Israel Expands Military Operation, SCOTUS Hears Purdue Pharma Case, Liz Cheney

2023-12-04 00:13:56

NPR's Up First is the news you need to start your day. The three biggest stories of the day, with reporting and analysis from NPR News — in 10 minutes. Available weekdays at 6:30 a.m. ET, with hosts Leila Fadel, Steve Inskeep, Michel Martin and A Martinez. Also available on Saturdays at 9 a.m. ET, with Ayesha Rascoe and Scott Simon. On Sundays, hear a longer exploration behind the headlines with Ayesha Rascoe on "The Sunday Story," available by 8 a.m. ET. Subscribe and listen, then support your local NPR station at donate.npr.org.<br><br><em>Support NPR's reporting by subscribing to Up First+ and unlock sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org/upfirst</em>

4Speaker 4
00:02.72 – 00:07.96

Israel says it expanded its ground defensive against Hamas to all parts of Gaza.

1Speaker 1
00:08.26 – 00:12.68

This includes the occupied territory's southern areas where people fled to in the early days of the war.

00:13.02 – 00:14.96

So what does this mean for the civilians in Gaza?

4Speaker 4
00:15.16 – 00:19.10

I'm Stephen Skeap with Michelle Martin, and this is Up First from NPR News.

00:21.16 – 00:25.66

Today the Supreme Court hears arguments for and against a bankruptcy settlement.

00:25.66 – 00:29.80

It involves Purdue Pharma, maker of the pain medication OxyContin.

00:30.20 – 00:33.50

Can members of the Sackler family limit their liability?

1Speaker 1
00:33.90 – 00:40.00

And former Wyoming Congresswoman Liz Cheney warns our co-host Leila Fadl about the threat of a second Trump presidency.

5Speaker 5
00:40.36 – 00:44.02

I think the danger is that great, that that needs to be everybody's top priority.

1Speaker 1
00:44.46 – 00:47.90

She makes the case against the Trump-led Republican Party in her new book.

00:48.24 – 00:50.32

Stay with us. We'll give you the news you need to start your day.

3Speaker 3
01:00.92 – 01:05.96

If you're hearing this, that means you haven't gone sponsor-free with NPR+.

01:05.96 – 01:12.40

Join us on the Plus side for awesome podcast perks across more than 20 NPR podcasts,

01:12.68 – 01:17.46

including bonus episodes, behind-the-scenes content, sponsor-free listening, and more.

01:18.00 – 01:21.68

Learn more and sign up at plus.npr.org.

2Speaker 2
01:21.98 – 01:23.68

And never hear this promo again.

6Speaker 6
01:24.68 – 01:28.24

On the TED Radio Hour, MIT psychologist Sherry Turkle.

01:28.68 – 01:34.22

Her latest research into the intimate relationships people are having with chatbots.

3Speaker 3
01:34.62 – 01:41.78

Technologies that say, I care about you, I love you, I'm here for you, take care of me.

6Speaker 6
01:42.22 – 01:45.30

The pros and cons of artificial intimacy.

01:45.50 – 01:47.84

That's on the TED Radio Hour from NPR.

1Speaker 1
01:49.22 – 01:53.16

Israel's military says it has expanded its ground offensive in Gaza

01:53.16 – 01:56.92

and is now targeting Hamas strongholds all across the Gaza Strip.

4Speaker 4
01:57.36 – 02:01.70

Israeli forces are telling people to flee some areas to avoid those strikes.

02:02.38 – 02:03.42

And that is the hard part.

02:03.78 – 02:07.94

Many civilians have already moved from northern Gaza to the south

02:07.94 – 02:12.18

and may now face demands to leave the same areas to which they fled.

1Speaker 1
02:12.76 – 02:15.94

Joining us now with more is NPR's Eleanor Beardsley in Tel Aviv.

02:15.94 – 02:16.68

Eleanor, hello.

2Speaker 2
02:17.60 – 02:17.98

Hello.

1Speaker 1
02:18.24 – 02:21.62

So the fighting resumed on Friday after the ceasefire broke down.

02:21.84 – 02:25.08

Would you just start by telling us more about Israel's stepped-up operations?

2Speaker 2
02:26.18 – 02:26.36

Yes.

02:26.46 – 02:29.72

Well, Israel says it's hit hundreds of Hamas targets overnight

02:29.72 – 02:32.02

as its forces pushed deeper into Gaza.

02:32.40 – 02:36.14

And there were multiple strikes in and around the southern Gaza city of Hanounis

02:36.14 – 02:38.86

where the top Hamas leadership is believed to be located,

02:39.06 – 02:42.98

including Yahya Sinwar, who orchestrated the October 7th attack.

02:42.98 – 02:47.24

Israeli media is reporting that any fighting in Hanounis will be complicated

02:47.24 – 02:50.72

not only by the hundreds of thousands of people who have fled from the north,

02:50.86 – 02:52.98

but also by the fact that some of the Israeli hostages

02:53.62 – 02:55.72

are believed to be held somewhere around the city.

02:56.22 – 02:59.56

Here's Israeli military spokesman Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari.

03:02.88 – 03:07.54

Yeah, so he says the Israeli forces are fighting Hamas terrorists face to face

03:07.54 – 03:09.50

wherever they are and killing them.

03:09.50 – 03:14.52

The Israeli military said that it has found 800 Hamas tunnels since the beginning of the war,

03:14.80 – 03:17.52

and it claims to have destroyed 500 of them.

1Speaker 1
03:17.64 – 03:21.36

So, Eleanor, as we already mentioned, Israel is telling many people in the areas

03:21.36 – 03:25.54

that it is targeting to leave, but how and where are they supposed to go?

03:25.60 – 03:29.84

We're already hearing that this latest evacuation warning is causing a lot of confusion and anger.

2Speaker 2
03:30.72 – 03:31.64

Yeah, that's right.

03:31.72 – 03:36.86

I mean, the Israeli army is claiming to have published a very detailed digital map online

03:36.86 – 03:38.88

to help people get to safer places.

03:38.88 – 03:40.82

And they've also dropped leaflets.

03:41.32 – 03:44.48

You know, they're urging people to go east or west toward the sea,

03:44.58 – 03:47.06

but you can't go any farther south, so it's difficult.

03:47.60 – 03:51.46

NPR's producer in Gaza, Anas Baba, spoke with Gazans yesterday.

03:51.90 – 03:54.96

Here's Bassel Bassouni. He's an engineer and a father.

03:55.32 – 03:59.24

He's putting up a tent for his family in Rafah. He's just fled Hanounis.

03:59.40 – 04:03.20

He says there are no words to describe the horrible conditions and what's happening.

04:09.34 – 04:11.54

He says there are more than 100 families here,

04:11.60 – 04:14.76

and the last two nights were the most terrible in my life, he told NPR.

04:15.20 – 04:19.46

Bassouni says he and his five children watched as the sky was lit up with bombing.

1Speaker 1
04:19.88 – 04:20.72

Well, what about Israelis?

04:20.80 – 04:23.52

What are you hearing Israelis saying about this renewed fighting?

2Speaker 2
04:24.54 – 04:28.12

Well, some Israelis will tell you that it's just time to get rid of Hamas once and for all,

04:28.18 – 04:32.32

but here in Tel Aviv the prevailing sentiment seems to be that getting the hostages out

04:32.32 – 04:34.54

is more important than the war, and it should come first.

04:34.54 – 04:40.38

I was at a massive rally in Tel Aviv over the weekend for the more than 100 hostages still in Gaza.

04:41.00 – 04:42.28

Hadass Calderon spoke.

04:42.44 – 04:46.70

Her two children, ages 12 and 16, were kidnapped from a kibbutz and just released.

04:46.84 – 04:47.66

Here she is.

04:50.96 – 04:57.80

Mom, you're alive, is the first thing my kid said to me, she tells the crowd.

04:57.94 – 05:02.20

And her kids thought she'd been killed when they were separated in the October 7th Hamas attack.

05:02.20 – 05:06.56

And Calderon told the crowd, we can't leave the hostages there in the dark and helpless.

1Speaker 1
05:06.96 – 05:10.34

And briefly, Eleanor, you were in the Israeli-occupied West Bank over the weekend.

05:10.42 – 05:11.56

What are people saying there?

2Speaker 2
05:12.18 – 05:16.12

Well, people feel frustrated and there's powerlessness over what's happening in Gaza.

05:16.24 – 05:19.50

I spoke with 70-year-old Ahmad Omar, a jeweler in Ramallah.

05:19.64 – 05:20.98

He described how people feel.

1Speaker 1
05:21.24 – 05:22.74

They feel so bad about Gaza.

05:23.08 – 05:26.18

You know, it's affecting everybody because they're Palestinians, you know, the same people.

6Speaker 6
05:26.40 – 05:27.82

We can't do nothing about it.

3Speaker 3
05:28.06 – 05:29.80

They bombarded it so much.

05:29.80 – 05:30.84

We see little kids.

1Speaker 1
05:31.22 – 05:31.64

It's hard.

2Speaker 2
05:32.18 – 05:35.14

You know, tensions have risen in the West Bank since October 7th.

05:35.38 – 05:41.18

And Israeli human rights groups say that 250 Palestinians have been killed since then.

05:41.46 – 05:44.16

One told me it was a pressure cooker ready to explode.

1Speaker 1
05:44.44 – 05:46.26

That's NPR's Eleanor Beardley in Tel Aviv.

05:46.36 – 05:47.06

Eleanor, thank you.

2Speaker 2
05:47.52 – 05:48.12

You're welcome.

4Speaker 4
05:56.94 – 06:00.06

The Supreme Court meets the opioid crisis today.

1Speaker 1
06:00.58 – 06:03.34

The justices hear arguments and a challenge to the bankruptcy deal

06:03.34 – 06:06.82

that was meant to compensate victims of the addictive painkiller OxyContin.

4Speaker 4
06:07.20 – 06:10.44

NPR legal affairs correspondent Nina Totenberg is covering the story.

06:10.52 – 06:11.02

Nina, good morning.

3Speaker 3
06:11.16 – 06:11.90

Good morning, Steve.

4Speaker 4
06:11.92 – 06:12.86

What's this case about?

3Speaker 3
06:13.50 – 06:17.82

Well, you know, today we know that Purdue Pharma actively pushed

06:17.82 – 06:18.10

a bill called the Affordable Care Act.

06:18.10 – 06:22.40

without telling people what they were doing.

06:23.04 – 06:29.32

That's documented in court and in a documentary called Crime of the Century.

4Speaker 4
06:29.72 – 06:31.46

This was a new drug cartel.

06:32.14 – 06:35.12

They were drug dealers wearing suits and lab coats.

3Speaker 3
06:35.82 – 06:39.38

By 2020, Purdue Pharma pleaded guilty to three criminal charges,

06:39.98 – 06:44.20

and the company agreed that it owed $8 billion in criminal and civil fines,

06:44.20 – 06:47.46

most of which were to be paid to state and local governments

06:47.46 – 06:50.10

handling the fallout from the opioid crisis.

06:50.60 – 06:53.02

And most of that money was conditioned on the company

06:53.02 – 06:57.02

reaching a deal in bankruptcy court that would reimburse the victims.

4Speaker 4
06:57.20 – 06:59.10

Okay, so I'd heard about all of that.

06:59.22 – 07:03.78

Is a challenge to that arrangement what the Supreme Court is now considering?

3Speaker 3
07:04.30 – 07:04.74

Correct.

07:05.32 – 07:08.76

The question at the center of the case is whether the bankruptcy court

07:08.76 – 07:12.60

has the authority to release the Sacklers from liability,

07:12.60 – 07:16.92

despite the fact that all three of the original Sackler brothers

07:16.92 – 07:21.02

who bought Purdue and ultimately developed OxyContin were doctors,

07:21.52 – 07:24.18

and that six Sacklers sat on the board of the company,

07:24.60 – 07:26.54

including the board chair Richard Sackler,

07:26.64 – 07:29.60

who closely directed the firm's aggressive and deceptive

07:30.52 – 07:32.36

OxyContin marketing strategy.

4Speaker 4
07:32.68 – 07:36.10

Okay, so the question is whether the court had the power,

07:36.20 – 07:38.40

but don't courts have a lot of power in these cases?

3Speaker 3
07:38.78 – 07:41.78

They do, but the question of releasing from liability

07:41.78 – 07:46.34

a whole category of guilty players is one that's not been decided

07:46.34 – 07:47.34

by the Supreme Court.

07:47.60 – 07:51.60

In this case, the Sacklers at first offered $4 billion for the settlement,

07:51.78 – 07:53.28

then moved it up to $6 billion.

07:53.74 – 07:57.80

But the Justice Department trustee who oversees bankruptcy cases

07:57.80 – 08:01.66

in New York, Connecticut, and Vermont still objected to the deal.

08:02.24 – 08:05.78

And defending that position today, the Biden administration will argue

08:05.78 – 08:09.62

that the bankruptcy law does not authorize bankruptcy courts

08:09.62 – 08:14.38

to approve or release from liability for third parties like the Sacklers

08:14.38 – 08:18.68

who have not declared bankruptcy and still have at least half their wealth

08:18.68 – 08:21.18

and probably more if the deal is approved.

4Speaker 4
08:21.54 – 08:24.46

Okay, so the Biden administration is taking the view that the Sacklers

08:24.46 – 08:28.44

shouldn't get away with whatever they still are getting away with.

08:28.80 – 08:30.34

What are the basing arguments on each side?

3Speaker 3
08:31.26 – 08:34.88

Those opposing the settlement deal say that the Sacklers are effectively

08:34.88 – 08:37.64

getting the rewards of a bankruptcy at half price,

08:37.64 – 08:41.48

but they're still able to keep more than half of their money and assets,

08:41.66 – 08:44.66

and they can't be sued personally, so they'll never have to testify

08:44.66 – 08:46.40

about their misdeeds.

08:46.92 – 08:50.18

Georgetown Law professor Adam Levitin puts it this way.

4Speaker 4
08:50.60 – 08:54.36

Bankruptcy is supposed to provide relief for honest but unfortunate debtors.

08:54.58 – 08:58.20

They come clean about their assets, and they give up all of their assets

08:58.20 – 08:59.08

to their creditors.

08:59.70 – 09:01.96

And the Sacklers are not doing either of those things.

3Speaker 3
09:02.34 – 09:06.68

The other side acknowledges that bankruptcies can be messy, like this one,

09:06.68 – 09:11.72

but it's the only way to get all the players and the victims in one tent

09:11.72 – 09:13.54

and provide some real compensation.

09:14.38 – 09:17.86

And if the Supreme Court vetoes the bankruptcy, there's no guarantee

09:17.86 – 09:21.98

that victims will actually be compensated because the Sacklers have hidden

09:21.98 – 09:24.98

their wealth in foreign banks that are very difficult to access.

09:25.50 – 09:30.36

And at best, getting to that money would take years and potentially burn

09:30.36 – 09:33.42

millions if not billions of dollars in legal fees.

4Speaker 4
09:33.42 – 09:35.20

NPR's Nina Totenberg, thanks so much.

3Speaker 3
09:35.30 – 09:35.90

Thank you, Steve.

1Speaker 1
09:42.72 – 09:46.08

Former Wyoming Congresswoman Liz Cheney is sounding a warning

09:46.08 – 09:47.98

about former President Donald Trump.

4Speaker 4
09:48.04 – 09:52.26

Yeah, she told our colleague Leila Fadl it would be the end of democracy

09:52.26 – 09:55.32

in this country if Trump is elected again.

09:56.10 – 09:58.96

Cheney used to be the number three House Republican, a post she lost

09:58.96 – 10:02.16

when she turned against Trump for his effort to stay in office

10:02.16 – 10:05.38

after he lost the presidential election in 2020.

1Speaker 1
10:05.70 – 10:08.14

She spoke to Leila ahead of the release of her new book,

10:08.20 – 10:11.24

which comes out tomorrow, and Leila is with us now to give us a preview.

10:11.34 – 10:11.68

Good morning.

6Speaker 6
10:11.92 – 10:12.58

Good morning, Michelle.

1Speaker 1
10:12.86 – 10:15.78

You had a pretty thorough conversation with her, and I know you read her book.

10:15.88 – 10:16.98

What was your biggest takeaway?

6Speaker 6
10:17.54 – 10:20.46

I mean, biggest takeaway is that Cheney's making it her mission

10:20.46 – 10:23.02

to make sure Trump is not reelected.

10:23.10 – 10:24.80

Let's listen to some of our conversation.

10:25.22 – 10:28.18

Are you considering a run for the presidency in 2024?

5Speaker 5
10:28.86 – 10:30.90

I haven't ruled it out.

10:30.90 – 10:35.94

I look at it, though, very much through the lens of stopping Donald Trump.

10:36.36 – 10:41.14

And so whatever it will take to do that is very much my focus.

10:41.32 – 10:44.94

I think the danger is that great that that needs to be everybody's top priority.

6Speaker 6
10:45.22 – 10:46.54

So her warning is stark.

10:46.70 – 10:49.92

She says, as Steve said, democracy in this country is at stake

10:49.92 – 10:51.56

if Trump is elected again.

10:51.64 – 10:54.96

And her book, Oath and Honor, is an accounting of what happened

10:54.96 – 10:58.72

inside her party in the weeks before and after the January 6th attack

10:58.72 – 11:01.16

on the Capitol by supporters of the former president.

11:01.72 – 11:04.22

And, Michelle, she does not hold back, calling her former colleagues

11:04.22 – 11:08.60

collaborators and enablers who knowingly went along with a lie

11:08.60 – 11:12.88

that the election was stolen in 2020 and a lie that led to the attack

11:12.88 – 11:13.42

on the Capitol.

11:13.52 – 11:16.78

And she writes in her book that Trump is the most dangerous man ever

11:16.78 – 11:18.48

to inhabit the Oval Office.

1Speaker 1
11:19.32 – 11:20.98

What about her former colleagues?

11:21.04 – 11:22.54

I mean, you said that she doesn't hold back there.

11:22.60 – 11:26.40

What about the Republican Party writ large, the party itself?

6Speaker 6
11:26.40 – 11:29.60

As you know, Michelle, Liz Cheney is a through-and-through conservative.

11:29.88 – 11:33.42

But she told me the Republican Party in its current form is not her party.

11:33.52 – 11:35.80

She calls it an anti-constitutional party.

11:36.20 – 11:39.12

And I asked her what she thought when she saw six out of eight

11:39.12 – 11:42.32

Republican White House hopefuls in a debate raise their hands

11:42.32 – 11:45.62

when asked if they'd support Trump as the Republican nominee

11:45.62 – 11:46.98

if he were convicted of a crime.

11:47.04 – 11:47.78

And here's what she said.

5Speaker 5
11:48.06 – 11:50.94

If the party goes down the path of nominating Donald Trump,

11:51.04 – 11:55.38

certainly the party itself will have lost any claim to be a party

11:55.38 – 11:58.28

that is, in fact, supportive of the Constitution.

1Speaker 1
11:58.86 – 12:01.28

You know, Layla, Cheney was part of the January 6th committee

12:01.28 – 12:03.22

which investigated the attack on the Capitol.

12:03.64 – 12:07.90

Does she think her work with that committee accomplished what it needed to?

6Speaker 6
12:08.22 – 12:11.82

You know, I asked her that, and she says that work was just the beginning.

12:12.08 – 12:14.50

It's why she wrote this book, she says, in which she calls out

12:14.50 – 12:17.18

the Republican Party leadership for being cowards,

12:17.52 – 12:19.92

who went along with Trump and risked the country's institutions,

12:20.08 – 12:21.08

is what she wrote.

12:21.32 – 12:24.68

And the danger, she says, is not in the rearview mirror.

5Speaker 5
12:24.68 – 12:27.22

There was an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal recently

12:27.22 – 12:30.56

where they suggested that even if Donald Trump were elected,

12:30.74 – 12:33.58

it wouldn't be that bad because, of course, we have these institutions

12:33.58 – 12:37.34

and we have these traditions and we have the separation of powers

12:37.34 – 12:40.68

and that people could somehow count on that to restrain him.

12:40.80 – 12:44.34

And one of the main messages of my book is, no, you can't.

12:44.40 – 12:47.12

You cannot count on those institutions to restrain him.

1Speaker 1
12:47.62 – 12:50.60

Well, looking forward to hearing more of what she said.

12:50.82 – 12:51.74

That's NPR's Layla Fowler.

12:51.84 – 12:52.54

Layla, thank you.

6Speaker 6
12:52.76 – 12:53.26

Thanks, Michelle.

1Speaker 1
12:53.26 – 12:55.94

You can find more of Layla's interview with Liz Cheney

12:55.94 – 12:58.26

on Morning Edition and at NPR.org.

13:04.58 – 13:07.14

And that's Up First for Monday, December 4th.

13:07.14 – 13:07.80

I'm Michelle Martin.

4Speaker 4
13:07.92 – 13:08.78

And I'm Steve Inskeep.

13:08.84 – 13:11.04

Today's Up First was edited by Michael Sullivan,

13:11.26 – 13:14.22

Krishnadev Kalamur, Reena Advani, and H.J. Mai.

13:14.54 – 13:18.14

It was produced by Lily Quiroz, Mansi Khurana, and Lindsay Totte.

13:18.34 – 13:20.42

We get engineering support from Stacey Abbott,

13:20.46 – 13:22.40

and our technical director is Zach Coleman.

13:22.40 – 13:23.24

Join us tomorrow.

1Speaker 1
13:23.74 – 13:24.80

And thanks for listening to Up First.

13:24.92 – 13:28.04

You can find more in-depth coverage of the stories we talked about today

13:28.04 – 13:30.54

and a lot more on NPR's Morning Edition.

13:30.70 – 13:34.28

That's the radio show that A. Martinez, Layla Fowler, Steve Inskeep, and I host.

13:34.86 – 13:39.40

Find Morning Edition on your local NPR station at stations.npr.org.

?Unknown Speaker
13:53.70 – 13:54.40

.

v1.0.0.260408-1-a910ba6_os