2023-09-25 01:01:32
Listening to America aims to “light out for the territories,” traveling less visited byways and taking time to see this immense, extraordinary country with fresh eyes while listening to the many voices of America’s past, present, and future. Led by noted historian and humanities scholar Clay Jenkinson, Listening to America travels the country’s less visited byways, from national parks and forests to historic sites to countless under-recognized rural and urban places. Through this exploration, Clay and team find and tell the overlooked historical and contemporary stories that shape America’s people and places. Visit our website at ltamerica.org.
Hello everyone, it's Clay Jenkinson with this podcast introduction to this week's program, How to be a Chautauquan. You know, I've done, I suppose, up to 15 Chautauquan characters over time. Six or seven of them are still in my basic repertoire.
I've been doing some Oppenheimer performances and want to do more because of the sensational film of Oppenheimer that Christopher Nolan produced this summer. So how do you? how do you work one of these up? How? what do you do? And I want you to know that. In our hour long conversation, Stephen Decrow of DeKalb, Illinois, and I, we never once mentioned costume. I've made a number of Chautauquan rules over a lifetime of performing.
And one of them is anyone who starts with the costume is going to be a terrible chautauquan. The costume is the last and least part of it. The most important thing is to understand the character, to try to suss out the mystery, to see what their basic view of life is, to be true to their view of life, it's not always pretty. An immense amount of reading, primary work, biographies, and actual works written by these historical figures.
And then secondary works, histories of that era, histories of American poetry, in the case of Steve's work. All those things are really important. Reading, and so you can read 10, 15, 20, 30 books just to get the background. To perform as Aaron Burr or Abigail Adams, or Elizabeth Cady Stanton or W.E..B du Bois. Then you have to turn it into something, a piece of performance art, and that's a whole different business.
And memorization, you know, memorization is always hard, It gets harder as you grow older, but you have to memorize some of the literature. You know, you can't paraphrase the Declaration of Independence, you can't paraphrase Meriwether Lewis's exaltation on leaving Fort Mandan and heading into the wilderness in April of 1805..
If you were doing Thoreau, you can't paraphrase the greatest passages in Walden. You have to memorize them. And then you have to be able to deliver them on stage, which is a very intimidating sort of thing to do anyway, and you have to deliver them organically. It can't be just a series of set pieces with continuity between them, it has to unfold in some logical and organic way. The audience has to be able to follow what you're trying to create.
Anyway, it's a really interesting conversation. I admire his work, he's a beautiful reader, actually, reciter of the poems. And I hadn't really thought about Rachel Lindsay for a very long time.
Now I will go back and read some of his poetry. He read a really extraordinary poem about Buffalo, which is on my mind because of the Great Ken Burns documentary on Buffalo that's premiering on PBS on the 16th of October. I'm in it, I don't know how much I'm in it. But I'm in the 32nd teaser. And I'm told by people who were in the editing booth that I'm in it quite a bit.
So I'm thrilled and honored, and humbled and delighted. I always worry, like, what did I say, what did I get wrong? what will I cringe at? Um, you know, your first desire is to be in it.
Your second desire is to be in it in a way that makes sense and not to say anything terrible. Uh, or something that would touch off controversy. As I once did in a Ken Burns film on Theodore Roosevelt by saying that he was a man who liked to kill things, which, of course, is 100 true. But the protectors of the flame don't like to think of their man, Theodore Roosevelt, in quite that way. So it's a wide ranging conversation about the preparation of Chautauqua characters. I recommend it. And one thing we did not get to talk about, which is important, is that it's a very different thing to talk about. Thomas Jefferson, or to be Thomas Jefferson, you know, it's easy to talk about things with our 21st century sensibility and our own sense of judgment, and so on.
But once you're in the character, then you have to try to think, well, what would he or she say on that occasion? How would Jefferson explain his ownership of enslaved people? I know what I think about it as a historian and humanities scholar. But to be Jefferson, it's one thing to talk about Lewis's Meriwether Lewis's mental fragility. It's quite another to be Meriwether Lewis.
And I think that's the real purpose of Chautauqua is that it dramatizes that, which we tend to look at from a kind of linear, Apollonian, left-brained way, analytical way, evaluative way. When it's actually a history, at its best, is a encounter with the past by way of a rigorous imagination. And so that's one of the reasons I think that the Chautauqua Forum is a valuable one. It can go wrong, and man, have I seen it go wrong? But when it's good, it really can light up a conversation about the past.
After the podcast ended, you know, we have to stay within the clock. We talked a little bit more, he wanted to talk a little bit about my book, The Language of Cottonwoods, and we talked a little bit about Spirit of Place. And so I'm going to include that now as sort of extra content here, and I'll come back for just a minute after that.
But I so much appreciate your listening. I hope you'll tell everyone you know if you can help us out in any way. We have five or six big initiatives, still need that ranch, still need some gas cards, etc. But let's first of all, let's listen to the conversation that occurred once the formal program on how to be a Chautauquan ended.
That was terrific, I hope you liked it.
Thank you. The only thing I wanted to do, one thing I wanted to get in, and I wasn't trying to ingratiate myself. To the host was your love song and the language of the Cottonwoods, your love song to Dakotas is so powerful. And there is that there's that section where you go back to your grandmother and grandfather's farm, and it is. It's so powerful and it's so moving. And it stands right up there in the pantheon of writing about place and why it's so critical and important.
I just, I wanted to say, people need to read this, people need to read this book.
It even Lindsay's gospel of beauty is really, in some ways, is talking about the seven points you have about, you know, the remedy. We need to really support artists, we need to write about North Dakota, we need to do art about it.
We need to get out into it. We need to take students out on buses to see North Dakota, feel the wind in the prairie and see these places. And and we need to get out into nature. I mean, that that is tied in with that, so Lindsay, and it's really, it's beautiful writing.
You should be, you should be so proud.
Well, you're very kind, I appreciate it. I loved writing the book. I do believe that spirit of place is everything you know when people say to me, Why would you live in North Dakota?
Which is a good question because North Dakota has become a hard read state. It's sort of Tucker Carlson's America now, or at least it pretends to be, and this really is disturbing to me.
I'm absolutely fine with conservative, even strong conservative, but I don't like angry grievance, rage, vendetta, conservative. Retribution, I guess, will be the key word in the future here. That really seems to me to be degrading to the human spirit. And I don't know where that came from, and I don't know how soon we're going to work it out of our system.
But we have got to.
So I believe in spirit of place, and so I moved here. Not for the politics, and not for the antique restaurants and theater, um, not for the vibrant book culture. I moved back to my home because I believe in the Great Plains, and I believe that, uh, that I am a child of the Great Plains. And that if I'm so glad I didn't, I wasn't born in Milwaukee or um, or, or Providence or Tampa. Because there's something about the Great Plains. That, uh, that evokes bison and Native Americans, and cottonwood trees and lazy rivers, and endless seas of grass, and, uh, a sense of of, of being swallowed up by the sheer immensity of America's grasslands.
And I absolutely love that, uh, but it comes at a price. Um, but I can't imagine my life without spirit of place, somewhere near the center of it. And I was hoping in that book to to evoke that in a number of different ways, so I appreciate that very much, Stephen.
So that was really kind of of of Stephen to say about my book. Uh, I've had several conversations in the past month of people that that found the book. Speak to them, even though they do not live on the Great Plains. But that, but somehow it, it, it gets close to the heart of of of rural America, the heartland. The way we're being abstracted and drawn away from, uh, land and spirit of place, uh, so fantastic, you know? Um, in every author's greatest dream is that somebody somewhere reads the book in the spirit that she wants it to be read in. And so when people do, better to have that comment than to sell 150 books that people are maybe going to glance into, and maybe not. So that was a delight.
So thanks to Stephen for bringing that up. This is a strange and wonderful time in my life. Uh, it's a it's a new era. I'm in the I'm in the last three innings of my life, let's put it that way.
And uh, but things are cracking and it's going to be an extraordinary few years. And, uh, and I want you along for the ride, so let's go to the show. Thanks for listening.
Hello everyone and welcome to this special edition of Listening to America with Clay Jenkinson. Today. The Chautauqua method I'm talking with Stephen Ducro of Dekalb, Illinois, about how you create a Chautauqua character by Chautauqua. I mean, a person who dresses up in costume and presents spontaneous monologue in character. In the character of Abraham Lincoln, or the character of Abigail Adams, or, in my case, Theodore Roosevelt, Thomas Jefferson and others.
And Steve, as I understand it, you've been involved in promoting the arts now for many, many years. You're now retired, and you've taken on the character of Carl Sandburg.
Yes, uh, two characters, uh, Vacha Lindsay, that I've been doing, the Illinois Prairie poet, and then lately, Carl Sandburg. so, uh, Sandburg is, uh, 50 there.
So, uh, you haven't done a performance yet, a public performance.
Well, actually, uh, I did a 20 minute performance at, uh, at the Kiwanis, that was my launching point.
What possessed you at some point in your career? To cross this boundary of? Not just talking about Vacha Lindsay or Carl Sandburg, or other poets, but to want to portray one or two of them?
I think there's a formula for this and it I can briefly outline, and then we can talk about them. But it, it's, it's words, it's place, it's the great characters, and it's story and art, and those four things are all bound together. And it starts really with the words, as Sandburg would say, wise, keen, beautiful words, Shakespeare words, words, words.
I think we hear those words when I first heard those words, and I first heard Lindsay's Gospel of beauty. Those words. I mean, they animate you, they get inside you, you, you, you have to say them, and you're almost, I don't know if you feel this way, you're almost possessed in that. You have to say them for other people because you believe in them so strongly that if since they've animated you, you feel that. If you stand in a public square, you say them to other people that it will animate them and move them forward toward whatever end. That is with making the democracy better, furthering the enlightenment, stopping, you know, uh, economic, uh forces and industrialization from rolling over. People. You feel like those words matter and they make a difference.
Sure, uh, but that doesn't mean you need to dress up as that character. You could be re giving talks where I'm going to recite several poems by Sandberg, maybe a few sonnets from Shakespeare, uh, an elegy by John Dunn. But. But you decided, in addition to that, to, in a sense, become those two characters. Why?
Well, I think you fall in love with them, you fall in love with their ideas. And, uh, it comes back to I, you know, I. I don't want to be like a, you know, a cover band where I'm dressing like Robert Plant. You need to, want to, you want to, you want to give the the appearance of in hint at what Lindsay is like and what Sandberg is like. And hopefully that adds to the words, it doesn't detract from it. Uh, so uh, that's I think it's adding a level of theatricality that hopefully enhances and does not detract from these words that you consider so critical.
Understood Are you a natural born performer?
Probably yes and no, because my training really is all informal. When I grew up, you saw these characters in the place that you lived, and you saw the way that you talk. They talked, and I was drawn to people who, like my history teachers, uh, uh, Mr. Zick and Mr. Belanger, they they performed the work.
Mr. Shannon, my English teacher. These words were alive with them, and they performed them, and they had timing, and they had comic timing, and they were passionate. And so you see that you see your uncle's telling stories in small towns, which I grew up in a small town, you hear these stories. And so that sense of theater, you know, sort of becomes you when you start to notice. Well, that was really funny. Or he paused just a little bit before they delivered that line.
And so you you begin to see these things and then hopefully use some of those tools. When, when you're in front of people and in trying to say these words that you hope will inspire them.
So you're Illinois, um, you know, you could be performing as Abraham Lincoln, you could be performing as Everett Dirksen. um, there are a range of historical characters that have a Illinois connection. And, of course, you don't have to stay within your lane.
You could be performing as Alexander Hamilton or Aaron Burr, um, or Gerald Ford for that matter, but you want to do poets, not historical figures per se.
No, I would, I would do historical figures, you know, I would do that. I find my my hands are full with these two, and, you know, I may do. Sandberg's Lincoln, but probably not as Lincoln, probably as Sandberg talking about Lincoln. Because, you know, he wrote, you know, in, Uh, he wrote more words that are in the Bible and more words, and Shakespeare wrote just about Lincoln alone. Uh, 10 volumes, isn't it?
It may be, it may be six. Um, I know it took him decades to write it, he started, Sandberg started writing out, he just wanted to write a children's book about Lincoln. And then suddenly he worked on The Prairie years, and then, and then he worked on, uh, you know, the four or five, six volumes of the War years.
And and he would say things like, Ain't it hell? The way the book walks up to you and makes you write it, you know? Because he was compelled and had to had to flesh out Lincoln because he felt he was so important. But, uh, Sandberg and Lindsay, now Aaron Burr would be, uh, would be interesting and fun, uh, and then you and Hal could mop the floor with me during some type of discussion.
I don't know. I think Burr was the cleverest of the three. He might not have been the most learned or the the the man of the greatest integrity of of the trio Hamilton, Jefferson and Burr, but Burr was an extremely clever and resourceful figure. So just now, when you were sort of talking about Sandberg's multi-volume Lincoln, you went into kind of a gruff, gravelly voice. Is that how he sounded?
He had that, he, he sort of had that soaring voice. It was he was Swedish and he was a lot of around, a lot of immigrants. So he picked up that language of place, that music of place, he was really attuned to that. He, I mean, he was. He was a prairie poet, and his whole, uh, driving force for poetry was that the American people were his subject and the vehicle, their language was his vehicle.
So he had that gruffness, he had, uh, a musicality about to, about the way he talked, and he had that Swedish and somewhat Irish, uh, flair. That was in his, you know, in his natural way of speaking.
Talking to Steven Ducro of DeKalb, Illinois, about Chautauqua characters, do we have audio of Sandberg?
Uh, yes, there's, uh, there's audio and video in that. Uh, he was on. At some point, his fame really grew. He was on the Ed Sullivan show writing, uh, you know, uh, speaking, Lincoln, he was on another show where, uh, he was writing, reciting a poem. And Gene Kelly was tap dancing around him. Uh, you know, so he was, uh, you know, on television and radio, he was, uh, quite, quite pronounced, so that, so that's, that's around, so you can hear him, and it's, boy, it's worth it.
Uh, it's worth hearing him read, He's, He is splendid and magnificent.
So I'm fortunate in that. We don't know what Thomas Jefferson sounded like, uh, or most of Meriwether Lewis or John Wesley Powell. Most of the characters that I've done, only two. Um, do we know what their voice quality was? One is Theodore Roosevelt, we have seven or eight sort of not very interesting, um audio clips of Theodore Roosevelt.
He in the 1912 Bull Moose campaign, he sat down with the new world of Uh, Phonograph and recorded a few campaign speeches. Um, but he lowered his voice and it doesn't really capture him. But we do know that much about him and we have many descriptions of how he talked. But I make almost no attempt to recreate the language. I come at it as a historian, as a humanity scholar, and I use the character sort of lightly, as a, as a delivery system for their outlook on the world and their ideas. But let's back up, Steven, I. When I met you again a couple of years ago, um, now in in your part of the world, I was doing a one man Shakespeare sort of thing.
Uh, and you announced that you were interested in doing Carl Sandburg and wondered if we could communicate about that. And I was, of course, glad to do that. So, let's start with Chautauqua 101. You, you chose this character, now what?
Well, you, you choose the character and then there becomes that research process and that, uh, you know, and wrestling, or Sandburg would say wrestling with the words. Uh, to get them in you, to feel them. So you can, uh, pick the material because there's so much material go over and, uh, learning that. And then again, I gave a bit of Sandburg's voice. But I think, you know, you have to be careful not to do a voice that that you want to give the flavor of somewhere between you and Sandburg. And then deliver, deliver that faithfully, somebody like Rachel Lindsay, It's not like there's people knocking on my door, you know, to, you know, to have me recite, Lindsay. But you try to go forth and you try to find platforms and places where where people will will allow you to perform these, these characters and say these words that are that are so important and are really bound up in place or spirit of place or place making cause.
That's, I think, what a lot of some of the characters you're talking about, but Sandburg and Lindsay, especially. They they were place mattered, place was democracy for them. That's what you want to be able to do is is get people excited about the words and about place.
You know, at one time, Rachel Lindsay was a household name throughout the Midwest, at least and beyond. He was one of America's most popular poets. For a time now, he's virtually forgotten, and I'm guessing the phone doesn't ring very often on that. Most Americans who had a literature course at some point in their life would recognize the name of Carl Sandburg.
Uh, they may not be able to do much. But, you know, whenever I go to Chicago, I automatically find myself saying, Chicago hog, butcher of the world, toolmaker, stacker of wheat. Um, you can't help it. It's, it's. It's his most recognizable single poem, because it's so, it's such an enormously insightful and beautiful evocation of Chicago. At a certain point in its history, it was a central place on the railroads.
It was one of the nation's great stockyards. It was a vibrant, kind of frontier, rough western city, in contrast to, say, Boston, Philadelphia and New York. And Carl Sandburg nailed it. But. But we have to take a break here in a minute. But, uh, you said research and then went straight on, Uh, you made it sound like that's a simple thing.
What do you have to do?
That is not a that's a life, that's a lifelong pursuit, really. Sometimes it's a lifelong pursuit. Just to go back and remember what you forgot about, the character and the date, and when it happened. No, that's that's a. I mean, that's jumping into the ocean and and immersing yourself in it for a long period of time.
So, Stephen, we need to take a short break when we come back. I want you to talk more about this research process and preparing a Chautauqua character. This is Listening to America with Clay Jenkinson. We'll be back in just a moment.
Welcome back to this special edition of Listening to America. I'm speaking with Stephen Ducro about how to create a historical character. I do eight or nine, I've done more in the course of my life, you do two.
You've come at it from a background in the arts, I come at it from a background in English literature and the humanities, so research. If I were going to start with Carl Sandburg, I would do the following. I would start by going to like Wikipedia or Britannica online and reading a simple three-page biographical sketch of the person of Sandburg. So that at least I knew when he was born and when he died, and so on. Um, I assume you do that, but you probably already were familiar enough with both Rachel Lindsay and Sandburg to not be starting from scratch.
But then what, how do you? How do you come to terms with the life of a complicated person like Carl Sandburg? What do you read?
People, it's lucky now that we can go to Wikipedia. Before you were knocking around in old bookstores, I remember going to cities and looking in the phone book and going and looking for old books. And now at least we have that, the ability to, you know, to find some of those, all of this material, you get anything you can for. For Lindsay, it was adventures while reach, while preaching the gospel of beauty, which is essentially what I.
Portray with Lindsay, the solo Penniless walks as a mendicant and beggar across the country. With the absurd notion of I'm not going to carry any money, I'm not going to carry any baggage. Except for my poems and the Gospel of Beauty and a few drawings. And I'm going to arrive on people's doors and saying, I'm the peddler of dreams. And if you allow me to recite tonight, I'll give you an, uh, a reading in exchange for food and lodging. And you know, if somebody did that today, they they'd arrest.
But, uh, so you start, you start reading the prose of them, if it exists. Adventures while preaching the gospel of beauty, a handy guide for beggars. You have his collected poems, you find his letters.
You start searching on a books for essays that have been written, you find dissertations and pull. But you're, you know, you're, you're constantly looking for this late at night, when, maybe when Netflix is on and you're just tired of your, you're on looking. It's like, Oh, there's a dissertation on on Lindsay. There's a book called The Other Sandberg where somebody's saying, Well, he was really a socialist, and boy, he was, you know, really radical. And nobody talks about that. This citizen, this beloved citizen, that's not who he was.
So you you begin to look at all these different sources, and I think you travel. I haven't traveled to Virginia. To see where Lindsay's maps and letters are. I do need to go to the University of Illinois. I don't know how to describe it.
It's just this ravenous, like, I know there's more. Maybe this history isn't complete, so maybe if, oh wait, this guy spoke at the Lindsay House in 1978, that pamphlet's not even around. Let me order that for $50, and then here's this promotional item that Lindsay is. 10. Lectures on cultural diversity delivered right after the race riots in 1908..
I got to get that. So you, you, you start just immersing yourself in finding all those sources, reading them and putting the story together.
Are you taking notes?
Uh, sometimes, uh, I find it helps, it helps to get these notebooks and and write things down and come back to them. And you were very helpful in suggesting, uh, you know? Come up with one page on these certain sections of a of a, uh, of a character and be able to review them. And going over them and putting together together. Sandburg That's, that's what I, that's what I've done is start to take his ideas about millionaires and definitions of poetry. And the people attacked him and put them onto succinct pages. So you can, you can kind of get the the essence of him.
When I started doing historical characters, let's just take Theodore Roosevelt, for example, one of my more recent characters. I start by creating a basic timeline of his life. Born 1858, died um January 6, 1919, 24th President of the United States, also New York City Police Commissioner, U.M. member of the U. S. Civil Service Board. UH, hunted in Africa 19 9, 19 10, Um explored one of the last unknown rivers in the Amazon Basin 1913 1914. Nearly died, lost a quarter of his body mass. So I, I start by making sure that I have, if someone asked me in an elevator, what should I? What do I need to know about Theodore Roosevelt?
I'd have a little biographical epitome and I write all that down, but that's the easy part. But I would try to cram into one page of typescript. Everything that you have to know, everything that's absolutely essential to know about that incident. So that two years from now, if someone calls and says, Oh, please come to DeKalb to, uh, to do a performance as Roosevelt, we want you to talk about the wildlife refuge system. On the plane, I can be paging through, I create these sort of, uh, notebooks that have the sort of glassine slots I can be paging through. Until I find the one pager, as I call it on the wildlife refuge system. And then I go over those facts, okay, that was 1903..
Uh, the attorney general was Philander Knox, uh, the first one was was in Florida, uh, there were 51 that followed. They weren't named wildlife refuges, they were called federal bird sanctuaries.
And all that data is on a single sheet. Which for Jefferson, uh, would also be the circumstances around which he wrote the Declaration of Independence in June and early July of 1776. But they helped me organize my thinking and and remind me that this is about story, these, this work is about stories, it's not about abstractions. Although there are some. And so I found that to be an extremely useful method for me. Not everybody would would would do it in the same way.
And, as you know, I'm militant about not having a memorized script.
Yes, very, very. It forces you to be concise, get, get the main facts together. I find once you get into this, you not only start to try to find out what Lindsay was like and Sandberg was like. But now that, now you, you know, when you do John Wesley Powell, now you find Gilpin, and then it's like, Well, what about him? or with Sandberg? Now? Now there's Edgar Lee Masters.
So now, now there's his relation, now there's William Butler Yates, you know, there's something with, there's a connection of Yates and Lindsay, and now there's Sandberg and Lindsay's. How did they get along? What letters are between them?
There's Lindsay and Hamlin, Garland, like Garland was a big supporter of of Lindsay. You know, you start to run into these other characters, so it just it just begins to grow and to grow and gets bigger and bigger. Which so, pulling it down to one page forces you to make some choices about material and get the stories because you're right. Uh, the trap is memorizing.
And it's also the hard part, cause you have to, you have to memorize some of it. It really is Randy Otto talked about. He does a churchill, a wonderful churchill, and talks about this wonderful encounter with Hal Holbrook, he said. You know, Hal said. It's the stories, like, you know, and it's transitions between that really, really matter.
Thank you, Randy for sharing that with me. But but that's it, it's it, it is story, cause all art is story.
Randy Otto as Winston Churchill There are a bunch of Churchills around. I haven't seen Randy's performance. I would like to, uh, there are lots of Lincolns, there are a number of Jeffersons.
There are plenty of Hamilton's now, uh, lots of Abigail Adams, Emily Dickinson's, you know, they're they sort of cluster and in a certain set of characters that are our household names. So I wouldn't take on a character like Rachel Lindsay today. Because the phone's not going to ring now, maybe it will ring a little bit more in Illinois than it would on the Great Plains. But but I. One of the first characters I ever did was Hamlin Garland.
I love him. He wrote one of the best autobiographies ever, Some of the Middle Border. His most famous book was Main Traveled Roads. He was a lover of the agrarian, was a big figure in the sort of era of Theodore Roosevelt, but he's utterly forgotten today, even on the Great Plains.
I try to get people to read some of the middle border. They just glare off into the distance. You need to choose somebody that people are going to be interested in. Back to method. So you've done all this reading?
How many books do you, would you say you have to read to become Carl Sandburg?
10 15.
I suppose somebody could do it in five. They could read Penelope Niven's biography of Sandburg and find it, but I don't. I don't think so. You got to read the letters.
You got to read the biographies, you've got to, you've got to fight.
And again, I'm just going through this very methodical approach to method. If you choose a historical character like Aaron Burr, if you look him up in Bartlett's quotations, there are almost no memorable Aaron Burr lines. So you can just paraphrase your way through Burr, quote him if you can. But only if it's worth it, only if it's so interesting that you couldn't paraphrase it.
So that's true of of some characters. If you do, Lincoln, you know, you better be able to. Quote from the Gettysburg address of the second inaugural address and the letter to the mother of the of the Fallen. Because otherwise, you're not going to be adequate if you choose a literary character, as you have done twice now. They have a huge body of poems and other writings, and you have to be able to not only memorize them, but master them so that you can perform them on stage. How many poems of Sandberg do you think you've memorized right now?
About 20, 20, and it's probably 25, but and I would say there's probably another 15 that are, what would I say, a 15 16ths in the bag. You know, it doesn't help you to drop a line on a poem, especially an important line. It's like, I know you got you got to work a little harder on that one. So I would say, you know, I think by the time I get done, it'll be 50..
It could, it could be more. Some of them are short fizag or primer lesson or losses. They're, you know, short poems, and then there's more challenging ones, like Chicago, which is a great poem. But, you know, there's a rhythm and A and a energy you need to bring to it, and it takes a while to learn and keep it fresh.
Don't you think sometimes you've done your, your work, your memorization, work on some things? And then you don't do it for a while? And then it's like, Oh, and I faster to learn it again, but you still have to stay on it.
I'll be on a plane and I'll be thinking, I'll be saying, All the world's a stage. All the men and women are the players. I'm just kind of mumbling to make sure I've got the language. And then then there's a performative aspect that happens when you're in front of a of an audience. How many Rachel Lindsay poems do you think you've memorized?
If you would ask me four years ago, I probably could have said 40.
And at one point, I if the Santa Fe Trail, I mean, is a very long poem, and at one point in my life I had it all. Not now. You just, you just can't stay on top of that much, you know that much, Lindsay.
There's cause, there's a lot, there's a lot of it.
So, give us a, if you can, a short Rachel Lindsay poem.
The flower-fed buffaloes of the spring.
In days of long ago ranged, where the locomotives sing, when the prairie flowers lie low, the tossing, blooming, perfumed grass was swept away by the wheat. Wheels and wheels and wheels spin by. In the spring that is still sweet, but the flower-fed buffaloes of the spring left us long ago. They gore no more.
They bellow no more, they trundle around the hills, no more, with the black feet lying low, with the pawnee lying low, lying low, lying low.
What an amazing moment of synchronicity this is. We're recording this on the last day of days of August 2023. I'm about to go to Greece with a cultural tour that I'm leading, Homeric Greece, when I come back. On October 16th, Ken Burns two-part documentary On the Buffalo will be aired on PBS. I'm in it.
I don't know how much I'm in it, but I've seen at least I'm in. The 30-second teaser that's being used on public television around the country. And I'm told by people from the inside that I'm in it quite a bit. And I put together a bibliography for books on Buffalo last night and about to post on my website. And I've been scouring my library, which is a mess, but I've been scouring it for books on Buffalo. So here you are.
I asked you to recite a poem. You could have recited one on Ghosts in a Cemetery or The Lost Love of a Maiden who died young. Instead. You, you, you did this poem about Buffalo, which really speaks to me, and so now I will go get that poem. And that's how it works.
I think, Steven, you know, when I was in college at the University of Minnesota, I had a professor named Arthur Geffen. He now lives in Greater Chicago. He's been retired for a long time. He was quite a character and he taught American literature. And one day in class, out of the blue, this was like a class in Melville, I think. Or Whitman.
He recited a sonnet by William Wordsworth that I that, in a sense, it changed my life. The world is too much with us late and soon getting and spending. We lay waste our power as little there is in nature that is ours. We have given our hearts away assorted boon and on and on. And when I heard it, I was mesmerized.
If he had read it, I would have been less so that he recited it, deepened it by magnitudes, and I was. I love the the the theme of the poem, which is that sort of. The scientific revolution and the enlightenment have basically squeezed the spiritual music out of the world and turned it into mere commodity. And and Wordsworth says at the end, Great God. I'd rather be a Pagan suckled in, a creed out worn, that he would, he'd like to. He'd like to jump over the whole Christian dispensation back into the Pagan world and hear old Triton blow his wreathed horn. And so that changed my life. I memorized that poem almost immediately.
I, I recite it when it's appropriate, a few times per year, I think that's how it works. And so you've made this poem on the Buffalo come to life for me. And I assume that if you're giving a performance in Aurora or, uh, Dekalb, uh, or, uh, Peoria, that somebody in that audience, it's going to hear. Something they never heard before and couldn't have had the same appreciation for if they saw it on a written page in a high school or college textbook, so that's the magic of oral traditions.
And, of course, we've lost them. And, frankly, most poets that I have ever heard in my life are terrible readers of their own poetry. I can't believe how poor readers they, generally speaking, are of their own work. You really gave that some drama. How and why do you know that?
That's how Lindsay would have done it.
Well, you know, there's a few recordings of Lindsay. And he revolutionized, I mean, he was the godfather of of spoken word. He. He was the first beat poet when he went out on the road in these solo walks. But they talk about Lindsay mesmerizing audiences. He shocked people with his his volume and his theatrics, and maybe sometimes he was over the top. But uh, so uh, there is a poem, there is Lindsay reading that poem.
And I'm kind of giving my own flavor. And the recordings of Lindsay, I don't think, do him justice, but he was a great reader. You should, you should listen to, go to Penn, Penn Archives or Penn Sound and listen to him read The Virginians are coming again. Uh, you know, or the Santa Fe Trail. You'll you really get the quirks of Lindsay in there. But I think it's diminished by 50. I think you have to, you got to listen to him and then add another 50 and and now now, you've got, now you have Lindsay.
So, but those it comes back to, those words get in you, you, you say them over and over again. I mean, it's you walk around with a book in your hand. Till you know them, and you're say them out loud in your home. And you know if people are looking in the windows, they're like.
Go, he really lives next to us because you have to say these words, you, you. You have so hearing that poem and being touched by it, you want to bring it to life and it, you're really animating the words. Uh, I think sometimes these poems by Sandberg and Lindsay, and even Jefferson's words, or Gouverneur Morris's words. We, the people, they're these sentinels, these silent sentinels that have been left somewhere. And they're activated when people read them, and if you read them in a public square to people, then you animate and activate these guardians. These words that are pushing us forward, not backwards.
We need to take another short break here. Um, this is a fascinating conversation about how the Chautauqua method works. I'm talking to Steven Ducro of DeKalb, Illinois, who portrays the now forgotten poet Rachel Lindsay. But that was quite a poem. And the somewhat better known poet Carl Sandberg, also one of the great biographers of, Uh, the 16th President, Abraham Lincoln. We'll be back in just a moment. This is listening to America.
Welcome back to Listening to America with Clay Jenkins. I'm talking with Steven Ducro of Dekalb, Illinois, performer of Chautauqua characters Carl Sandberg, and also the poet Rachel Lindsay, So back to Chautauqua 101. You read five, 10, 15 books, clearly you start to memorize, particularly if it's a poet. At some point. You have to outline, you know, so that sometimes I'm I'm at a rotary club and you've got 20 minutes.
Another time I've got an hour and a half, maybe you're in on a media call and you've got six minutes. So you have to ask yourself, what has to be in any Sandberg program? you cannot give a Sandberg program without what? So what would you say that is?
Well, Chicago, you definitely have to read that, since we were talking about the Buffalo and the Ken Burns film there. There are at least a couple of short Sandberg poems. That if you're going to talk about the Buffalo and place and the role of Native Americans, and the removal of the Buffalo. Like these are poems that you have to read. Because I think they capture the spirit and the the darkness, the beauty and the darkness that are all wound up in, you know, in that whole process.
So here's a bit more serendipity. You've got a couple of Sandberg Buffalo poems, give us one.
BuFFalo Dusk The Buffalo are gone, and those who saw the Buffaloes are gone, those who saw the Buffaloes. By the thousands. They're pawing the prairie sod into dust, with their hoofs, their great heads down, pawing on in a great pageant of dusk.
Those who saw the buffaloes are gone, and the buffaloes are gone.
Wonderful, wonderful poem. And there's one about a coin, about the Buffalo nickel.
Yeah, he writes. A. It's called a coin, and you can imagine someone holding up the Buffalo Nickel, which has a, you know, the black diamond buffalo on one side. And it has a composite of. I think it's two moons and iron tail of three chiefs that James Earl Frazier did. You could see this as a somebody saying, Oh, we did this tribute to you. So, uh, let's see if I got this one down.
It's called a coin. Your Western heads here cast on money. You are the two that faded away partners in mist lunging Buffalo shoulder lean Indian face.
We who come after where you have gone, salute your forms on the new nickel.
You are to us, the past runners on the prayer.
Goodbye.
So this one is not as good a poem as the other one, I don't think, but but it moves me, and I'll tell you why. In my most recent book, Uh, Language of Cottonwood Essays on the Future of North Dakota, I write about this. White civilization decided that free range bison were incompatible with its mission.
And so partly by policy, but mostly in sort of just a kind of cultural dynamism. We essentially exterminated the Buffalo, and at one point we were down to fewer than 500 on Earth. At the height of when Lewis and Clark came through, for example, there might've been as many as 50 million. We erased them, and now that they're gone, there's a nostalgic commemoration. Somehow, their nobility is in the loss, but we will ennoble them in their sense of tragic loss. I get it.
I like that icon. But it's also, in a sense, deeply offensive because it wants to lock a nostalgia in for a creature that came so close to extinction. That the gene pool has been an issue ever since. And so I love that theme, and I think Sandberg understands that, you know, he's not a New York poet, he's not a Los Angeles poet, he's a Midwestern poet, right?
Proudly, I was born on the prairie, and the milk of its wheat, and the red of its clover, and the eyes of its women. Gave me a song and a slogan. You know, he's him, and him and Lindsay when you read about Lindsay, the building of Springfield, how he, he boy. They were both about place. They were crusaders for beauty and place, especially the Midwest, and it's one of the things that they really were roundly chastised for. I like to say that Lindsay and Sandberg had two original sins.
One, they were born in the Midwest, and two they wanted to innovate. And in the literary world, that's original sin. But getting back to the Buffalo in the I just started reading the Beyond, the Hundredth Meridian and in the notes that Wallace Stegner has. He claims that in one of the books, they talk about measuring the tonnage of bones of buffaloes. And the estimate on the Santa Fe Railroad is the weight of the bones would have been 31 million buffalo removed from Kansas alone. Another gentleman talks about standing by the railroad tracks and seeing 12 foot high piles of bones going a half a mile in length.
So the you can't, even you can't even imagine this, but these poems help us get to this tragic loss, I think.
I agree with you. So not to get stuck on the bison, although with Ken Burns film coming, Oh, I know this Buffalo bill became the Buffalo Bill. There were several contenders by killing the most number of bison in a single day in Kansas, and it was over 400. And when you read that, you think, Oh, it reminds me of a line from King Lear as flies to wanton boys. So are we to the Gods? I mean, what kind of a civilization would kill 400 Buffalo in a single day as a kind of a parlor bet trick?
And yet we are that civilization, right?
Right, and you know Wynne Handman, the group, the legend of American theater, that everybody's seen Wynne's work, and the actors of Wynne. It just asked that central question, What? What kind of a man would do that? And so when you're talking about Chautauqua characters, what kind of a man walks penniless across the country, reading poems to people, what, you know? What kind of a man does it? What kind of a man shoots 400 buffaloes and says, Number one, I got it.
Unchallenged, I'm the dimaggio of shooting buffaloes.
These are very different things, of course, one is an act of of darkness and destruction and wantonness, and the other, uh, in the case of walking across the country. As a poetic mendicant, uh. This harkens back to to the world of Arabia and the homeric poems and the great oral traditions of the world. There's a nobility about it. I think it probably worked then, I don't think it would work today, because poetry has ceased to be central to American civilization.
You know, most people I meet, including highly educated people, say, I just don't get poetry, I can't do poetry. And so today I think Rachel Lindsay would have a would have a rough walk. I want to go back to Sandberg for a moment, so what everybody knows about Sandberg, who knows anything about Sandberg?
Is that he wrote this immense biography of Lincoln and that he wrote the fabulous poem Chicago? He was maybe a socialist, he was a reformist, he was a critic of American civilization, would have been seen in some circles as a radical.
True, uh, and as a socialist, what was he fighting for? He was fighting for better wages, safe work conditions, the end of child labor, eight hour work day, five day work week. You know, fair with that, everybody said, Well, he's a socialist, was like, but they're all embracing those things now. So, uh, at some point he quit the Socialist Party, uh, and became more mainstream. But those ideas, he, his poetry, was trying to give voice to the discarded and the voiceless.
He, uh, he believed in that, and he, he would say things like, And if I fail at this task, it's because I simply could not do any better. He wrote The Dago Shovel Man, which is like one of the first poems that takes an Italian immigrant and treats them seriously. And not not as a comic character. So, yeah, Sam Sandberg was invested in taking the common man. He said. Uh, to write about the lowly, you need to know the lowly.
I knew the lowly.
I think you told me when we were preparing for this program that you've given one performance of Sandberg to the Kiwanis club. How many gigs per year would you want to do?
You know, three 65 would be three 66 and leap year, you know, I'm saying that part partly lighthearted. You know? I would like to do 50, 75, I'd be satisfied with 25, but you know, I, I'd like. Just because the words need to be, they need to be heard, I'd be satisfied with that.
How many do you expect?
I don't expect that.
So you're not going to get 50 per year, I mean, I'm thinking you're going to get 12..
Yeah, I think you're right. Baker's Dozen 13..
Is it worth it? Is it worth it?
Absolutely, of course, of course, because, uh, at some point before we done, I, I do want to do a quick. I want to read and recite Rachel Lindsay's Gospel of beauty. Because I think you'd be interested in it, because it was his practical application of Jefferson.
Let's hear it all right?
The things most worthwhile are one's own hearth. In neighborhood, we should strive to make our own home and neighborhood the most beautiful, the most democratic, and the holiest in the world. The children growing up should become devout gardeners, or architects, or park architects, or teachers of dancing in the Greek spirit. Or musicians, or novelists, or poets, or story writers, or wood carvers, or actors, or singers, or dancers. They should find their own talent, and they should nurse it industriously. They must believe in every possible application of art theory to the thoughts of, well, the Declaration of Independence and Lincoln's Gettysburg address.
Oh, if led by the spirit, they should wander the whole nation in the search of the secret of democratic beauty. At the same time, with our hearts overflowing with the righteousness of God.
But then they should come home and they should come back to their own hearth in neighborhood, and they should gather a little circle of their own sort of workers about themselves. And strive to make the home and the neighborhood more beautiful and more democratic and more holy with their special art.
Gospel of Beauty by Rachel Lindsay.
I'm speaking with Steven Ducro of Illinois about the Chautauqua method and his own preparation now to do. CarL SandbUrg So let's say you have an hour long Sandburg performance in Peoria. What percentage of the performance will be recitation of Sandburg poems?
I think there'll probably be a dozen poems, but they'll be wound into a story. He'll start with saying, You know, I'll probably die propped up in bed trying to write a poem about America. And then he'll move through, talking about poetry and his journey and how hard it was, and how Chicago was first published. And, you know, the shocking harsh language at the time. And then he'll lead people on through Halstead, Streetcar. And a poem about a prostitute, a poem about the Dago Shovelman, a poem about the Muckers.
And then he'll go into story and he might start talking about millionaires. Millionaires who laugh are rare. He'll talk about Woolworth, and he'll talk about Bill Wrigley and Marshall Field. And then he'll morph into things about Hell, where he said, You know, Milton and Dante wrote about hell, never saw the place. I wrote about it after living for years and years in Chicago, you know? And then there'll be, you know, assort meditations, some poems on, you know, some of his stories. But it'll be probably a mix of 60 story, 70 story. And the poems will be in there to flavor, to illustrate, to help illustrate some of his points.
Will you take questions?
Absolutely, I, uh. The character interview as Wynne Hanman talks about the character interview that you throw yourself open to. God bless you for just standing in front of people and taking any question you can. And having to be able to recall all that I think, I think, is amazing, and you're doing it on eight characters, I'm doing it on two.
If you had to do a third character, who would it be?
It might be Burr, you know, I don't think I could do. You've piqued my interest on Eric Severide, he would be fascinating. I think I know there's others, I just can't think, I just can't think of them.
Of course, of course, I wish you luck with Eric Severide. He was once one of the central figures of American media life, now mostly forgotten.
He's from Velva, North Dakota, he's our favorite son, he's one of my heroes, and I try to shape my own life. As a public commentator on his capacity for fairness, open-mindedness, erudition, um, and clear commentary. But we can't finish this conversation without Chicago. So let her rip.
Let's let's hear Carl Sandburg's, in my opinion, most popular and probably greatest poem, Chicago.
Chicago.
Oh, butcher for the world, toolmaker, stacker of wheat, player with railroads and freight handler to the nation, stormy, husky, drawing city of the big shoulders. They tell me, you are wicked. My reply is yes. I have seen the painted women under the gas lamps luring the farm boys, and they tell me, you are crooked. And my answer is yes. I have seen the gunman kill and go free to kill again.
And they tell me that you are brutal. And my reply is on the faces of women and children, I have seen the marks of wanton hunger. And having answered. So, I turn to those, turn to those once more who sneer at this. My city, and I give them back the sneer. And I say, Come show me another city. With lifted head singing. So proud to be alive, so coarse, so strong, so cunning.
Here's a tall flinging, magnetic curses amid the toil of piling job on job. Oh, here's a tall, bold slugger. Set vivid against the little, soft cities. Fierce as a dog with tongue lapping for action, cunning as a savage, pitted against the wilderness, bare headed, shoveling, wrecking, planning, breaking, rebuilding. Under the smoke, dust all over his mouth, laughing with white teeth, under the terrible burden of destiny. Laughing as a young man, laughs, laughing even as an ignorant fighter, laughs who's never lost a battle, bragging and laughing. That under his wrist is the pulse, and under his ribs is the heart of the people. Laughing, laughing, the stormy, husky, brawling laughter of youth.
Bare headed, shoveling, half naked, proud to be hog butcher, tool maker, stacker of wheat, player with railroads and freight handler to the nation.
What a magnificent poem, darker than I remembered, so energetic, so dynamic in Chicago of that era. Unfortunately, we're out of time. StepHen DuCRO, Thank you. I want to see one of your Sandberg performances.
I am coming your way in November to get back on stage with my friend John Williams. I hope to see you there. If you do. Aaron Burr, you know how to find me. We'll get you on this program again and again. So thanks for your time today to all of you.
We'll see you next week for another important edition of Listening to America with Clay Jenkinson. Thanks for listening.
v1.0.0.260408-1-a910ba6_os