Israel's Supreme Court, State Legislatures Lookahead, Ridding Water of PFAS

2024-01-02 00:14:54

NPR's Up First is the news you need to start your day. The three biggest stories of the day, with reporting and analysis from NPR News — in 10 minutes. Available weekdays at 6:30 a.m. ET, with hosts Leila Fadel, Steve Inskeep, Michel Martin and A Martinez. Also available on Saturdays at 9 a.m. ET, with Ayesha Rascoe and Scott Simon. On Sundays, hear a longer exploration behind the headlines with Ayesha Rascoe on "The Sunday Story," available by 8 a.m. ET. Subscribe and listen, then support your local NPR station at donate.npr.org.<br><br><em>Support NPR's reporting by subscribing to Up First+ and unlock sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org/upfirst</em>

1Speaker 1
00:02.84 – 00:06.86

Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his right-wing government passed a law

00:06.86 – 00:09.16

recently that weakened the country's Supreme Court.

3Speaker 3
00:09.30 – 00:11.94

Now that same Supreme Court has struck down the law.

1Speaker 1
00:12.22 – 00:14.88

Can Netanyahu fight the decision while leading a war?

00:15.10 – 00:18.46

I'm Michelle Martin, that's Steve Inskeep, and this is Up First from NPR News.

3Speaker 3
00:21.48 – 00:26.82

State legislatures plan to tackle issues this year that Congress has been slow to take on.

00:27.38 – 00:30.74

That includes how to limit the power of artificial intelligence.

1Speaker 1
00:31.02 – 00:35.38

Plus the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency may soon set limits on several so-called forever

00:35.38 – 00:37.10

chemicals in drinking water.

2Speaker 2
00:37.44 – 00:41.74

Exposure can impact the body's ability to fight infections and lead to reproductive

00:41.74 – 00:44.10

effects or an increased risk of cancer.

1Speaker 1
00:44.24 – 00:48.26

How difficult and expensive is it to rid water supplies of these chemicals?

00:48.40 – 00:50.12

Stay with us, we'll give you the day's news.

2Speaker 2
00:57.32 – 01:02.38

If you're hearing this, that means you haven't gone sponsor-free with NPR+.

01:02.38 – 01:09.48

Join us on the Plus side for awesome podcast perks across more than 20 NPR podcasts, including

01:09.48 – 01:13.86

bonus episodes, behind-the-scenes content, sponsor-free listening, and more.

1Speaker 1
01:14.40 – 01:18.08

Learn more and sign up at plus.npr.org.

2Speaker 2
01:18.20 – 01:20.08

And never hear this promo again.

01:21.04 – 01:24.64

On the TED Radio Hour, MIT psychologist Sherry Turkle.

01:25.08 – 01:30.60

Her latest research into the intimate relationships people are having with chatbots.

5Speaker 5
01:31.08 – 01:38.16

Technologies that say, I care about you, I love you, I'm here for you, take care of me.

2Speaker 2
01:38.60 – 01:41.70

The pros and cons of artificial intimacy.

01:42.06 – 01:44.28

That's on the TED Radio Hour from NPR.

1Speaker 1
01:45.30 – 01:49.84

Israel's Supreme Court says the government cannot limit the court's power after all.

3Speaker 3
01:50.12 – 01:55.32

By a narrow majority, the court struck down a law that was designed to curtail the court's

01:55.32 – 01:55.92

own authority.

01:56.50 – 01:59.84

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's coalition passed a law last year.

02:00.18 – 02:05.40

The effort united his right-wing government but divided Israeli society at large.

02:05.52 – 02:10.20

It was the reason for massive protests in the months before the start of the war against

02:10.20 – 02:10.70

Hamas.

1Speaker 1
02:10.70 – 02:14.82

NPR's Daniel Estrin is in Tel Aviv now to tell us more about this.

02:14.92 – 02:15.76

Daniel, good morning.

4Speaker 4
02:16.58 – 02:17.38

Good morning, Michelle.

1Speaker 1
02:17.66 – 02:21.78

So would you just start by reminding us about what this law was all about?

4Speaker 4
02:22.38 – 02:26.94

Yeah, it was the number one focus of the right-wing government when it came to power in Israel

02:26.94 – 02:27.54

a year ago.

02:27.68 – 02:32.40

And the idea was that the government wanted to strip the Supreme Court of some of its

02:32.40 – 02:32.78

powers.

02:33.22 – 02:37.60

This is the most right-wing religious nationalist government in Israel's history.

02:37.60 – 02:44.02

And it saw the Supreme Court as too left-wing, too protective of Palestinian rights, and

02:44.02 – 02:47.28

said the government should be the one to rule.

02:47.46 – 02:51.14

Let the elected officials rule, accusing the court of too much interference.

02:51.42 – 02:56.38

And this attempt to overhaul the judiciary sparked historic protests in Israel.

02:56.84 – 03:00.94

Hundreds of thousands of people in the streets, demonstrators accusing the government of

03:00.94 – 03:02.94

weakening Israel's democracy.

03:03.38 – 03:06.36

But the government passed this law anyway this summer.

03:06.36 – 03:10.72

It stripped the court of one of its powers to overturn government appointments.

1Speaker 1
03:11.40 – 03:13.32

And why did the court strike it down?

03:13.52 – 03:15.20

What grounds did it give for this?

4Speaker 4
03:15.80 – 03:21.52

The court says that this law was a, quote, severe and unprecedented harm to the core

03:21.52 – 03:26.64

character of Israel as a democratic country, and said the government does not have omnipotent

03:26.64 – 03:27.08

powers.

03:27.58 – 03:29.80

This is a landmark ruling in Israel.

03:29.90 – 03:34.10

It's the first time the Supreme Court has overturned the equivalent of a constitutional

03:34.10 – 03:34.62

amendment.

03:34.62 – 03:40.54

And it is a big blow to Netanyahu and to his right-wing allies, because this judicial overhaul

03:40.54 – 03:43.68

was the number one main agenda of the government.

1Speaker 1
03:44.32 – 03:49.26

And is there any way in which this decision might play into Israel's handling of the war

03:49.26 – 03:49.76

in Gaza?

4Speaker 4
03:50.46 – 03:54.86

Well, the Israeli government now, we hear officials, they're not very happy with this

03:54.86 – 03:59.20

ruling, but they suggest that they're not going to do anything further to overhaul the

03:59.20 – 04:02.02

judiciary while the country is at war.

04:02.70 – 04:08.74

They recognize it's too divisive of an issue at this time of war, but it does add fuel

04:08.74 – 04:14.92

to what we're hearing as a growing discontent in Israel about the war, about the government's

04:14.92 – 04:19.40

role in this catastrophic situation Israel's facing.

04:19.58 – 04:25.14

Israeli defense officials, in the months leading up to the war, had warned publicly that Israel's

04:25.14 – 04:30.80

regional enemies saw how the country was torn apart over this judicial overhaul debate.

04:30.80 – 04:35.30

And that enemies were identifying this as a moment of weakness to attack Israel.

04:35.82 – 04:38.26

And indeed, Hamas attacked on October 7th.

04:38.30 – 04:42.84

The military spokesman yesterday said that was likely one of the reasons Hamas chose

04:42.84 – 04:44.48

this moment to attack.

04:44.82 – 04:49.38

And there are also implications, Michelle, about the day after the war.

04:49.64 – 04:54.28

Analysts say that the government, you hear officials in the government talking about

04:54.28 – 04:59.50

all kinds of policy proposals for what they want to see in Gaza, things that the Supreme

04:59.50 – 05:01.40

Court might determine to be unreasonable.

05:01.70 – 05:05.74

And now that they've overturned this law, they will be able to weigh in.

1Speaker 1
05:06.42 – 05:09.42

That is NPR's Daniel Estrin speaking to us from Tel Aviv.

05:09.52 – 05:10.50

Daniel, thank you so much.

4Speaker 4
05:10.94 – 05:11.34

You're welcome.

1Speaker 1
05:11.82 – 05:15.62

We're also following news of an earthquake that struck Japan on New Year's Day.

05:16.08 – 05:19.30

It had a magnitude of 7.6, which is very powerful.

05:19.58 – 05:24.48

It struck far from the population center in Tokyo, but near towns on a peninsula along

05:24.48 – 05:25.70

Japan's western coast.

05:25.70 – 05:30.22

An Associated Press photo shows people who've come outside for safety standing in a street

05:30.22 – 05:31.68

lined with massive cracks.

05:32.28 – 05:35.12

More than 100 aftershocks are complicating rescue efforts.

05:35.58 – 05:37.48

We will bring you more as we learn it.

05:46.36 – 05:50.44

We told you a lot about what the U.S. Congress did not do last year.

05:50.58 – 05:55.18

But state legislatures are a very different story, and this year their agendas are packed.

05:55.18 – 05:59.22

As lawmakers head back to work in the next couple of weeks, many of them have big plans

05:59.22 – 06:02.86

to tackle issues that federal lawmakers have been dragging their feet on.

06:03.18 – 06:06.22

Reid Wilson is here to give us a preview of the year ahead in state legislation.

06:06.64 – 06:08.76

He is the editor-in-chief of Pluribus News.

06:08.76 – 06:12.80

That's a news service that focuses on state-level policymaking, and he is with us on the line

06:12.80 – 06:13.48

from Arizona.

06:13.64 – 06:14.06

Good morning.

5Speaker 5
06:14.54 – 06:14.90

Good morning.

1Speaker 1
06:15.18 – 06:19.92

So a big topic of debate on the federal level right now has been artificial intelligence.

06:20.26 – 06:22.46

How are state legislators talking about this?

5Speaker 5
06:23.18 – 06:27.12

Well, artificial intelligence policy is top of mind in just about every state capital

06:27.12 – 06:27.78

in the country.

06:28.30 – 06:32.02

Lawmakers are thinking about how to promote what could be this massive economic engine

06:32.02 – 06:36.52

in their own backyards, and they're also considering ways to set up guardrails to protect against

06:36.52 – 06:38.92

things like discrimination in algorithms.

06:39.42 – 06:43.86

I think this year is going to be mostly about studying government's role in AI policy.

06:44.04 – 06:48.68

But the common thread in the dozens of conversations that we've had with lawmakers across the country

06:48.68 – 06:53.48

about this is that the states feel the need to act because they don't trust Congress to

06:53.48 – 06:54.44

get its act in gear.

06:54.86 – 06:58.70

We're going to see a lot of efforts to regulate social media companies in different ways this

06:58.70 – 07:01.62

year, all in services of protecting kids online.

07:02.02 – 07:07.06

You know, eight states passed digital privacy laws in 2023, and lots more will be taking

07:07.06 – 07:12.32

up bills that either require parental permission for kids to access social media sites or to

07:12.32 – 07:14.88

ban addictive features in social media apps.

1Speaker 1
07:14.88 – 07:19.92

OK, speaking of addiction, something we've reported on extensively is the opioid crisis,

07:20.40 – 07:22.76

and states have been on the front lines of that for years.

07:23.20 – 07:27.26

Do you see more legislation on addiction and health care coming up?

5Speaker 5
07:27.98 – 07:29.74

Yeah, this is huge in the states.

07:30.04 – 07:33.20

We're going to see two distinct trends in health care this year.

07:33.52 – 07:37.90

First of all, states are trying to find a solution to this massive opioid crisis.

07:38.44 – 07:42.80

Blue states are considering proposals like creating safe injection sites or legalizing

07:42.80 – 07:45.00

drug paraphernalia like fentanyl test strips.

07:45.34 – 07:49.28

The theory really being users are going to use, so why not give them a safe environment

07:49.28 – 07:50.28

in which to do so?

07:50.64 – 07:55.62

Red states and even some Democratic states are also moving to increase penalties on dealers

07:55.62 – 07:59.28

who provide drugs that cause a user serious harm or death.

07:59.76 – 08:03.44

The second big trend in health care is this never ending effort to bring down costs.

08:03.86 – 08:08.00

Some states are pressuring the Biden administration to approve permits that would allow them to

08:08.00 – 08:10.64

reimport prescription drugs from Canada.

08:10.64 – 08:15.06

Some blue states are in the process of setting up panels that would be able to set payment

08:15.06 – 08:16.62

limits on high cost drugs.

08:16.86 – 08:21.90

And some of the 10 red states that have yet to expand Medicaid coverage under the Affordable

08:21.90 – 08:26.82

Care Act are going to at least consider doing so after North Carolina Republicans decided

08:26.82 – 08:28.26

to expand coverage last year.

1Speaker 1
08:28.44 – 08:29.86

And what about climate change?

08:29.88 – 08:35.14

You know, we saw a number of state leaders attending the climate change conference in

08:35.14 – 08:36.04

Doha this year.

08:36.60 – 08:39.96

Does that say something about what the states are interested in moving on?

5Speaker 5
08:40.70 – 08:41.40

I think it does.

08:41.50 – 08:46.30

I mean, we're in the midst of a massive transition from a carbon based energy to renewable and

08:46.30 – 08:48.86

clean energy, and the states are really leading the way on this.

08:49.18 – 08:53.90

More states move to require utility companies to transition to entirely renewable energy

08:53.90 – 08:56.62

portfolios by 2040 or 2050.

08:56.92 – 09:01.28

Big renewable projects like solar or wind farms require lots of space.

09:01.28 – 09:06.54

So we're even seeing some states move to preempt local authority to block those projects as

09:06.54 – 09:07.98

a way to speed construction.

09:08.52 – 09:11.62

And you know, Michelle, there's also a renewed interest in nuclear energy.

09:11.78 – 09:16.46

And after the development of what are called small modular reactors, these reactors, they're

09:16.46 – 09:20.28

a lot smaller and higher tech than traditional nuclear reactors you might think of.

09:20.60 – 09:25.32

And both red states and blue states are considering new plants that would eventually provide a

09:25.32 – 09:27.20

lot of non-carbon energy to the grid.

1Speaker 1
09:27.34 – 09:30.90

And before we let you go, and obviously this is a subject that requires, you know, a lot

09:30.90 – 09:35.80

more time, but we saw the states really taking on a lot of these hot button, what we would

09:35.80 – 09:40.46

call maybe culture war issues, like gender affirming care for minors, you know, abortion

09:40.46 – 09:41.56

rights, things of that sort.

09:41.90 – 09:43.34

Are we going to see more of that?

5Speaker 5
09:44.04 – 09:44.90

I think we will.

09:45.30 – 09:49.58

Most abortion rights and gender affirming care bills have passed in the states where

09:49.58 – 09:50.52

they're going to pass.

09:50.60 – 09:53.66

So a lot of that is going to be an issue on the ballot box this year.

09:53.92 – 09:59.30

But in conservative states especially, one of the areas where the culture war has flared

09:59.30 – 10:00.60

up is over education.

10:00.96 – 10:05.12

Sort of the watchword among conservative circles is the Parents' Bill of Rights.

10:05.44 – 10:09.76

Lawmakers are trying to legislate what books can be included in libraries, what subjects

10:09.76 – 10:11.32

can be discussed in the classroom.

10:11.58 – 10:13.14

And that's become a real flashpoint.

10:13.48 – 10:17.78

In some conservative states, others and even liberal states haven't brought those up yet.

10:17.90 – 10:21.00

So I expect we'll see a lot more of that discussion coming this year.

1Speaker 1
10:21.60 – 10:23.98

Reid Wilson is editor-in-chief of Pluribus News.

10:24.22 – 10:25.18

Reid, thank you so much.

5Speaker 5
10:25.70 – 10:26.12

Thank you.

?Unknown Speaker
10:31.30 – 10:32.42

Thank you.

1Speaker 1
10:35.14 – 10:40.98

Early this year, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is expected to set limits on six so-called

10:40.98 – 10:43.72

forever chemicals, known as PFAS, in drinking water.

3Speaker 3
10:44.08 – 10:50.20

One city that has seen elevated levels of two of those chemicals is Tampa, Florida.

10:50.70 – 10:55.02

Now the city says it will likely be the first in the country to use technology that will

10:55.02 – 10:57.58

make it easier to filter out these PFAS.

1Speaker 1
10:57.58 – 11:02.88

Joining us now to tell us more about the city's plans is Jessica Mazaros with WUSF in Tampa.

11:03.04 – 11:03.68

Jessica, welcome.

11:03.80 – 11:04.66

Thanks for joining us.

2Speaker 2
11:05.08 – 11:05.78

Thank you for having me.

1Speaker 1
11:06.10 – 11:10.26

So could you just start by reminding us what PFAS chemicals are?

2Speaker 2
11:10.78 – 11:10.94

Sure.

11:11.12 – 11:16.44

So PFAS actually stands for a large family of toxic man-made chemical compounds.

11:16.82 – 11:22.10

They've been used in consumer and industry products since the 1940s, from clothing, upholstery

11:22.10 – 11:26.64

and carpet to microwave popcorn bags, pizza boxes and even candy wrappers.

11:26.64 – 11:29.34

They've been linked to negative health effects for people.

11:29.90 – 11:34.66

Exposure to certain levels can impact the body's ability to fight infections and lead to

11:34.66 – 11:37.38

reproductive effects or an increased risk of cancer.

11:37.90 – 11:41.68

At this point, they are everywhere, so they end up in the water supply.

11:41.96 – 11:44.16

Here's Sarah Burns with Tampa's water department.

11:44.44 – 11:48.18

We are passive receivers, so we don't generate a single drop of PFAS.

11:48.36 – 11:50.50

It just comes to us in our source water.

11:50.70 – 11:55.74

The utility is actually part of a lawsuit against manufacturers of PFAS, like 3M and

11:55.74 – 11:58.14

DuPont, to recover the cost of removal.

1Speaker 1
11:58.56 – 12:01.82

So tell us about this big new technology that Tampa is bringing in.

2Speaker 2
12:02.08 – 12:05.52

Yeah, the city of Tampa is getting the technology from the Netherlands.

12:05.88 – 12:09.00

It's called SIX, or Suspended Ion Exchange.

12:09.62 – 12:14.68

It removes things like decaying vegetation from the water, and the city says to filter

12:14.68 – 12:17.98

out PFAS, you have to first remove the organic matter.

12:18.74 – 12:22.46

Tampa's water department would be the first in the country to have this system.

12:22.46 – 12:27.90

The other two are in Europe, and the plan for this one is to filter 140 million gallons

12:27.90 – 12:28.40

a day.

1Speaker 1
12:29.04 – 12:31.26

Can I ask the why is this needed?

12:31.42 – 12:33.34

Is Tampa's water that bad?

2Speaker 2
12:33.80 – 12:35.40

Well, it's not that the water is bad.

12:35.50 – 12:39.88

It's just that the city gets its drinking water from the Hillsborough River, which is

12:39.88 – 12:42.78

collected along with all sorts of organic matter from nature.

12:43.52 – 12:49.54

Now, Tampa did recently find slightly elevated levels of two of six PFAS in its drinking

12:49.54 – 12:50.36

water supplies.

12:50.36 – 12:55.80

The EPA proposed limit is at four parts per trillion for these two, and the highest the

12:55.80 – 12:58.16

city found in its water was just over six.

1Speaker 1
12:58.48 – 12:59.74

This sounds expensive.

13:00.30 – 13:01.68

How is this going to be paid for?

2Speaker 2
13:02.04 – 13:06.34

Well, Tampa is still in the designing phase, and the system won't be completed until about

13:06.34 – 13:12.64

2032, but Tampa's more than 700,000 water customers are already paying for it.

13:12.94 – 13:17.94

It's expected to cost $200 million, and it's part of a larger infrastructure improvement

13:17.94 – 13:19.96

plan that the city council already approved.

13:19.96 – 13:24.46

Their water bills will be increasing every October until 2040.

13:24.98 – 13:29.08

That said, city officials do point out that the technology will actually save the department

13:29.08 – 13:31.54

nearly a million and a half dollars a year.

1Speaker 1
13:31.68 – 13:32.20

And how?

13:32.56 – 13:33.68

How will it save that money?

2Speaker 2
13:34.24 – 13:38.48

Well, installing this sick system means they'll use less chemicals and filters.

13:39.12 – 13:43.36

Sarah Burns said if they weren't using this, they'd have to otherwise go through double

13:43.36 – 13:43.94

the filters.

13:44.52 – 13:48.92

Plus, getting the organic matter out of the water early on in the treatment process actually

13:48.92 – 13:53.20

improves all the other stages that follow, so it makes the system a lot more efficient.

1Speaker 1
13:53.60 – 13:56.26

That's Jessica Mazaros with WUSF in Tampa.

13:56.46 – 13:57.58

Jessica, thank you so much.

2Speaker 2
13:57.92 – 13:58.40

Thank you.

1Speaker 1
14:02.80 – 14:05.58

And that's Up First for Tuesday, January 2nd.

14:05.60 – 14:06.26

I'm Michelle Martin.

3Speaker 3
14:06.64 – 14:07.50

And I'm Steve Inskeep.

14:07.54 – 14:12.14

Today's Up First was edited by Kevin Drew, Allie Schweitzer, and Susanna Capilouto.

14:12.38 – 14:16.02

It was produced by Ziad Butch, Ben Abrams, and Taylor Haney.

14:16.02 – 14:20.58

We get engineering support from Stacey Abbott, and our technical director is Carly Strange.

1Speaker 1
14:21.12 – 14:21.34

Zach?

14:21.48 – 14:22.90

You don't look like Carly Strange to me.

3Speaker 3
14:23.70 – 14:27.92

Okay, Zach Coleman is our technical director, although, of course, we admire Carly Strange.

14:28.06 – 14:28.72

Join us here tomorrow.

1Speaker 1
14:29.24 – 14:30.54

Thanks for waking up with NPR.

14:30.68 – 14:33.40

Your NPR station makes Up First possible each morning.

14:33.96 – 14:39.16

Support their work and ours, please, at donate.npr.org slash upfirst.

v1.0.0.260408-1-a910ba6_os