Hamas Leader Killed, Harvard's President Resigns, NRA Trial in New York

2024-01-03 00:13:45

NPR's Up First is the news you need to start your day. The three biggest stories of the day, with reporting and analysis from NPR News — in 10 minutes. Available weekdays at 6:30 a.m. ET, with hosts Leila Fadel, Steve Inskeep, Michel Martin and A Martinez. Also available on Saturdays at 9 a.m. ET, with Ayesha Rascoe and Scott Simon. On Sundays, hear a longer exploration behind the headlines with Ayesha Rascoe on "The Sunday Story," available by 8 a.m. ET. Subscribe and listen, then support your local NPR station at donate.npr.org.<br><br><em>Support NPR's reporting by subscribing to Up First+ and unlock sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org/upfirst</em>

2Speaker 2
00:02.48 – 00:06.78

A top Hamas leader was killed in Lebanon's capital of Beirut.

00:07.00 – 00:10.96

The militant group accused Israel of carrying out the drone strike that killed him, as did

00:10.96 – 00:11.90

Lebanese leaders.

00:12.32 – 00:15.30

Could this attack in Lebanon trigger a wider war?

00:15.52 – 00:18.68

I'm Laila Fadl, and this is Up First from NPR News.

00:21.54 – 00:25.38

Harvard's president has resigned after just six months on the job.

00:25.38 – 00:31.40

Claudine Gay had come under fire for her congressional testimony about anti-Semitism on campus and

00:31.40 – 00:33.04

allegations of plagiarism.

00:33.52 – 00:37.68

Does her departure point to an even bigger political battle across academia?

00:38.16 – 00:42.82

Plus New York's attorney general is hoping to oust the National Rifle Association's

00:42.82 – 00:46.78

longtime leader, Wayne LaPierre, from his position on corruption charges.

00:47.14 – 00:48.52

How strong is her case?

00:48.92 – 00:49.46

Stay with us.

00:49.54 – 00:51.46

We'll give you the news you need to start your day.

3Speaker 3
00:58.66 – 01:03.70

If you're hearing this, that means you haven't gone sponsor-free with NPR+.

01:04.42 – 01:10.84

Join us on the Plus side for awesome podcast perks across more than 20 NPR podcasts, including

2Speaker 2
01:10.84 – 01:15.22

bonus episodes, behind-the-scenes content, sponsor-free listening, and more.

3Speaker 3
01:15.76 – 01:19.44

Learn more and sign up at plus.npr.org.

01:19.74 – 01:21.44

And never hear this promo again.

2Speaker 2
01:22.40 – 01:26.00

On the TED Radio Hour, MIT psychologist Sherry Turkle.

01:26.46 – 01:31.98

Her latest research into the intimate relationships people are having with chatbots.

1Speaker 1
01:32.36 – 01:39.54

Technologies that say, I care about you, I love you, I'm here for you, take care of me.

2Speaker 2
01:39.96 – 01:43.04

The pros and cons of artificial intimacy.

01:43.36 – 01:45.66

That's on the TED Radio Hour from NPR.

01:46.46 – 01:52.64

A senior Hamas leader and six other members of its armed wing were killed in an explosion

01:52.64 – 01:53.40

in Lebanon.

5Speaker 5
01:53.80 – 01:58.06

Lebanon blames Israel, which has not claimed responsibility for the attack.

01:58.36 – 02:03.12

It's the first such killing after Israel vowed to target Hamas officials in other countries

02:03.12 – 02:07.30

after the militant Palestinian group's October 7th attack on Israel.

02:07.46 – 02:12.26

And Lebanese leaders have warned that the assassination could open another front in

02:12.26 – 02:13.02

the war on Gaza.

2Speaker 2
02:13.58 – 02:16.88

NPR's Jane Araf joins us now to discuss this from Amman, Jordan.

02:17.06 – 02:17.50

Hi, Jane.

1Speaker 1
02:18.02 – 02:18.72

Hi, Laila.

2Speaker 2
02:18.92 – 02:21.84

So what do we know about what happened in Lebanon?

1Speaker 1
02:22.62 – 02:28.40

According to the Lebanese government, an Israeli drone targeted an office building in a southern

02:28.40 – 02:30.02

suburb of Beirut Tuesday.

02:30.80 – 02:34.06

Hamas announced the explosion killed Saleh al-Aruri.

02:34.48 – 02:39.38

He's deputy head, he was deputy head of its political bureau and one of the founders of

02:39.38 – 02:41.58

the organization's military wing.

02:41.58 – 02:47.32

And that's significant because it's one thing to target Hamas leaders in Gaza, where war

02:47.32 – 02:53.14

between Hamas and Israel has been raging for three months, but it's another to launch attacks

02:53.14 – 02:55.06

in the capital of another country.

02:55.66 – 03:01.20

Israel and Hezbollah, that Iran-backed Lebanese militia, have been attacking each other across

03:01.20 – 03:05.94

the Lebanese border since the start of the war in Gaza, but so far they've stayed within

03:05.94 – 03:08.58

a fairly limited zone around that border.

2Speaker 2
03:08.58 – 03:12.62

Yeah, I mean, you mentioned this is really different to attack in a capital of another

03:12.62 – 03:13.00

country.

03:13.18 – 03:16.70

How have officials in Lebanon reacted to these killings?

1Speaker 1
03:16.84 – 03:18.38

Well, there's a lot of worry.

03:18.72 – 03:23.18

Lebanon's prime minister, Najib Makati, has said the attack is aimed at opening a new

03:23.18 – 03:28.66

phase in the conflict at the Lebanese border, and he's asking the UN Security Council to

03:28.66 – 03:31.02

condemn the breach of Lebanese sovereignty.

03:31.74 – 03:36.22

We have to note that Israel hasn't claimed responsibility for the attack, as you mentioned.

03:36.82 – 03:44.02

Mark Regev, an advisor to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, said in an MSNBC interview

03:44.02 – 03:49.14

that whoever did it was not targeting Lebanon or Hezbollah.

03:50.00 – 03:56.02

But the big danger is that Hezbollah will likely feel compelled to respond in some way,

03:56.18 – 04:00.84

and if it does escalate, Iran, which backs Hezbollah, could get involved.

04:01.52 – 04:07.76

Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah has said in the past that any assassinations in Lebanon

04:07.76 – 04:12.60

will incur retaliation, and he's giving a speech this evening in Lebanon.

04:13.00 – 04:18.30

That speech, to commemorate the U.S. killing of Iranian General Qasem Soleimani in Baghdad

04:18.30 – 04:24.06

four years ago, happens on an already tense anniversary, but that might give us some picture

04:24.06 – 04:24.78

of what's ahead.

2Speaker 2
04:25.20 – 04:25.48

Okay.

04:25.88 – 04:29.74

What more do we know about this senior Hamas leader, Arouri?

1Speaker 1
04:30.54 – 04:35.34

Well, he was 57 years old, a sheikh who studied Islamic jurisprudence in the West Bank.

04:35.76 – 04:40.54

He spent years in Israeli jail, and he became one of the founders of the military wing of

04:40.54 – 04:47.80

Hamas, which was established after the Palestinian uprising in 1987 against Israeli occupation.

04:48.24 – 04:53.86

He was deported in Turkey, and in Lebanon, importantly, he was the main liaison with

04:53.86 – 04:59.72

Hezbollah, and is credited with building relations with Iran, a Shia Muslim country, while Hamas

04:59.72 – 05:00.92

is Sunni Muslim.

05:01.48 – 05:06.56

He was also involved in negotiations in Doha over a ceasefire in Gaza and the release of

05:06.56 – 05:09.66

Israeli hostages, which could complicate things.

2Speaker 2
05:10.26 – 05:13.82

And very quickly, I mean, we talked a lot about Lebanon, but what's been the reaction

05:13.82 – 05:16.00

among Palestinians to this killing?

1Speaker 1
05:16.32 – 05:21.02

Lots of demonstrations in the West Bank and general strikes in several West Bank cities

05:21.02 – 05:27.58

to protest, but the day is still young, and that killing really does raise tensions around

05:27.58 – 05:28.06

the region.

2Speaker 2
05:28.60 – 05:31.20

NPR's Jane Araf talking to us from Amman, Jordan.

05:31.36 – 05:32.12

Thank you so much, Jane.

1Speaker 1
05:32.36 – 05:33.00

Thank you.

2Speaker 2
05:42.34 – 05:46.28

The search is on for a new president of Harvard University.

5Speaker 5
05:46.56 – 05:51.50

Yes, six months after she took the job, Claudine Gay, Harvard's first black president, resigned

05:51.50 – 05:51.98

yesterday.

05:52.48 – 05:56.80

She's been taking a lot of heat for her comments to a congressional committee about anti-Semitism

05:56.80 – 06:00.70

on campus and accusations of plagiarism in her past academic work.

2Speaker 2
06:00.98 – 06:04.56

NPR's Tovia Smith has been following the story, and she joins us now.

06:04.62 – 06:05.04

Hi, Tovia.

3Speaker 3
06:05.42 – 06:05.90

Hi there.

2Speaker 2
06:06.18 – 06:11.26

So what was it that pushed Gay to resign all these weeks later after the congressional

06:11.26 – 06:11.64

hearing?

3Speaker 3
06:11.78 – 06:16.50

Well, it seems it was these multiple allegations of plagiarism that ultimately brought her

06:16.50 – 06:16.82

down.

06:17.22 – 06:22.38

There was, of course, fierce backlash to her testimony last month after she said that calls

06:22.38 – 06:26.72

for genocide against Jews would not necessarily violate campus rules.

06:26.86 – 06:28.80

But at that point, Harvard still had her back.

06:29.18 – 06:33.38

Things really seem to have changed this week when we learned of even more allegations that

06:33.38 – 06:35.94

she lifted chunks of language without attribution.

06:36.44 – 06:41.30

In her resignation statement, Gay said it was difficult beyond words to have doubt cast

06:41.30 – 06:46.40

on not only her commitment to confronting hate, but also now on her scholarly rigor.

06:46.40 – 06:49.38

And she said she's resigning so as not to be a distraction.

2Speaker 2
06:49.38 – 06:54.12

Now, I know this is happening during Harvard's winter break, and so there's not really anyone

06:54.12 – 06:54.60

on campus.

06:54.78 – 06:56.72

What kind of reaction are you hearing?

3Speaker 3
06:57.36 – 06:58.08

Well, it's split.

06:58.20 – 07:01.72

There are those who've been calling for Gay's resignation all along who say they're thrilled

07:01.72 – 07:03.32

now that she's finally gone.

07:03.72 – 07:08.28

That includes a Harvard grad student I spoke to named Shabbes Kestenbaum.

6Speaker 6
07:08.88 – 07:14.46

Whether it was her disastrous congressional testimony, whether it was her inability to

07:14.46 – 07:21.30

enforce policies about anti-Semitism on campus, or whether it was creating a hostile culture

07:21.30 – 07:26.34

at Harvard where people don't feel that they have the ability to exchange ideologies that

07:26.34 – 07:32.42

are not in favor at the moment, just time and time again, she did the wrong thing.

3Speaker 3
07:33.16 – 07:36.94

And I'll add that many people who've called for Gay's ouster have said that Harvard's

07:36.94 – 07:39.96

problem is not a single person, but a culture.

07:39.96 – 07:45.68

And that was also echoed by Elise Stefanik, the congresswoman who grilled Gay and the

07:45.68 – 07:47.90

presidents of Penn and MIT at that hearing.

07:48.42 – 07:53.32

Stefanik said in a statement that her investigations would continue into what she called a woke

07:53.32 – 07:57.56

agenda and political bias at Harvard and at other campuses.

2Speaker 2
07:57.84 – 08:03.20

Okay, so how much do those comments from Stefanik about Harvard actually point to a bigger, broader

08:03.20 – 08:04.54

political battle here?

3Speaker 3
08:04.92 – 08:05.78

Very much.

08:05.78 – 08:10.58

As one faculty member I spoke to put it, this is not about Harvard, it's about New Hampshire

08:10.58 – 08:11.38

and Iowa.

08:11.92 – 08:18.00

Or as another put it, the committee is using the pretext of fighting anti-Semitism to actually

08:18.00 – 08:23.26

fight DEI, or diversity, equity, and inclusion, as well as to fight how schools approach things

08:23.26 – 08:24.26

like race and gender.

08:24.68 – 08:29.90

I spoke with Harvard professor Khalil Gibran Muhammad, who called Gay's resignation a terrible

08:29.90 – 08:31.18

moment for higher ed.

6Speaker 6
08:31.18 – 08:37.28

That is the witch hunt that is unfolding right now, where the argument has now been extended

08:37.28 – 08:44.34

in plotting Gay as a first black woman, as a diversity hire, who is supposedly unqualified

08:44.34 – 08:50.18

as proof that Harvard had lowered its standards and was being ruined from within.

08:50.58 – 08:53.40

And that is not going to stop at Harvard.

3Speaker 3
08:54.02 – 08:59.40

Gay herself noted in her statement that she's faced personal attacks, quote, fueled by racial

08:59.40 – 09:03.56

animus, and Harvard's board also cited racist vitriol directed at her.

2Speaker 2
09:04.14 – 09:07.10

So now that Gay is out, what happens next?

09:07.12 – 09:07.86

Who leads Harvard?

09:08.26 – 09:11.06

The battle over what speech is protected on campus?

3Speaker 3
09:12.18 – 09:17.24

Yeah, Gay stays at Harvard as a tenured faculty member and an interim president takes her

09:17.24 – 09:22.62

job until a permanent one is found, but no, don't expect her resignation to be the end

09:22.62 – 09:28.30

of it, either in terms of the tussle over what's taught on college campuses or on where

09:28.30 – 09:31.56

to draw the line between protected speech and hate speech on campus.

2Speaker 2
09:31.84 – 09:32.80

NPR's Tovia Smith.

09:32.94 – 09:33.38

Thanks, Tovia.

3Speaker 3
09:33.90 – 09:34.40

Thank you.

2Speaker 2
09:42.86 – 09:47.22

Jury selection began yesterday in a civil trial in New York that could transform the

09:47.22 – 09:50.44

National Rifle Association, the nation's largest gun rights group.

5Speaker 5
09:50.74 – 09:56.46

Yeah, New York Attorney General Letitia James is hoping to oust longtime NRA leader Wayne

09:56.46 – 09:58.16

LaPierre on corruption charges.

09:58.32 – 09:59.50

He's denied any wrongdoing.

10:00.00 – 10:03.56

Three other current and former NRA leaders are also named in the suit.

2Speaker 2
10:03.98 – 10:06.48

NPR's Brian Mann is covering this and joins us now.

10:06.56 – 10:06.90

Hi, Brian.

4Speaker 4
10:07.42 – 10:07.98

Hey, good morning.

2Speaker 2
10:08.26 – 10:08.64

Good morning.

10:08.74 – 10:10.86

So what are the accusations Wayne LaPierre is facing?

4Speaker 4
10:11.96 – 10:16.44

You know, the NRA was once one of the biggest political forces in Washington and in state

10:16.44 – 10:17.62

capitals around the country.

10:17.72 – 10:22.72

The organization really succeeded for decades under LaPierre's leadership, pushing the gun

10:22.72 – 10:27.34

control debate to the right, blocking gun control measures even after catastrophic mass

10:27.34 – 10:29.16

shootings like Sandy Hook and Parkland.

10:29.68 – 10:34.66

But beginning in 2019, the organization began to unravel with internal feuds and accusations

10:34.66 – 10:35.44

of corruption.

10:36.08 – 10:40.02

New York's Attorney General Letitia James began investigating, and her team says they

10:40.02 – 10:46.62

found evidence that more than $64 million in cash from NRA donors was misused by LaPierre

10:46.62 – 10:47.42

and other leaders.

10:47.74 – 10:51.64

The lawsuit claims the organization became a personal piggy bank, paying for things like

10:51.64 – 10:53.46

private jet flights to the Bahamas.

10:54.24 – 10:58.24

This is a civil lawsuit, so there's no risk of jail time or criminal penalties for LaPierre

10:58.24 – 10:59.92

or the three others named in the suit.

11:00.00 – 11:04.90

But if the NRA loses this case, LaPierre could be ousted after more than 30 years at the

11:04.90 – 11:10.06

helm, and New York officials would also gain a lot more regulatory oversight over the NRA's

11:10.06 – 11:10.72

activities.

2Speaker 2
11:11.24 – 11:13.52

What do LaPierre and the NRA say about these claims?

4Speaker 4
11:14.60 – 11:18.78

Well, in the outset, they've argued that this is an attempt to silence and weaken a conservative

11:18.78 – 11:19.58

pro-gun group.

11:19.58 – 11:22.92

Basically, they say it's a political attack by a Democratic Attorney General.

11:23.52 – 11:27.18

The NRA tried repeatedly to have this case dismissed on those grounds, but their arguments

11:27.18 – 11:28.82

have been rejected by appeals courts.

11:28.98 – 11:30.36

So now we're going to trial.

11:30.58 – 11:35.04

It is important to note that this case and the growing controversy surrounding LaPierre

11:35.04 – 11:37.32

have already really crippled the NRA.

11:37.56 – 11:41.66

Since the lawsuit was filed in 2020, they've lost millions of members.

11:41.82 – 11:47.02

The NRA shut down their juggernaut media operation, even attempted once to file for bankruptcy.

11:47.02 – 11:52.58

And LaPierre, who's 74 years old now, he used to be a really high-profile player in American

11:52.58 – 11:58.10

politics, courted by presidents, and his personal influence has clearly waned because of all

11:58.10 – 11:58.48

of this.

2Speaker 2
11:58.88 – 12:03.36

Okay, so it seems like the NRA is back on its heels here, facing serious legal peril.

12:03.52 – 12:06.94

How has that affected the wider debate over gun rights and gun safety?

4Speaker 4
12:07.80 – 12:08.60

Yeah, this is interesting.

12:08.74 – 12:12.90

Before the NRA was hit by internal dissent and these legal troubles, a lot of their beliefs

12:12.90 – 12:17.58

about gun regulations had really been adopted wholesale by the Republican Party and by

12:17.58 – 12:19.36

many of the GOP's core voters.

12:19.52 – 12:25.00

So while the NRA's direct influences faded, we haven't seen big changes to the politics

12:25.00 – 12:25.84

of gun control.

12:26.38 – 12:31.50

Despite the growing number of mass shootings in America, daily gun violence in some cities,

12:31.70 – 12:37.16

and also polls showing broad public support for things like universal background checks,

12:37.78 – 12:42.38

the GOP's largely stuck to their argument that almost all gun regulations violate the

12:42.38 – 12:42.92

Second Amendment.

12:43.72 – 12:48.94

So the NRA is a shadow of itself as this case goes to trial, but the NRA's ideas, they're

12:48.94 – 12:50.44

still incredibly influential.

2Speaker 2
12:51.00 – 12:53.38

NPR's Brian Mann, thanks for your reporting, Brian.

4Speaker 4
12:53.82 – 12:54.56

Thank you.

2Speaker 2
12:58.68 – 13:01.34

And that's Up First for Wednesday, January 3rd.

13:01.36 – 13:02.30

I'm Laila Faldal.

13:02.42 – 13:07.80

Today's episode of Up First was edited by Mark Katkov, Michael Sullivan, Catherine Laidlaw,

13:07.94 – 13:09.08

and Andrea DeLeon.

13:09.08 – 13:12.44

It was produced by Ziad Butch, Ben Abrams, and Taylor Haney.

13:12.74 – 13:17.74

We get engineering support from Nisha Hynes, and our technical director is Zach Coleman.

13:18.22 – 13:21.08

The NPR app lets you keep public radio in your pocket.

13:21.56 – 13:25.82

You'll find a mix of local, national, and international news, plus the best podcasts

13:25.82 – 13:26.92

from the NPR network.

13:27.30 – 13:28.28

Download the NPR app.

v1.0.0.260408-1-a910ba6_os