosophically, you can go down that path, but it requires more courage than being a thief. It requires just sitting down with a 13-year-old and go, hey, we don't have much money.
We want you to pitch in. Some of the money you make, you ought to pitch in here in the family. Demand that of him. You could do that, but that's different than stealing out of his underwear drawer or selling his lawnmower when he's not home. That's cowardly.
She did that.
because she knows she's wrong.
I'd probably bring that up. If it were my brother or sister, I'm really trying to put myself in your shoes. If it were my brother or sister and I saw that, I think that I would approach it in that way. Like what Dave said, I'd say, look, if you need help around the family, which, by the way, you shouldn't, but if you did, why can't you be a grown adult and model what a grown adult conversation would be like and say to him, hey, this month is tight. Would you mind helping out?
Or I need you to help out. Or I'm?
going to make you help out. Right. But at least do that to his face instead of just scarfing his stuff up. Number one. But before all that, what would I do if I were in your shoes, Justin?
It sounds like you have a fairly close relationship to her and it sounds like she has, she's off base. And so you need to take her to coffee and say, all right, sis, here's what's going on. You don't make enough money. Your job sucks and you don't work much. You need to work more and you need to get a better job so you don't have to steal from your own kid.
And I'll help you do that. I'll coach you along. Sis, I'll help you get into Financial Peace University. I'll help you get on a budget. I'll help you start acting like an adult.
So you're, as an adult, not dependent upon a 13 year old to quote pay bills. You ought to be ashamed of yourself. Putting your family in that position when you're able, bodied and can make enough to take care of your family instead of scarfing from your family. And so that's me and her having a conversation at coffee. But there's nothing that requires her to do that in the law.
And you can't make people do smart stuff. If you could, I'd have been out of business a long time ago.
Halloween bump music, huh? All right. The booth dudes, ladies and gentlemen, bringing you what's known as production value. Open phones at 888-825-5225.. Laura is with us in West Palm Beach, Florida.
Hey, Laura, what's up?
Hi, I was actually calling because I'm wondering if there's any benefit in taking out a student loan, going back to finish to get my bachelor's degree and increase the money that I'm making, or if that's a poor decision to take on more debt.
I think it's a poor decision to take on more debt. There might be benefit in going back to school and finding a way to pay to go back to school. But I don't think that there would be a benefit in taking out student loans in order to do so.
What's your bachelor's? you're studying?
I was. I took a break and I haven't gone back in years, but it was for communication.
Okay. And how's that going to increase your income?
I mean, most of the jobs that I see are all. they want your bachelor's, and it's been very hard to get a job, which I've managed to do, but I'm not really enjoying it. And it doesn't really pay a whole lot.
That's an absolute mythology. That's just not true. Okay. The idea that you get a generalized degree, like a communications degree, and it automatically qualifies you to make more money is absolutely not true. Okay.
And you know how? I know that I've got a thousand people working in this building in a white collar setting. I've got everything from computer programmers, web designers, creatives, production people. I've got lots of people in the communications field. I can't tell you a single one off the top of my head that I pay money to, I'm their boss, that I know what their degree is.
I don't know if Jade has a degree.
No one has ever asked me for my degree, ever, ever.
Wow. Okay. So what happened was, is somehow they got into an interview and convinced us at Ramsey that they could do the job. And then they got in the building and they actually did the job. The degree was irrelevant.
The knowledge to do the job would be relevant, but the actual degree keeping someone from getting a great paying job, lots of people in this building make an incredible money. And I couldn't tell you a single one of them's degree. Actually, I take that back. I have an on-staff counsel, that is our staff attorney. I do know that he has a law degree.
Yeah. That one I do know. And I actually know where his law degree is from, oddly enough. But I couldn't tell you the other lawyers that we've hired where they went to school. even.
So where you went to school, or the fact that you have a degree in most fields today does not hold you back. What does hold you back is connectivity to the subject at hand. What is it you want to work in? Do you know enough about it? Do you have enough knowledge base?
And connectivity to the people in that building or in that organization that you want to be a part of? that lets you have a chance to go. prove yourself. But this idea that there's some kind of vague veil out there, that only the people with degrees get behind the veil, that's old-fashioned mythology. And the last time that was true was probably 20 years ago.
What's the sort of job that you're trying to get, Laura?
Right now, I mean, I'm a writer. I'm in marketing. But I just feel like, I mean, I make 50k a year now. And I just feel like I'm going to be stuck in that pay range. I don't feel like there's much, unless I hop jobs and then find someone to pay.
Are you any good?
Are you good at what you do? Are you good at it? You are? Yes. Okay.
Are you doing something to?
get better at it?
Yes. What? What are you doing? I'm getting certifications online, actively researching what's new in the industry. To me, that's more valuable.
That's way more valuable.
than going back to school.
Graduates with a degree in communication that come out or a degree in journalism that come out, that want to write, very seldom make 50k out of the gate. Very few of them, first job out, make 50k right now.
Communications degree and journalism degree. just don't pay that much. Journalism is worse.
Right. It's absolutely horrid. I almost wonder.
if the better route for her, it sounds like with what she does, there's probably freelance work that she could do if she wanted to really quickly raise her income. Well, what I would do is also.
start putting some people around you that are better than you are. Yeah, that's true. And start meeting with them and brainstorming and increasing your skill set in writing and marketing. Are you doing copywriting? That's one type of marketing.
Or, you know, writing ad copy or something that, you know, that's a skill, that's a unique skill set that's very valuable. Yeah. Because when you can do that well, it creates an instant ROI for the people you wrote the ad for. And then you go, oh, she's a studly copywriter. I need her writing this.
Or is she writing digital narratives for marketing campaigns? What is it? Because just a content person, today there's so much content out there. Yeah. Oh, yeah.
And good quality content delivered in a way that actually communicates is not a skill set that you get from a four-year communications degree. It's a skill set you get from writing a lot with other high quality, world-class writers, looking over your work and questioning you and measuring the results of your work. And so I'll give you an example. We're editing a book of mine right now. The old Total Money Makeover book sold 10 million copies.
We're working on it. They haven't done a new issue of it in like a decade. We're going to do a new issue in the spring. So we're going through the stupid thing with a fine-tooth comb, looking at every detail and every statistic that's in there. that's outdated.
Right. And some of the examples we have from 15 years ago, the home price examples, are humorous. You know, they're hilarious. So we're going through and changing all that. So I'm not personally doing it.
I read through it this weekend. I read through the work that our writers have done. But the quality of their writing, we could tell by how much correction I sent back. Wow. You know?
Yeah. And so how valuable is that young guy that's doing, Nick is doing that writing and they're pretty dead gun. valuable, because I didn't find a lot wrong with it. His math was excellent. That's excellent.
And his ability to grasp what we were trying to say and saying it better in a new world. Just modernizing it. You know, it was excellent. I mean, there's probably 800 entries in there, or something like that of changes, and I probably didn't touch 100 of them. That's pretty good.
Wow, that is pretty good. You know, I mean, that's exactly what you learn to do. I mean, that's your world. They don't teach you how to do that. That's what I'm saying.
If she were to go back to.
school, what she learns is already going to be outdated. Like she's going to learn more, getting in there, like you said, getting around people who are better than her, analyzing people's work.
that's better than hers. Former writer's coffee group that meets for a Bible study or for a writer's coffee group on Wednesday mornings before work, and y'all sit and judge each other's writing and up each other's game. Yeah. And, you know, like songwriters do it in Nashville all the time. Oh, yeah.
The number of people that write a hit song by themselves is unusual. It's very. Yeah, it's always a group. Almost always. I've got a buddy on a sat down and I had this hook and he added this lyric.
Yeah. And that melody shifted. And I've heard that story from songwriters in Nashville thousands and thousands of times over the years. And it's all there was, was they good, got in a room and made each other better. Yeah.
Or, if she starts freelancing, that'll tell.
her quickly because people aren't afraid to give you that feedback. Or if she's having trouble.
getting work, that would also indicate. Laura, all of this is not to correct you. It is to encourage you. You don't need to spend a dime on a four year degree. I wouldn't.
I would spend a ton of effort in getting better. I agree. All of you out there, the knowledge currency is what's important. Knowledge is the currency that gets you in the door, keeps you in the door and moves you up the ladder. Knowledge.
So how do you? how do you get in the door, move up the ladder? You get more and more knowledge. So you're always adding knowledge. You're always adding tools to your belt.
The rest of your life. If the last time you read a nonfiction book was when you were in school, you're failing. You're destined for mediocrity. Read a nonfiction book, particularly in your area of expertise, for God's sakes. You know, lean in, learn something new, learn something new.
Hey, when I started Ramsey, they hadn't invented the Internet. yet. If I had learned something new, most of you 20 million people wouldn't even be out there right now. You have to learn something new all the time, every day, every week, every year. You got to get better.
You're the answer. Knowledge is the currency, boys and girls, not degrees. This is the Ramsey Show.
Jade Walsh, our Ramsey personality, is my co-host today. The Ramsey Show question of the day is brought to you by Neighborly, your hub for home services. Neighborly is one place that brings together a nationwide family of locally operated providers to help you take care of repairs, routine maintenance, or home improvements. Go to Neighborly.com slash Ramsey today and start.
your search. All right, today's question comes from Addie in Oklahoma. She says, I'm writing because I have a bit of doubt about this situation. My mom wants to be a cosigner for me to be able to buy a property through an FHA loan. since I will be a first-time home buyer.
I will be living in the property, but it will be divided and the other side will be rented. I was pre-approved for $325,000.. My mom and the realtor we are working with are telling me that we have to put offers on properties at full asking price, but I'm concerned about this. I'm 23 years old. I only make $36,000 a year as a medical assistant and currently owe $10,000 on student loans.
Should I wait before I make such a big investment? Yes. Yes, yes, yes. Okay, let's look at some red flags here. Number one, you make $36,000 a year.
That's quite low. It's half of the national average. Yeah, that's quite, quite low. And you're wanting to buy a quarter of a million dollar house, over a quarter million dollar house, $325,000.. The reason you feel nervous and the reason that you feel like you can't breathe, because it's literally like John Delaney would say, it's your body telling you there's something wrong.
And when there's something wrong, don't ignore it. Let's look at what's wrong. And you can see what the problem is here. You understand that the only way that you're getting this loan is your mom would be signing for it. That means if you can't get a loan on your own, it means that all of the loan companies know this is a bad idea.
You can't pay. And the only way that we mitigate some of this risk is we bring on someone who we think might be able to pay when you won't be able to make the payment. And in that case, this would be your mother. And she probably thinks that she's being sweet for saying, oh, I'll sign for you. I want you to have this home.
But it's a horrible idea because you know, and I know, that you're not making a lot of money. You still have debt. And the chances of you not being able to make this payment is high, not to mention there's the renting side about this. It sounds like you are both dependent on a renter to live on the other side in order to make this payment, which again is creating a lot of risk. Yeah, this is a mess,
Addie. Don't do it. This is a mess. And let's add one more element to this. It's okay.
You're going to be a homeowner. Yeah, you're 23.. It's okay. You're going to make it. Okay.
But your mom has been controlling this entire conversation. Yeah. And maybe it's time that you just said, mom, you know, I love you. And I'm just not going to do this right now. And that's going to do a lot of things for you and your mom.
One is she's not going to get to control you with the purchase. She and the realtor are telling you what to do. Do you not hear that? It was very clear in the language that you used. You're being treated like a little girl.
Like your mom's pretty, she may mean well, but she's pretty stinking controlling here. And she loves the fact she needs to co-sign. She loves the fact that you are dependent upon her, because now she gets to tell you what to do even more. So you need to break free of mommy. Mommy needs to be a grownup and Addie needs to be a grownup.
Yeah, because what happened to be separated from mommy? and enjoy mommy as a peer, not as a controlling mother of a 23 year old treating you like, like you're 13.. You're not making a decision in this entire thing. Every one of these decisions are being made by someone else and pushed upon you. You need to stiff arm this back, step back, breathe, get you a nice little apartment and a great life.
And let all those people go do their little lives. And then, when you get ready to buy a house, you'll be in.
a position to buy a house. Yeah. Cause, only, only two scenarios come of this. If she went, if she doesn't make that payment, a, her mom's, lording it over her.
Her mom's, her mom's going to tell her when she can take vacation. Cause she co-signed the loan. I'm telling you, I smell control freak a mile away and I've got a good nose for it. Courtney's in Oklahoma city. Hey Courtney, what's up?
Hey Dave. Hey Jade. How are you guys doing? Better than we deserve. Well, how can we help?
Um, so first of all, Jade, I'm a huge fan. I've seen your debt-free screen about a hundred times. It's fascinating to me. It's awesome. It is awesome.
I am, I am, I've been married for 12 years. Um, my husband and I have three kids. We're have almost a hundred thousand dollars in total debt and we're on baby step two. Um, and when we pay off these small cards, you know, that's, that's great. That's a great morale booster.
I would say it's, it's easy, um, instant satisfaction. And we have some bigger balances that are coming up that I know are not going to have that, that, that instant gratification. Um, so what I'm asking is, how can I keep morale and encouragement with my husband and I in between, as we come into these larger balances that we know are going to take longer and there's not going to be some instant gratification there. Yeah. What are, what are the biggest balances that you have?
We have two $20,000 cards and one $20,000 student loan debt.
Okay. That's not, as, that's not as bad as I thought you were going to say. What's your income?
Uh, we make collectively almost 90, $95,000 a year. And, um, at this point, how much are,
what's your margin going to the debt snowball every month?
We can maybe put an extra 150.. He's working two jobs. I'm working two jobs.
Wait a second. Did you say 150? what? Dollars.
No girl. 95,000?.
You shouldn't have told me that. That's, that's not intense. That's not intense at all. Well, no wonder you're worried about these $20,000 balances, because that's going to take forever.
Forever. Yeah. I think it's, it's, it helps more when they're the smaller cards, because the smaller cards get paid off. Well, yeah. Well, it helps more because you're not paying.
anything on them. Right. I mean, you've got $150 card. It works real good. Pay 150, but it doesn't work real good.
when you got 20,000, you got to put 2000,, not 150..
So he's actually active duty military. He's an officer. We've had about almost our entire marriage in active duty military. Okay. And he's, um, he actually did the green to gold program so that he could become an officer.
He wasn't listed. That obviously comes with more income. Okay. And he gets promoted next week. So that's a significant.
Honey makes 95 now and you're only putting 150.. Why? Where's all your freaking money going?
Debt that I accumulated from my parents. No, you already told us the debt. Okay.
Yeah. How much are you paying? How much are you paying to your parents?
Oh, I'm not. I bet they took things out of my full security number.
Well, why would you pay it? That's called fraud. Correct. You're correct. Why would you pay it?
You don't need to pay that.
File a police report and tell the police, you know, where the criminal is. Oh, I'm not kidding at all. Yeah. Right. Who steals from their own kid?
That's a great question. People that go to jail. That's who it is. Yeah.
What's the amount of that?
That wasn't very much, but probably about 10,000 of that.
Okay. So let's just stop a second. Let me go back. You sidetracked me there with that ridiculous story of your crazy parents.
But the deal is still this, you got $95,000 coming in. That is not all going to $10,000 worth of debt that your parents took out in your name. Where the flip is all your money going?
My car payments and other...
How much is your car payment?
Mine's $700..
Okay. What's the other car payment?
His is $950..
Okay. Sell the stupid cars.
Today, those are completely asinine. Who has $1,800 worth of car payments and calls? with the financial trouble? I mean, you sell your cars.
Do you see how much quicker you would pay off your debt if you had that extra $1,700 freed up, $1,650 freed up?
You are car poor.
Have you got a Ford tattoo on your forehead? Do they own you? You should get one. They own you.
Wow.
And a Chevrolet tattoo on the other arm or whatever it is. Oh my God. $900 and $700.. We found your problem, Courtney. My goodness.
It is cars. You guys got car disease.
They sure do. Austin, we make sure they get every dollar.
You need to amputate the Tahoe. Amputate the Tahoe. Shoot. This is our empty share.
Listen, tickets for the Live Like No One Else cruise are selling fast. This is the ultimate debt-free vacation, and I can't wait to celebrate with all the folks who've worked their butts off and changed their family trees. We will be sailing through the blue waters of the Caribbean with the Ramsey personalities and other special guests. A bunch of cabin options are already sold out, so hurry and reserve yours with a $600 deposit today at RamseySolutions.com slash events.
Jade Walsh, our Ramsey personality, is my co-host today. Donnie is in St. Louis. Hi, Donnie. Welcome to the Ramsey Show.
Hi, guys. I'm privileged to talk to you guys. Sorry, I'm a little nervous.
I'll give you the rundown here, just in case you need all this information. I'm going to be 47 next month. My wife and I recently married. We've been together for three years. We each have three kids from a previous marriage, so six kids total.
We are both debt-free. We are a fully funded emergency fund.
Well done.
Right now, I'm only contributing the bare minimum, 6% of my retirement to get the match, because we want to save for our house. The house we're living in is from her previous marriage, and it has more problems than you could shake a stick at. It's probably going to be one of those as-is, to cut that short.
When the kids are growing on. in eight years, we want to move, get a house. that's ours.
Why don't you move before then? Why don't you move now?
Well, because we don't know if we would stay in Illinois or if we would go to Missouri. It just kind of depends. We have relatives that may or may not be here at that time also.
I know, but why would you stay in a house you hate for eight years?
We don't hate this house. We don't hate it.
It's got more problems than you can shake a stick at. I thought I heard some guy say that.
Yeah.
If you sold it, would it bring anything, or it would just be a break-even?
Still low on it. Still low, about 70 on it.
What would it bring, as-is right now?
As-not right now, it might just break-even.
Okay, so you would get out of it and then you would... So if you saved up a down payment in the next year or so, I would move. I don't want to stay in a place that's not fun for eight years.
Oh, not for eight years. No, I don't want to do that. Move into something that's fun, even if it's just around the corner and it's just not broken.
I agree.
Well, I mean, there's things that need to be updated on it, like the electrical and the plumbing.
I thought you were going to sell it as-is.
Well, that's what I'm saying is wrong with it. It's livable. It's not like we don't hate it, like we want to get out tomorrow if we could.
Okay. How can we help you?
Which is we'd like to move in. My question is, the reason I put all that in there, so I just started saving for retirement last year because both of us were in previous relationships that you had the other spouse, you were dragging along trying to do the daytime and I didn't want to do it kind of thing. Luckily, we both found each other and we're both on board with Dave's plan. So, the root of my question is, for saving for our house, I know you've said if you are going to be saving for more than five years or more to do an S&P 500, and I didn't know if I should, that's the case because of how bad the market was this past year.
The market was not bad the past year. Since January 1, the S&P would have made you 9.5%.
Right.
That's not bad.
I mean, my retirement has been bad this past year. I'm like down 7%.
I don't know what you're invested in.
Compared to, well, it's on fidelity and it's also the top as far as life average return and 10 years average return percentages for small, mid, international, and large cap at 25%.
I don't know what your mix is that caused you to lose money in this calendar year. You shouldn't have lost money in this calendar year. You should have made money. Now, you've lost money since July.
It's gone down. The market's down since July, but since January 1, it's up 9.5%.
Okay. It was about even all year until the last couple of months.
Yeah, the last couple of months are horrible. Yeah.
In the last couple of months, it went down. Yeah.
But yeah, that's the only thing I've personally been able to see. And I see it every week because I constantly, I get paid weekly. So I keep track of what I contribute versus how much it's worth.
But my point is that you're making a statement about, an absolute statement about the market that is absolutely incorrect because of the way you're watching it. And so, based on that, you were getting ready to do the wrong thing. Now, if you want to leave the money alone for three or four years, the S&P will be fine. If you'd left it alone since January 1 to now, you would have made almost 10% on your money, even though since July, the market is down. And so I've got money parked in an S&P, but I can afford the up and the down.
Even if you lost some money, it's not the end of the world in your whole scenario here. So if you want to use the S&P, as long as you can handle it, that's fine. But the way your brain's working on the market, I'm not sure you should do it.
You should just put it in a high yield savings account. And I want to call out, if you are planning to have this money or save for the next five or whatever years, if you're planning to do your plan, I would not stay at 6% on your investing for that long, by the way. At some point, maybe after year two, I'd kick it up to 15% and save up for your down payment a little slower, because I don't want you only doing 6% for the next five to eight years.
And, by the way, I just pulled it up for the fun of it. The S&P for the past five years is up 53.91%. So that would be almost 11% a year. Love it. Okay, for five years.
That's the average for five years. So the last five, as of today.
But since July this year, the market is down. Sure. And because what we're seeing, we're seeing the high interest rates under the Biden Fed. They're driving the housing market to a screeching halt, and it's affecting a whole bunch of other things. Retailers are really freaking out about Christmas.
They're starting to worry that it's going to be a really slow Christmas. A lot of people barking about recession, but I don't know. We'll see. We're in an election year, coming up on into an election year. So we'll see how this plays out.
But anyway, all that to say, Donnie, you have a perception of the market that is based on last week's paycheck. So if that's how you're going to measure it, you should not put money into an S&P.
No, because you'd mess around and pull it out.
High yield savings account, and then get your Baby Step 4 back up to 15%, as Jade said, because you're not doing this short term. You don't want to be out of 15% in Baby Step 4 for longer than two and a half, three years. And what you're describing here is eight years. And so you need to be fully invested into good mutual funds in your retirement.
Do you think he was trying to save up and pay full out cash for a house?
I don't know.
Because I'm like an eight-year plan. That's aggressive.
I don't know. They've done really well. But that old house represents a bunch of stuff I don't like personally. Ruth is in Macon, Georgia. Hi, Ruth.
How can we help?
Hi, Dave. Hi, Jade. The reason I'm calling in is because my husband and I have been on Baby Step 2.. Not as intense as we should have been. Kind of starting to pick it up.
But I'm due with a baby in six weeks. And y'all have always said to, you know, when you get to that point, pump the brakes and just save up. Yeah. So that's what we're doing now. But, you know, come January, after she's born, barring any complications, we'll start back intense again.
No, intense for the first time.
Well, yeah, intense for the first time. Okay. We still had a reduction this year. It just wasn't the way it should have been.
Yeah, that's not intense. Yeah.
Anyway, so my question is, I owe about $22,000 left on my car. So it's at about the point where I could trade it in for about $25,000 right now, or sell it for around $30,000..
Or by the time we pay it off, and if we stick to the snowball schedule, I've ran all the numbers multiple times. It always comes out to April of 2025..
Sell it. Yeah. Sell it and buy a $7,000 car. Yeah.
Yeah, because we're at the point where it's like, you know, we want something that's dependable.
$7,000 cars are dependable.
What about your husband's car?
He has a truck, but it's almost paid off.
I want something that's dependable as code, for, I don't like the car. All these cars are dependable. $7,000 cars are dependable. There's nothing wrong with a $7,000 car. If you pick the right car, you have it checked out mechanically.
You don't buy a piece of junk, you know, because you just look like the way it looked or something. But I mean, actually check out the mechanical background. There's lots of really good cars for $7,000, really nice cars. And so, yeah, I would sell that puppy and be out of debt. There's no way I'm fighting with a stupid vehicle for three years.
v1.0.0.260408-1-a910ba6_os