Student Protests Continue, The Week In Trump Trials, UNRWA Report

2024-04-27 00:16:26

NPR's Up First is the news you need to start your day. The three biggest stories of the day, with reporting and analysis from NPR News — in 10 minutes. Available weekdays at 6:30 a.m. ET, with hosts Leila Fadel, Steve Inskeep, Michel Martin and A Martinez. Also available on Saturdays at 9 a.m. ET, with Ayesha Rascoe and Scott Simon. On Sundays, hear a longer exploration behind the headlines with Ayesha Rascoe on "The Sunday Story," available by 8 a.m. ET. Subscribe and listen, then support your local NPR station at donate.npr.org.<br><br><em>Support NPR's reporting by subscribing to Up First+ and unlock sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org/upfirst</em>

1Speaker 1
00:02.48 – 00:06.10

I am not afraid anymore, so why should the administration be?

5Speaker 5
00:06.32 – 00:10.06

Students speak out about Gaza, Israel, and one another.

3Speaker 3
00:10.30 – 00:12.88

As the schools they attend scramble to respond.

5Speaker 5
00:13.16 – 00:14.30

I'm Aisha Roscoe.

3Speaker 3
00:14.36 – 00:17.14

I'm Scott Simon, and this is Up First from NPR News.

00:20.22 – 00:24.90

Today on the podcast, ongoing demonstrations on college campuses across the country.

00:25.04 – 00:25.82

We have the latest.

5Speaker 5
00:25.82 – 00:31.34

And the weekend former President Trump's legal maneuvering, both at his trial in New York

00:31.34 – 00:35.66

and at the Supreme Court, where his attorneys took some extreme positions.

3Speaker 3
00:35.98 – 00:40.36

And the findings of an investigation into a humanitarian group devoted to Palestinians.

5Speaker 5
00:40.84 – 00:45.44

The report concerns one of two controversial claims about UNRWA.

00:45.84 – 00:46.64

Stay with us.

00:46.70 – 00:48.60

We've got the news you need to start your weekend.

1Speaker 1
00:57.28 – 01:01.42

On the TED Radio Hour, MIT psychologist Sherry Turkle.

01:01.88 – 01:07.38

Her latest research into the intimate relationships people are having with chatbots.

01:07.86 – 01:14.96

Technologies that say, I care about you, I love you, I'm here for you, take care of me.

01:15.38 – 01:18.46

The pros and cons of artificial intimacy.

01:18.82 – 01:21.02

That's on the TED Radio Hour from NPR.

5Speaker 5
01:23.90 – 01:28.88

Hey there, this is Felix Contreras, one of the co-hosts of Alt Latino, the podcast from

01:28.88 – 01:34.14

NPR Music, where we discuss Latinx culture, music, and heritage with the artists that

01:34.14 – 01:34.76

create it.

01:35.10 – 01:38.04

Listen now to the Alt Latino podcast from NPR.

01:43.96 – 01:48.98

First up today, students protest on college campuses across the country.

01:48.98 – 01:54.98

At schools like Columbia University, Yale, and Harvard, demonstrations of solidarity

01:54.98 – 01:56.22

with the people of Gaza.

3Speaker 3
01:56.78 – 01:59.08

Many of these students have formed encampments.

01:59.50 – 02:00.54

Hundreds have been arrested.

02:00.82 – 02:04.52

And here is Jasmine Garst, who's been covering the protest and joins us from New York.

02:04.72 – 02:06.08

Jasmine, thanks for being with us.

2Speaker 2
02:06.58 – 02:06.86

Hi.

3Speaker 3
02:07.28 – 02:11.68

Please bring us up to date on where the situation stands with Columbia University.

2Speaker 2
02:12.18 – 02:15.42

Yeah, I was there all day yesterday and it's very calm.

02:15.42 – 02:20.92

That wasn't the case a week ago when NYPD got called in to disperse the encampment and

02:20.92 – 02:22.92

over 100 students were arrested.

02:23.78 – 02:28.56

The president of Columbia, Manoush Shafiq, has come under fire for calling the police.

02:29.04 – 02:32.22

And many Columbia faculty members have condemned the decision.

02:32.46 – 02:35.64

Earlier this week, I spoke to Professor Thomas Howley.

5Speaker 5
02:35.90 – 02:40.40

The way the university escalated by reaching immediately for the nuclear option of police

02:40.40 – 02:45.14

force has attracted more radical elements that are not part of our student protest community

02:45.14 – 02:47.12

and don't share the values of our students.

2Speaker 2
02:47.52 – 02:52.82

Shafiq has defended her decision to send in NYPD, but she's also acknowledged that it

02:52.82 – 02:53.88

was ultimately ineffective.

02:54.42 – 02:57.74

She said the university is focusing on negotiating with students.

3Speaker 3
02:58.30 – 03:00.08

What about other campuses across the country?

2Speaker 2
03:00.80 – 03:05.88

Well, protests have spread nationwide with similar demands that the universities disclose

03:05.88 – 03:08.16

financial ties to Israel and divest.

03:08.66 – 03:13.02

Now what's really unprecedented here is that while you expect this type of activism at

03:13.02 – 03:17.94

schools like, I don't know, UC Berkeley, the protests have also moved into schools

03:17.94 – 03:23.26

like University of Southern California or Cal Poly, which are not historically associated

03:23.26 – 03:24.82

with this kind of activism.

03:25.20 – 03:29.22

A couple of schools have experienced similar aggressive police response.

03:29.50 – 03:34.82

There were over 100 arrests at the University of Texas in Austin and the University of Southern

03:34.82 – 03:35.56

California.

03:36.38 – 03:41.88

Emory University's student newspaper reported that the Atlanta police deployed gas into

03:41.88 – 03:43.40

a crowd of protesters.

3Speaker 3
03:44.54 – 03:48.62

There have been charges of anti-Semitism at some of these protests.

03:48.78 – 03:50.26

What did you find on campus?

2Speaker 2
03:50.86 – 03:56.22

So yesterday at a press conference hosted by Columbia, Barnard, Hillel, several pro-Israel

03:56.22 – 03:58.38

students expressed fear and anger.

03:58.62 – 03:59.50

Here's Noah Fay.

1Speaker 1
03:59.92 – 04:01.78

No one is above the law.

4Speaker 4
04:02.20 – 04:07.44

Arrest the students on Butler Lawn and discipline those that continue to call for the death

04:07.44 – 04:08.86

of my friends and family.

2Speaker 2
04:09.42 – 04:11.58

Look at me, the Jew facing this.

04:11.58 – 04:13.22

I am not afraid anymore.

04:13.56 – 04:15.10

So why should the administration be?

04:15.94 – 04:20.32

She pointed out that one of the leaders of the Columbia encampment in a social media

04:20.32 – 04:22.76

video called for the death of Zionists.

04:23.20 – 04:26.08

He's since apologized and been barred from campus.

04:26.70 – 04:29.94

Now a few days ago, I also had a chance to sit down with Sarah Boris.

04:30.48 – 04:33.70

She's one of the students who were arrested last week at Columbia.

04:33.98 – 04:34.82

She's been suspended.

04:35.06 – 04:36.48

She can't go back on campus.

04:37.16 – 04:38.24

She herself is Jewish.

04:38.24 – 04:43.52

And she says the only thing making her feel unsafe right now is the heightened police

04:43.52 – 04:44.28

presence.

1Speaker 1
04:45.16 – 04:51.72

In my capacity as a Jewish student, I feel safe, but not with all of the militarization

04:51.72 – 04:52.36

of our campus.

04:52.62 – 04:58.06

I don't think anyone feels safe on our campus because of the way that Manoush Shafik and

04:58.06 – 05:00.96

the administration have escalated the situation.

2Speaker 2
05:01.40 – 05:06.80

And what she told me is she feels protesting Israel's mass killings makes her a better

05:06.80 – 05:07.18

Jew.

3Speaker 3
05:07.78 – 05:10.04

And graduation's right around the corner, isn't it?

2Speaker 2
05:10.28 – 05:10.62

Yes.

05:10.72 – 05:15.06

So the University of Southern California has canceled its main graduation ceremony.

05:15.80 – 05:20.94

And speaking to students from different colleges, I've heard of speakers stepping down, venues

05:20.94 – 05:21.78

canceling.

05:22.06 – 05:24.90

It's going to be a very different graduation season.

05:25.48 – 05:30.46

As for Columbia, they're hoping to continue negotiating with the students and getting

05:30.46 – 05:35.36

that encampment cleared in time for graduation on May 14th.

3Speaker 3
05:35.36 – 05:37.16

And Judge Jasmine Garth, thanks so much.

2Speaker 2
05:37.62 – 05:38.40

Thanks for having me.

5Speaker 5
05:49.60 – 05:54.72

It's the end of another busy week in court as a former president finds himself needing

05:54.72 – 05:57.40

to mount defenses on a number of fronts.

05:58.16 – 06:03.44

This week, a tabloid publisher told a New York jury about his efforts to pay off people

06:03.44 – 06:07.62

with salacious stories about Donald Trump before the 2016 election.

3Speaker 3
06:08.00 – 06:12.04

And the U.S. Supreme Court debated whether Trump should get a legal shield for his actions

06:12.04 – 06:15.18

pertaining to the January 6th attack on the U.S. Capitol.

06:15.38 – 06:19.36

And PR Justice Correspondent Carrie Johnson is following all of this.

06:19.56 – 06:21.20

Carrie, thanks so much for being with us.

4Speaker 4
06:22.00 – 06:22.78

Good morning, Scott.

3Speaker 3
06:22.90 – 06:24.78

And let's begin with the U.S. Supreme Court.

06:24.90 – 06:26.20

How do you read what happened there?

4Speaker 4
06:26.90 – 06:31.94

Well, the justices are considering whether Trump should enjoy absolute immunity from

06:31.94 – 06:32.96

criminal prosecution.

06:32.96 – 06:36.84

This would be for his efforts to cling to power after the 2020 election.

06:37.56 – 06:42.56

And Donald Trump's lawyer, John Sauer, took some heat this week for his extreme positions,

06:43.06 – 06:47.82

things like arguing Trump might be able to use the military to mount a coup attempt or

06:47.82 – 06:49.28

to kill a Trump rival.

06:49.64 – 06:55.06

But most of the conservative justices seemed a lot more concerned about tying a future

06:55.06 – 06:59.66

president's hands than about violence at the U.S. Capitol on January 6th, 2021.

07:00.58 – 07:04.42

Here's Justice Samuel Alito talking to the government lawyer, Michael Dreeben.

3Speaker 3
07:04.78 – 07:07.16

Presidents have to make a lot of tough decisions.

07:07.80 – 07:12.24

You don't think he's in a special, a peculiarly precarious position?

1Speaker 1
07:13.08 – 07:17.22

Making a mistake is not what lands you in a criminal prosecution.

4Speaker 4
07:17.70 – 07:21.50

That's what the government lawyer said, but others, including the chief justice, John

07:21.50 – 07:26.90

Roberts, really seem worried about prosecutors hounding a future president, even though the

07:26.90 – 07:30.68

lawyer for the Justice Department said the country hasn't faced these kinds of questions

07:30.68 – 07:31.88

since Richard Nixon.

3Speaker 3
07:33.10 – 07:35.28

That was the view from conservatives who are on the high court.

07:35.44 – 07:37.22

What did some of the more liberal justices say?

4Speaker 4
07:38.00 – 07:42.48

Justice Elena Kagan said the founders really knew how to write immunity for the president

07:42.48 – 07:48.08

into the Constitution, but that they had decided not to do that because they didn't want some

07:48.08 – 07:49.98

kind of all-powerful monarch.

07:50.62 – 07:55.60

Justice Katonji Brown-Jackson said she feared giving a president too much power, giving

07:55.60 – 07:57.22

him a get-out-of-jail-free card.

07:57.68 – 07:59.62

Here's more from Justice Jackson.

5Speaker 5
07:59.96 – 08:06.26

I'm trying to understand what the disincentive is from turning the Oval Office into, you

08:06.26 – 08:09.64

know, the seat of criminal activity in this country.

4Speaker 4
08:10.04 – 08:14.94

And she also tried to focus the court on the specific allegations against Donald Trump,

08:15.30 – 08:20.00

who's charged with subverting the will of voters while he's running to return to the

08:20.00 – 08:20.70

White House this year.

08:20.74 – 08:22.48

Trump, of course, has pleaded not guilty.

3Speaker 3
08:23.08 – 08:28.64

But the Supreme Court ultimately decides, and when, could make or break that federal

08:28.64 – 08:30.74

January 6 case against Donald Trump.

08:31.34 – 08:35.62

Carrie, can you venture any inferences from the questioning you heard this week?

4Speaker 4
08:36.10 – 08:40.58

It's always dangerous, but it seemed like at least four of the conservative justices

08:40.58 – 08:44.56

wanted to give the president some protection from criminal prosecution.

08:45.14 – 08:49.78

And they may want to draw some lines between actions that a president takes as a part of

08:49.78 – 08:52.44

his job and ones that are simply personal.

08:53.02 – 08:57.48

Now, that kind of opinion could take a long time to write, especially if the justices

08:57.48 – 09:01.50

want to send the case back to the lower courts for more fact-finding.

09:02.12 – 09:06.62

The chances for a trial in Washington, D.C., for Donald Trump before the November election

09:06.62 – 09:09.20

now seem pretty slim to none.

3Speaker 3
09:10.18 – 09:13.46

Donald Trump couldn't make his own Supreme Court case, because, of course, he had to

09:13.46 – 09:15.18

be in New York for his criminal trial.

09:15.78 – 09:20.00

That jury in Manhattan's been hearing evidence in the case about accounting for hush money

09:20.00 – 09:20.54

payments.

09:20.88 – 09:21.56

What did they hear?

4Speaker 4
09:22.18 – 09:25.38

Jurors heard from the first witness from the district attorney.

09:25.56 – 09:28.56

That would be former National Enquirer publisher David Pecker.

09:29.04 – 09:33.60

He described himself as a longtime friend to Trump, but he offered some pretty damaging

09:33.60 – 09:34.20

testimony.

09:34.84 – 09:39.24

He said he knew about or took part in payoffs to people who had stories to sell about Trump's

09:39.24 – 09:40.08

personal behavior.

09:40.08 – 09:46.18

Before the 2016 election, David Pecker said Trump was not worried about his family finding

09:46.18 – 09:51.78

out, but he was worried about his political standing if stories about his alleged womanizing

09:51.78 – 09:52.52

got published.

09:53.00 – 09:57.22

Trump's lawyers tried to suggest Pecker was acting to benefit his own company, not Trump.

3Speaker 3
09:57.52 – 09:59.36

Gary, what are you going to be watching for this week?

4Speaker 4
09:59.74 – 10:03.90

This week, the judge in New York, Juan Marchand, is considering whether Donald Trump should

10:03.90 – 10:09.48

be fined for repeatedly violating a gag order and verbally attacking potential witnesses

10:09.48 – 10:10.08

in the case.

10:10.58 – 10:15.44

Right now, a money penalty seems to be on the table, but if Donald Trump does not stop

10:15.44 – 10:20.52

posting negative information about his former lawyer, Michael Cohen, this judge may have

10:20.52 – 10:22.34

to consider harsher measures.

3Speaker 3
10:22.64 – 10:24.40

And Paris Carey Johnson, thanks so much.

4Speaker 4
10:24.62 – 10:25.20

My pleasure.

3Speaker 3
10:41.50 – 10:47.00

Finally today, an independent review says that Israel has not provided evidence to support

10:47.00 – 10:52.28

its accusation that a significant number of employees of a U.N. relief agency in the Gaza

10:52.28 – 10:58.22

Strip are members of Hamas, the Palestinian militant group that attacked Israel last October.

5Speaker 5
10:58.56 – 11:04.62

That agency is UNRWA, officially the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine

11:04.62 – 11:06.26

refugees in the Near East.

11:06.26 – 11:11.92

And the accusation led to a loss of vital international funding at a time when Gaza

11:11.92 – 11:13.36

is on the brink of famine.

11:14.06 – 11:18.94

NPR international affairs correspondent Jackie Northam has been following the details of

11:18.94 – 11:20.48

this story and joins us now.

11:20.56 – 11:21.10

Hi, Jackie.

1Speaker 1
11:21.48 – 11:22.16

Morning, Ayesha.

5Speaker 5
11:22.48 – 11:26.68

So, first of all, can you tell us a few more details about this review?

1Speaker 1
11:27.20 – 11:32.18

Well, it was led by former French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna, and she was charged

11:32.18 – 11:37.40

with looking into whether UNRWA was ensuring that there was no complicity with Hamas.

11:37.94 – 11:43.24

And the review started in late January after Israel made accusations of terrorist links

11:43.24 – 11:45.04

among UNRWA employees.

11:45.20 – 11:49.62

And, you know, after that, more than a dozen international donors, including the U.S.,

11:49.62 – 11:52.58

suspended about $450 million in funding.

11:52.68 – 11:55.48

And, you know, that's money that's desperately needed right now.

11:56.00 – 12:00.46

UNRWA is the main agency in Gaza providing aid and social services.

12:00.46 – 12:05.76

And these are critical at this moment when there are dire shortages of, you know, food

12:05.76 – 12:10.98

and water and sanitary conditions because of the Israeli military campaign.

12:11.26 – 12:15.58

And, you know, some countries have restored funding, Germany most recently, following

12:15.58 – 12:16.76

this latest report.

12:16.94 – 12:21.70

But, you know, Congress has suspended U.S. financial support until at least March 2025.

5Speaker 5
12:23.14 – 12:28.56

So late January until this week, this review took about nine weeks.

12:28.56 – 12:31.30

What are some of the key findings?

1Speaker 1
12:31.98 – 12:37.14

Well, the review found that, in fact, UNRWA was doing everything in its power to ensure

12:37.14 – 12:38.20

its neutrality.

12:38.76 – 12:44.42

However, it also found some employees had expressed political views and said critical

12:44.42 – 12:49.96

breaches of neutrality could include the discovery of weapons and tunnels, which the agency always

12:49.96 – 12:50.56

protests.

12:51.16 – 12:57.44

I spoke with William Dury, and he heads UNRWA's Washington representative office, and he felt

12:57.44 – 12:59.94

that the report was fair and balanced.

13:00.10 – 13:00.68

Here he is here.

13:00.98 – 13:06.36

Foreign Minister Colonna said, you know, confirmed that we actually have procedures and mechanisms

13:07.24 – 13:12.36

in place to address neutrality better than any other U.N. agency or NGO.

13:12.70 – 13:16.86

And that's, as she noted, because of politically challenging part of the world in which we

13:16.86 – 13:17.36

operate.

13:17.50 – 13:18.98

But like anyone, you can do better.

13:19.20 – 13:22.52

And hence the recommendations that she included in the report.

13:22.82 – 13:27.28

You know, and some of the recommendations include better training, a more robust screening

13:27.28 – 13:28.08

of employees.

13:28.50 – 13:33.78

You know, until just recently, Israel received lists of UNRWA employees, but without Palestinian

13:33.78 – 13:35.34

identification numbers.

13:35.48 – 13:38.56

And then in March, the list did have ID numbers.

13:38.64 – 13:44.16

And that's when Israel says a significant number of employees were members of terrorist

13:44.16 – 13:45.04

organizations.

13:45.34 – 13:49.96

But, you know, Ayesha, the report said Israel has yet to provide supporting evidence of

13:49.96 – 13:50.22

that.

13:50.86 – 13:55.12

Israel, for its part, dismissed the findings of the review, saying it doesn't deal with

13:55.12 – 13:58.84

the, quote, scope of Hamas's infiltration into UNRWA.

5Speaker 5
13:59.46 – 14:03.96

Now, this is just the first of two U.N. commissioned reports on UNRWA.

14:05.04 – 14:06.10

What about the other one?

1Speaker 1
14:06.38 – 14:06.66

Right.

14:06.72 – 14:12.60

So the other investigation is looking at Israel's claims that about a dozen UNRWA employees actually

14:12.60 – 14:17.04

took part in the October 7th attack on Israel that killed about 1,200 people.

14:17.48 – 14:21.52

It's being conducted by the U.N. Office of Internal Oversight Services.

14:21.52 – 14:26.58

And, you know, shortly after Israel made those accusations, UNRWA terminated the contracts

14:26.58 – 14:27.82

of 10 of those workers.

14:28.26 – 14:29.82

Another two were confirmed dead.

14:30.24 – 14:32.96

But no word yet on when that report is due.

5Speaker 5
14:33.50 – 14:34.76

NPR's Jackie Northam.

14:35.12 – 14:36.34

Jackie, thank you so much.

1Speaker 1
14:36.72 – 14:37.12

Thank you.

3Speaker 3
14:41.14 – 14:44.94

And that's a first for Saturday, April 27th, 2024.

14:45.36 – 14:46.12

I'm Scott Simon.

5Speaker 5
14:46.60 – 14:48.00

And I'm Ayesha Roscoe.

3Speaker 3
14:48.00 – 14:52.94

Danny Hensel produced today's podcast with help from Martin Patience and Fernando Naro.

14:53.50 – 14:54.78

Michael Ratcliffe directed.

5Speaker 5
14:55.16 – 15:01.28

And Ed McNulty edited, along with Krishna Dev Kalimer, James Heider, and Catherine Fox.

3Speaker 3
15:01.46 – 15:05.88

Our technical director is Hannah Glovner, with engineering support from Carly Strange,

15:06.02 – 15:08.66

Nisa Hynes, and Jobi Tenseko.

5Speaker 5
15:09.02 – 15:11.50

Evie Stone is our senior supervising editor.

15:11.80 – 15:14.26

Sarah Oliver is our executive producer.

15:14.76 – 15:17.32

Jim Kane is our deputy managing editor.

3Speaker 3
15:17.84 – 15:23.06

Tomorrow on Up First, the promise and the peril of solar geoengineering.

5Speaker 5
15:23.16 – 15:28.22

And this weekend on Weekend Edition, ransomware and insurance companies, grizzlies and the

15:28.22 – 15:32.32

Cascades, and what's behind the moves against TikTok, and more.

3Speaker 3
15:32.56 – 15:35.36

It's more of the news you need, you want, you crave.

5Speaker 5
15:35.76 – 15:36.86

You gotta have it.

3Speaker 3
15:37.02 – 15:40.44

Find your NPR station at stations.npr.org.

5Speaker 5
15:55.26 – 15:57.10

What's happening on NPR Podcasts?

1Speaker 1
15:57.10 – 15:57.28

Money.

15:57.50 – 15:57.72

Power.

15:58.02 – 15:58.50

Tacos.

15:58.66 – 15:59.52

White colloquium.

15:59.68 – 16:00.36

Green party.

5Speaker 5
16:00.48 – 16:01.38

Black reparations.

16:01.58 – 16:05.02

More of the perspectives that make your world a more vibrant place.

1Speaker 1
16:05.22 – 16:06.62

NPR Podcasts.

5Speaker 5
16:06.66 – 16:07.38

More voices.

16:07.56 – 16:08.26

All ears.

16:08.42 – 16:10.28

Find NPR wherever you get your podcasts.

4Speaker 4
16:10.50 – 16:15.68

The NPR app cuts through the noise, bringing you local, national, and global coverage.

16:15.68 – 16:17.00

No paywalls.

16:17.00 – 16:18.00

No profits.

16:18.20 – 16:19.10

No nonsense.

16:19.58 – 16:21.34

Download it in your app store today.

v1.0.0.260408-1-a910ba6_os